Retail business owners face more technology choices than ever before, and picking the wrong POS system can cost thousands in lost sales and operational headaches. With consumer expectations at an all-time high and competition fiercer than ever in 2025, retailers need technology that works flawlessly during peak shopping periods like Black Friday or holiday rushes. Vend POS (now operating under the Lightspeed Retail brand) and Square POS represent two fundamentally different approaches to retail management, each built with distinct business models in mind.
The importance of choosing the right POS system cannot be overstated in 2025’s competitive retail environment. A system that aligns with your specific requirements can transform how you operate, while the wrong choice can lead to unnecessary expenses, workflow disruptions, and missed opportunities for business optimization. Modern retailers need solutions that handle everything from basic transaction processing to complex inventory management, customer relationship building, and omnichannel selling capabilities.
Vend established itself as a retail-specific solution with comprehensive inventory management capabilities, making it particularly attractive to established retailers with complex stock requirements. Square gained popularity for its accessibility and versatility across various business types, offering an integrated ecosystem that handles payments, online selling, and business management from a single platform. Understanding these fundamental differences helps retailers make informed decisions about which platform better serves their specific operational needs.
Both systems have evolved significantly since their initial launches, with Vend becoming part of the Lightspeed ecosystem and Square expanding its feature set to compete with specialized retail solutions. These developments have created more overlap between the platforms while maintaining their distinct strengths and target markets.
When evaluating POS systems, pricing often becomes a decisive factor for small to medium-sized businesses. Vend POS starts at $99 per month (or $119 if billed monthly), which is significantly higher than Square’s basic free plan. This price difference immediately positions Square as more accessible for startups and smaller retailers with limited budgets. Vend’s Lite plan comes with restrictions, including a $20,000 monthly turnover limit and single-outlet capability, forcing businesses to upgrade to the Pro plan at $129 per month ($159 monthly billing) once they exceed these thresholds.
Square’s pricing model operates differently, with a free basic plan and transaction fees starting from 2.6% + 10¢ for in-person payments. For businesses seeking advanced features, Square offers a Plus plan at approximately $60 per month per location. This tiered approach allows retailers to start with minimal investment and scale up as needed. While Square’s transaction fees are slightly higher than some competitors, the absence of monthly fees for basic functionality creates an attractive value proposition for businesses with lower transaction volumes.
Hardware costs also factor into the overall investment equation. Square provides a free basic magstripe reader upon signup, with more advanced hardware available starting at $49. Vend requires compatible hardware that often represents a more substantial investment, though they offer flexibility to use existing equipment if compatible. Additionally, Square has no turnover limits on any plan, whereas Vend restricts users to $25,000 monthly turnover on their Lite plan—a crucial consideration for growing businesses.
For established businesses with higher transaction volumes, Vend’s flat monthly fee without per-transaction charges could potentially offer better value, assuming they’re already exceeding the Lite plan’s turnover limits. However, for new retailers or those with seasonal fluctuations, Square’s pay-as-you-go model presents lower financial risk and greater flexibility in managing operational costs.
Both Vend and Square offer comprehensive feature sets, but they excel in different areas of retail management. Vend POS was designed specifically for retail environments, and this specialization shows in its robust inventory management capabilities. Vend allows for detailed product management with support for variants, composite products, and supplier management. Its inventory control features include stock transfers between locations, purchase order management, and automatic reordering. These retail-specific functions give Vend an edge for businesses with complex inventory needs.
Square, while offering solid inventory tools, delivers exceptional versatility across business types. Its strengths lie in its intuitive interface, seamless payment processing, and integrated business ecosystem. Square’s feature set includes appointment scheduling, online selling capabilities, digital receipts, and customer feedback collection—all accessible through a unified platform. Square also excels at providing real-time analytics and reporting tools that offer actionable business insights without requiring additional integrations.
For customer management, both systems offer robust capabilities with different approaches. Vend provides comprehensive customer profiles with purchase histories, loyalty programs, and custom fields. Square similarly tracks customer information and purchase patterns while offering marketing tools like email campaigns and loyalty programs. However, Vend’s loyalty features are generally considered more advanced, particularly for retail-specific applications requiring detailed customer segmentation and reward customization.
