Selecting the ideal point of sale system represents one of the most strategic decisions restaurant owners face when establishing or upgrading their operations. The technology powering your restaurant directly influences efficiency, customer satisfaction, and ultimately, profitability. Among the restaurant POS market leaders, Upserve POS (now Lightspeed Restaurant U-Series) and Toast POS consistently emerge as top choices for operators across various industry segments. Both platforms offer specialized features designed for food service businesses, yet they differ in important ways that could make one better suited for your specific operation.
Both Upserve and Toast POS deliver comprehensive functionality specifically engineered for restaurant operations, though they emphasize different aspects of the management experience. Upserve, now operating as Lightspeed Restaurant U-Series following its acquisition, prioritizes data analytics and guest relationship management above all else. The platform excels at tracking customer spending patterns, identifying your most valuable patrons, and providing actionable insights about menu performance. Its menu intelligence feature specifically helps restaurants understand which items drive repeat business versus items that are merely popular but don’t create customer loyalty.
Toast POS has built its reputation on operational efficiency and seamless front-of-house management capabilities. Its tableside ordering capabilities using handheld devices consistently receive praise from users for improving table turn times and increasing server efficiency. Toast pioneered mobile POS technology in restaurants and continues leading with innovations like QR code payment options allowing customers to pay directly from smartphones. The system also features a robust kitchen display system that improves ticket times and coordination between front and back of house operations.
Both systems offer standard POS features including check splitting, customizable floor plans, inventory management, and employee scheduling, though their implementations differ in ways that might better suit different operational styles. Toast particularly shines with its dynamic pricing optimization features that use AI to adjust pricing based on demand and market factors.
The user interface significantly impacts staff adoption and daily efficiency with any technology solution. Upserve POS is widely recognized for its intuitive, easy-to-learn interface that requires minimal training for new staff members. The system was designed with input from restaurant industry professionals, which shows in its workflow that mirrors natural restaurant service patterns. Servers particularly appreciate Upserve’s split check functionality, allowing effortless division of checks and items between multiple payment methods.
Toast POS also offers a user-friendly interface, though it generally requires slightly more initial training than Upserve. However, many restaurants find this investment pays off with Toast’s extensive customization options. The interface can be tailored to match specific restaurant workflows, proving particularly valuable for establishments with unique service models or complex menu structures. Both systems feature offline modes that allow operations to continue during internet outages, though Toast’s functionality is somewhat more limited in offline mode.
For table service restaurants, both systems offer strong table management features, but Toast’s visual layout and drag-and-drop functionality typically receives higher marks from users managing complex dining rooms with frequent table combinations. The training mode feature enables new employees to practice using either system without affecting actual restaurant operations.
Restaurant owners seeking a competitive edge need advanced communication solutions that integrate seamlessly with their existing POS systems. Loman’s revolutionary AI for restaurants platform operates as a 24/7 phone agent specifically designed for food service businesses, handling customer calls with the intelligence of your best staff member. The system integrates directly with popular POS platforms like Square, Toast, and Clover, creating a unified communication and ordering ecosystem that reduces missed calls and captures more revenue opportunities.
Unlike general POS solutions that focus primarily on in-store operations, Loman specializes in the critical gap most restaurants face with phone-based orders and inquiries. The AI agent is trained on your specific menu, policies, and customer preferences, ensuring accurate order taking and consistent customer service even during peak hours. This specialized approach dramatically reduces wait times, eliminates missed calls that cost revenue, and frees up staff to focus on in-person customer service. The platform also provides built-in analytics and real-time insights that help owners understand call patterns, popular menu items, and customer preferences.
What sets Loman apart from traditional POS solutions like Upserve and Toast is its lightning-fast implementation and scalability. Restaurants can go live in under a day without complex hardware installations or extensive staff training. Whether you operate a single location or manage multiple establishments, Loman scales effortlessly while providing the specialized restaurant communication features that general POS systems often lack. This focused approach to phone-based customer interactions complements rather than replaces your existing POS system, creating a comprehensive technology stack that addresses every customer touchpoint.