Where Square gains significant advantage is in its native eCommerce capabilities. While Vend requires third-party integrations for online selling, Square offers built-in online store functionality, social media selling, and multi-channel inventory management. This integrated approach simplifies operations for retailers looking to maintain consistent inventory and customer experiences across physical and digital channels without managing multiple software platforms.
While traditional POS systems like Vend and Square serve retail environments well, restaurants face unique operational challenges that require specialized solutions. The restaurant industry demands immediate response capabilities, menu-specific ordering systems, and seamless integration with kitchen operations—areas where general retail POS systems often fall short. Restaurant owners frequently struggle with missed calls during peak hours, inconsistent order taking, and the challenge of maintaining service quality while managing costs.
Loman addresses these specific restaurant pain points through its AI for restaurants platform, offering a 24/7 AI phone agent that never misses calls or takes breaks. This specialized solution integrates seamlessly with existing POS systems like Square, Toast, and Clover, while being trained specifically on restaurant menus, policies, and customer preferences for accuracy. Unlike general retail POS systems that treat all businesses similarly, Loman reduces missed calls, shortens wait times, and improves sales through its restaurant-focused approach with built-in analytics and real-time insights for better decision-making. The platform offers fast setup (live in under a day) and scales efficiently for single locations, chains, or franchises—providing the specialized restaurant functionality that platforms like Vend and Square can’t match despite their strengths in general retail operations.
Hardware flexibility represents a significant point of differentiation between Vend and Square. Vend operates as a web-based POS system compatible with iPad, Mac, and PC devices, offering businesses versatility in their hardware choices. This cross-platform compatibility allows retailers to leverage existing equipment, potentially reducing implementation costs. Vend works with a variety of third-party hardware components including receipt printers, barcode scanners, and cash drawers from multiple manufacturers.
Square takes a more controlled approach to hardware integration. While the basic Square Point of Sale app functions on both iOS and Android devices, Square’s proprietary hardware ecosystem—including the Square Stand, Square Terminal, and Square Register—provides the most seamless experience. Square’s first-party hardware comes with a two-year warranty compared to typical one-year warranties from other providers, representing better value protection for your investment.
Regarding peripheral compatibility, Square’s ecosystem works best with Square-approved devices, though it supports certain third-party accessories. Vend offers greater flexibility, working with a wider range of hardware peripherals from various manufacturers. This difference becomes important for businesses with existing hardware investments or specific peripheral requirements that might not be available in Square’s more limited ecosystem.
For mobility considerations, both systems perform well but with different approaches to portability. Square originated as a mobile solution and maintains excellent portability with compact card readers and tablet compatibility. Vend offers mobility through its iPad app but generally functions best in fixed-location retail environments. Square’s mobile focus makes it particularly suitable for businesses requiring on-the-go transactions, pop-up shops, or market stalls where traditional fixed hardware isn’t practical.
Payment processing flexibility constitutes a fundamental difference between Vend and Square’s business models. Vend operates as an open platform, allowing integration with multiple payment processors including Square, Tyro, WorldPay, PayPal, and others. This processor-agnostic approach enables retailers to shop around for the best processing rates or maintain existing processor relationships. For businesses processing large transaction volumes, this flexibility could translate to significant savings over time.
Square functions as an all-in-one solution with integrated payment processing. While convenient, this closed ecosystem means businesses must use Square’s payment processing service exclusively. Square’s processing rates start at 2.6% + 10¢ for in-person transactions and 2.9% + 30¢ for online payments. These rates remain consistent regardless of card type or transaction volume, creating pricing predictability but potentially higher costs for businesses qualifying for lower rates with traditional processors.
For international businesses, Vend offers greater payment flexibility with support for multiple currencies and region-specific payment methods. Square, while expanding internationally, still maintains more limited global payment options. Vend’s ability to work with region-specific payment providers gives it an advantage for businesses operating across multiple countries or those planning international expansion.