Hardware requirements represent a significant consideration affecting both upfront costs and long-term flexibility. Upserve POS offers compatibility with both iOS and Android devices, providing restaurants with more flexibility in hardware selection. This cross-platform compatibility allows businesses to leverage existing tablets or choose from a wider range of hardware options based on preference and budget. Upserve’s hardware is generally regarded as durable and restaurant-ready, with options including stationary terminals, handheld devices for tableside service, kitchen display systems, and various peripheral devices.
Toast POS operates exclusively on Android devices, which presents both advantages and limitations. The Android-only approach typically results in lower hardware costs compared to iOS-based systems, but restricts flexibility for restaurants preferring Apple products. Toast manufactures its own proprietary hardware, including Toast Go handheld devices specifically designed for restaurant environments with features like extended battery life and spill resistance. This dedicated hardware approach ensures seamless integration but locks restaurants into Toast’s ecosystem.
Understanding the complete cost structure remains essential for accurate budgeting and determining long-term value. Both systems operate on subscription-based models with tiered pricing plans, but their approaches differ significantly. Upserve starts at approximately $89 per month for the Starter plan, with additional terminal fees applying. Toast’s pricing begins around $69 per month per terminal, with their Core plan including essential POS functionality. Additional features like online ordering, loyalty programs, and inventory management are available as add-ons, which can significantly increase monthly costs.
A POS system’s ability to integrate with other business tools significantly impacts its long-term value and adaptability. Both Upserve and Toast have developed extensive integration ecosystems, though with different partnership approaches. Upserve offers integration with a wide range of third-party applications covering areas like accounting (QuickBooks, Xero), inventory management, employee scheduling (7shifts, Homebase), and reservation systems (OpenTable, Resy). This open approach allows restaurants to continue using preferred tools while gaining benefits of data synchronization across platforms.
Toast has developed a more controlled but comprehensive ecosystem through its Toast Partner Connect program. This approach emphasizes deeply integrated partnerships with selected vendors rather than broader compatibility. Toast’s integrations span similar categories as Upserve’s but often feature more seamless connections with fewer configuration requirements. Key integration categories include:
Both systems offer APIs for custom integrations, though Toast’s developer resources are generally considered more extensive. For restaurants with existing technology infrastructure, Upserve may offer more flexibility in maintaining those investments. However, restaurants building their technology stack from scratch might benefit from Toast’s more curated ecosystem.
Data-driven decision making has become increasingly important in restaurant management, and both systems offer robust analytics with different approaches and strengths. Upserve POS has built its reputation largely on superior analytics capabilities. The platform provides detailed insights into menu performance, showing not just which items sell best but which items drive repeat business. Its Server Performance feature analyzes individual staff members’ sales patterns, identifying strengths and coaching opportunities.
Upserve’s Guest Book functionality tracks customer visit history and spending patterns, enabling personalized service and targeted marketing efforts. The system can flag menu items as “greatest hits,” “one-hit wonders,” or “underperformers,” providing staff with real-time information for recommendations and upselling strategies. This data-driven approach makes Upserve particularly valuable for restaurants focused on building regular clientele.
Toast POS offers comprehensive reporting with particular strength in operational analytics. Key reporting features include:
Both systems provide mobile access to reports, allowing owners and managers to stay connected to business performance remotely. For restaurants primarily seeking deep customer insights and relationship management tools, Upserve’s analytics generally receive higher marks. However, for operations focused on tight cost control and efficiency metrics, Toast’s reporting suite may provide more actionable operational data.
Understanding total cost of ownership requires careful evaluation of monthly software fees, payment processing costs, hardware expenses, and implementation charges. Both systems require payment processing through their platforms, with Upserve charging approximately 2.6% plus $0.10 per transaction, comparable to Toast’s processing fees. A key distinction is Toast’s flexibility with hardware implementation options, including starter kits with 0% financing, which can reduce initial capital expenditure.
For Upserve, the Professional plan includes more advanced features though pricing requires custom quotes. Enterprise-level implementations can reach up to $399 per month depending on specific requirements and location count. Toast’s add-on structure allows restaurants to customize their feature set but can lead to significantly higher monthly costs as additional modules are added.
Restaurant operators should carefully evaluate which features are essential versus nice-to-have when comparing total costs. Both systems offer scalable pricing that grows with business needs, but the specific feature requirements of your operation will largely determine which platform offers better long-term value.
The quality of customer support and implementation services dramatically impacts a restaurant’s experience with their POS system, particularly during critical initial deployment phases. Upserve offers 24/7/365 customer support with representatives specifically trained in restaurant operations. Their onboarding process typically includes personalized setup assistance, menu building help, and comprehensive training for management and staff. Many users specifically praise Upserve’s responsive support team, noting availability of both phone and email channels.
Toast similarly provides 24/7 support across multiple channels, including phone, email, and chat. Their implementation approach tends to be more structured, with dedicated project managers assigned to guide restaurants through deployment processes. Toast places particular emphasis on in-person training, with options for on-site sessions conducted by Toast specialists. Both companies offer remote installation services, though Toast has developed a larger network of local representatives in major markets.
For restaurants with limited technical expertise or those undergoing complex implementations, Toast’s more hands-on approach may provide greater value. However, restaurants seeking more self-directed implementation with responsive backup support might prefer Upserve’s model. Both systems include extensive knowledge bases and training videos for self-guided learning and ongoing education.
With dramatic growth in off-premise dining, robust online ordering capabilities have become essential for most restaurants. Toast POS offers a particularly strong native online ordering system that integrates seamlessly with its POS platform. This integration eliminates the need for separate tablets or manual order entry that many third-party delivery platforms require. Toast’s online ordering system allows customers to place orders directly through restaurant websites, with orders automatically appearing in kitchens without staff intervention.
The system also features delivery management tools, including delivery zone configuration, driver assignment, and real-time delivery tracking. Toast has developed particularly strong partnerships with delivery providers, allowing for seamless menu synchronization and order injection directly into the POS. This comprehensive approach makes Toast typically better suited for restaurants heavily focused on takeout and delivery business.
Upserve also provides integrated online ordering capabilities, though historically its implementation has received more mixed reviews than Toast’s solution. However, since being acquired by Lightspeed, Upserve’s online ordering features have seen significant improvements. Both systems offer integration with major third-party delivery platforms like DoorDash, Grubhub, and Uber Eats, though the depth of these integrations varies considerably.
After examining both systems across all major functionality and service aspects, it’s clear that Upserve and Toast offer robust restaurant management solutions with distinct strengths making each better suited to different operation types. Upserve POS (Lightspeed Restaurant U-Series) stands out for superior analytics capabilities, customer relationship management tools, and an intuitive interface requiring minimal training. It particularly excels for full-service restaurants focused on building regular clientele and maximizing customer lifetime value through data-driven insights.
Toast POS distinguishes itself through operational efficiency, comprehensive online ordering capabilities, and excellent tableside service features. Its hardware durability and purpose-built design for restaurant environments make it particularly well-suited for high-volume operations where speed and reliability are paramount. Multi-location restaurant groups often prefer Toast for its strong enterprise-level features and centralized management capabilities that scale effectively across multiple properties.
The best choice ultimately depends on your specific business priorities, operational model, and growth plans. Both systems continue evolving rapidly with regular feature updates and improvements. Restaurant operators should consider arranging demonstrations of both platforms, ideally involving key staff members who will use the system daily, before making final decisions. The right POS system should not only meet current needs but provide a scalable platform that grows with your business for years to come.
Whether you choose Upserve’s analytics-focused approach or Toast’s operational efficiency emphasis, Loman’s specialized restaurant communication platform integrates seamlessly with both systems to handle the critical phone-based customer interactions that drive revenue. With setup completed in under a day and scalability for single locations through large franchise operations, Loman ensures your restaurant captures every customer opportunity while your staff focuses on delivering exceptional in-person experiences.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