Payment security represents another crucial consideration for modern retailers. Both systems maintain PCI compliance, but their approaches differ significantly. Square absorbs much of the compliance burden through its integrated system, simplifying security management for merchants. Vend requires adherence to PCI standards in conjunction with your chosen payment processor, potentially creating additional compliance responsibilities but offering more control over security implementations.
In today’s omnichannel retail environment, seamless eCommerce integration has become essential for most retailers. Square and Vend offer distinctly different approaches to online selling capabilities. Square provides a native, fully integrated online store solution that synchronizes automatically with in-store inventory and the POS system. This built-in functionality allows merchants to launch an online presence with minimal technical expertise, manage all sales channels from a single dashboard, and maintain consistent inventory across physical and digital touchpoints.
Vend takes a different approach, requiring third-party eCommerce integrations to establish online selling capabilities. The platform offers direct integrations with major eCommerce platforms including Shopify, WooCommerce, and BigCommerce. While this approach provides flexibility to choose specialized eCommerce solutions, it introduces additional complexity and costs. Importantly, Vend requires the Pro plan ($129/month) for any eCommerce integration, making online selling impossible on their entry-level Lite plan.
Multi-channel selling capabilities differ significantly between the platforms in terms of ease of implementation. Square easily facilitates selling across various channels including social media platforms like Instagram and Facebook, online marketplaces, and through QR codes—all managed from a single interface. Vend requires separate integrations for each sales channel, potentially creating more complex workflows for businesses selling across multiple platforms but offering more customization options for each channel.
Order fulfillment features also distinguish the systems in practical daily operations. Square offers integrated shipping tools with discounted rates, local delivery options, and in-store pickup capabilities as standard features. Vend provides similar functionality but typically requires either the Pro plan or additional third-party integrations to enable comprehensive order fulfillment options. For retailers prioritizing an omnichannel strategy with minimal implementation complexity, Square’s integrated approach offers distinct advantages despite Vend’s potentially more customizable options for specialized requirements.
The ability to connect with complementary business systems can significantly extend a POS platform’s functionality beyond basic transaction processing. Vend and Square take different approaches to their integration ecosystems, each with distinct advantages for different business types. Vend offers extensive third-party integrations, particularly on its Pro plan, connecting with:
Square similarly offers a robust app marketplace with numerous integration options, but takes a more unified approach by providing native functionality for many business needs. Square’s ecosystem includes first-party solutions for payroll, team management, marketing, banking, and online selling—all designed to work seamlessly together. This integrated approach reduces the need for third-party connections while simplifying data flow between business functions.
For accounting integrations—crucial for most retailers—both systems connect with major accounting platforms, though Vend’s accounting connections are generally considered more comprehensive, particularly for complex retail operations. Square’s accounting integrations, while functional, sometimes require additional configuration to handle specialized retail accounting needs such as consignment tracking or complex cost-of-goods calculations.
API access represents another consideration for businesses requiring custom integrations or specialized functionality. Vend provides API access on its Pro plan, enabling custom development for specific business requirements. Square similarly offers API access, though some advanced functionality may require higher-tier plans. For businesses with unique operational requirements necessitating custom software development, API accessibility becomes particularly important for long-term scalability and operational efficiency.
When evaluating the total cost of ownership for POS systems, businesses must consider not just monthly subscription fees but also transaction costs, hardware investments, and integration expenses. Vend’s pricing structure favors established businesses with predictable monthly revenues, as their flat monthly fee ($99-$129) eliminates per-transaction charges that can accumulate significantly for high-volume retailers. However, this model requires upfront financial commitment regardless of actual sales performance.
Square’s transaction-based model (2.6% + 10¢ for in-person transactions) aligns costs directly with revenue, making it attractive for new businesses or those with seasonal fluctuations. For a business processing $10,000 monthly in credit card sales, Square’s fees would total approximately $260, compared to Vend’s $99-$129 monthly subscription plus whatever their chosen payment processor charges. The break-even point varies based on transaction volume and the specific payment processor rates available through Vend’s platform.
Additional cost considerations include:
For businesses planning rapid growth, Square’s scalable pricing model reduces financial risk during uncertain periods, while Vend’s feature-rich Pro plan may provide better value once transaction volumes consistently exceed certain thresholds. Understanding your current transaction patterns and growth projections helps determine which pricing model offers better long-term value for your specific situation.
User experience significantly impacts POS system adoption and daily operational efficiency across different retail environments. Vend POS offers an intuitive interface designed specifically for retail environments, with a checkout screen that resembles traditional register layouts, making it immediately familiar to retail staff. The system provides customizable quick keys, product search capabilities, and streamlined checkout processes optimized for retail scenarios. While Vend’s dashboard organization could be more intuitive in some areas, its overall design reflects a deep understanding of retail workflows and inventory management needs.
Square emphasizes simplicity and accessibility across its interface, requiring minimal training and making it ideal for businesses with high staff turnover or those seeking rapid implementation. Square’s dashboard provides clear analytics visualizations and straightforward navigation between features. Its minimalist design prioritizes essential functions while maintaining comprehensive capabilities beneath the surface. For businesses valuing immediate usability over specialized retail functionality, Square’s approach offers distinct advantages in terms of staff adoption and reduced training requirements.
Customer support experiences vary between the platforms based on subscription levels and support channel preferences. Vend provides round-the-clock support via email, live chat, and phone for all subscription levels, with their extensive online knowledge base and community forums supplementing direct support options. User reviews generally indicate positive experiences with Vend’s support team, though some mention occasional response delays during peak periods, particularly for technical integration questions.
Square similarly offers 24/7 support, though phone support accessibility varies by plan level. Their help center provides comprehensive documentation, video tutorials, and troubleshooting guides that often resolve common issues without requiring direct contact. Square’s large user community also creates informal support networks through active forums and discussion groups. Some users report challenges reaching live support representatives during high-volume periods, though email support generally receives positive feedback for response quality and technical accuracy.
After examining the comprehensive features, pricing structures, and capabilities of both Vend POS and Square, it becomes evident that each system excels in different retail scenarios. The optimal choice depends largely on your specific business requirements, growth trajectory, and operational priorities. Vend POS, now rebranded as Lightspeed Retail, offers a specialized retail solution with robust inventory management, detailed reporting, and flexibility in payment processing options that make it particularly suitable for established retailers with complex inventories, multiple locations, or specific hardware preferences.
Square presents a more accessible, integrated ecosystem with seamless payment processing, built-in eCommerce capabilities, and minimal upfront costs. Its intuitive design and versatile functionality make it ideal for new retailers, businesses with simpler inventory needs, or those requiring mobility in their operations. Square’s unified approach to business management—combining POS, payments, online selling, and marketing in one platform—offers compelling advantages for businesses seeking operational simplicity over specialized functionality.
For retailers prioritizing cost considerations, Square’s free entry-level plan with pay-as-you-go processing presents lower financial risk, particularly for businesses with seasonal fluctuations or uncertain growth trajectories. Vend’s subscription model offers potential savings for high-volume merchants but requires a more substantial initial commitment that may not suit all business situations. Hardware flexibility represents another key consideration—Vend accommodates diverse equipment preferences while Square offers a more standardized but seamlessly integrated hardware ecosystem.
When making your final decision, consider conducting a trial of both systems to evaluate real-world performance in your specific retail environment. Both Vend and Square offer free trial periods that allow you to test core functionality without financial commitment. Additionally, assess your long-term business roadmap—including planned expansion, eCommerce integration needs, and inventory complexity—to ensure your chosen system can scale appropriately with your business growth and evolving operational requirements.
Looking ahead to 2025 and beyond, the retail technology landscape continues evolving rapidly, with AI-powered solutions, enhanced mobile capabilities, and improved integration options becoming standard expectations rather than premium features. Whether you choose Vend’s specialized retail focus or Square’s integrated ecosystem approach, both platforms offer solid foundations for modern retail operations. For restaurants and food service businesses specifically, consider exploring specialized solutions like Loman’s AI-powered phone agents that integrate seamlessly with existing POS systems to handle the unique challenges of food service operations, offering fast implementation and scalable solutions for single locations, chains, or franchises seeking improved efficiency and enhanced customer experience.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
