In today’s fast-paced restaurant industry, choosing the right point-of-sale (POS) system is one of the most impactful decisions owners will make. Toast and Upserve (now Lightspeed Restaurant U-Series) lead the market with robust solutions tailored for food service operations. Both streamline day-to-day processes, improve customer experiences, and deliver valuable business insights, but their distinct approaches and feature sets make them stand apart.
Toast’s reputation as a restaurant-first platform is supported by its Android-based system and extensive toolset built specifically for dining establishments. The company focuses on restaurant-specific needs, prioritizing efficient workflows and seamless technology integration. Upserve, launched in 2009 and now part of Lightspeed, has evolved from Breadcrumb POS into a management powerhouse with sophisticated analytics and cross-platform device compatibility.
This article reviews their strengths, weaknesses, and what sets them apart, helping you navigate everything from hardware features to pricing and support. As restaurant technology rapidly develops, grasping the details between these systems becomes essential for future-proofing your business and gaining a competitive edge.
The look and feel of a restaurant POS system plays a massive role in staff efficiency and training. Toast stands out for its intuitive, food-service-focused interface, shaped by industry professionals who understand the challenges of busy service. Large buttons, logical flows, and responsive design make it easy to learn and operate—even for new staff.
Upserve matches Toast’s ease-of-use with a clean, simple interface that many reviewers appreciate for quick employee tracking and check splitting. Its “training mode” lets staff practice without disrupting live operations, ideal for fast-paced environments with high turnover. The system is flexible and works smoothly across both iOS and Android, allowing you to utilize preferred devices.
Some Upserve users mention occasional lags or more complicated menu programming compared to Toast. While both brands invest in training resources, Toast’s dedicated onboarding team and restaurant-specific support deliver a smoother transition, especially for those moving from older systems.
For restaurants needing rapid staff onboarding with minimal friction, both offer strong options. Toast’s design gives most operations a slight boost in staff efficiency, but the final choice usually hinges on workflow preferences and current hardware.
Toast and Upserve each deliver dependable core POS functions, but with some clear differences. Toast shines for its online ordering and kitchen integration: orders sync automatically to kitchen displays for real-time updates to staff and guests. Handheld devices let servers take orders and process payments directly at the table.
Upserve’s strong suit is check management, enabling easy splitting or transferring by seat, percentage, or item—a must for busy restaurants. Offline mode keeps the system running (including credit card processing) during internet outages, capturing encrypted transactions until connectivity returns.
Restaurants benefit from both systems’ menu management, modifier customization, and pricing control. Toast’s enterprise menu management is a winner for multi-location operations, while Upserve’s recipe costing and inventory tracking help with food cost control.
Order routing, kitchen display, and payment processing are reliable on both platforms, but Toast’s kitchen displays get extra points for customizability and resilience during peak hours. Both systems extend flexible payment options, with Toast leading in handheld tableside solutions.
Key POS Features at a Glance:
For most restaurants, feature disparities are minor. Prioritize Toast for integrated ordering; Upserve if flexible check handling is vital.
Hardware is a pivotal factor when choosing a POS, impacting both upfront costs and downtime. Toast offers proprietary Android terminals and handhelds engineered for restaurants—spill-resistant, durable, and optimized for high-traffic use. This approach promises reliable performance but requires hardware purchases directly from Toast.
Upserve is more flexible, supporting both iOS and Android tablets, which can lower starting costs if you already own compatible devices. However, consumer-grade tablets may not match the durability of Toast’s dedicated hardware, increasing the risk of failures and replacements.
Both brands provide compatible peripheral options—receipt printers, cash drawers, card readers—so you can tailor your setup. Toast’s system is tightly integrated, assuring flawless connectivity, while Upserve’s flexibility allows more third-party hardware choices.
Choose Toast for maximum reliability; Upserve for lower investment or hardware flexibility.
As restaurants become more data-driven, analytics capabilities are crucial for informed business management. Toast delivers complete real-time analytics through a web and mobile app, including sales, labor, menu performance, and inventory metrics. You can analyze trends, spot issues, and monitor your business anywhere.
Upserve’s analytics (Upserve HQ) rivals Toast with deep insights into guest behavior and server performance. Managers can track which team members drive higher sales or push more profitable items. The “Daily Digest Email” brings critical stats right to your inbox for effortless oversight.
Both platforms offer customizable dashboards, but Toast’s reporting is typically more intuitive for broad business analysis. Upserve digs deeper into menu engineering and staff efficiency for those who want extra granularity.
For analytics-focused restaurants, both systems impress—just match your most critical metrics to the platform’s strengths.
Restaurant tech rarely exists in isolation nowadays, so integrations matter more than ever. Toast built a robust ecosystem of both in-house tools and third-party integration partners, spanning online ordering, delivery, reservation, accounting, inventory, and scheduling. This deeply connected approach means less juggling between disparate systems.
Upserve counters with broad integration support, especially strong with inventory partners (Orca, BevSpot), accounting platforms (KitchenSync, Shogo), and scheduling solutions (Homebase, 7shifts). Major reservation systems such as OpenTable and Resy also play nice with Upserve, streamlining guest management.
While Toast leans toward an all-in-one suite built for internal harmony, Upserve’s openness means you can cherry-pick specialized best-of-breed tools. Toast’s standout kitchen integrations allow seamless flow from online order to kitchen display. Upserve integration may require a bit more configuration for seamless operation.
Operations heavily invested in third-party systems must verify compatibility before signing up. If you want everything under one roof, Toast fits best; for flexibility or third-party modules, Upserve is preferable.
Is your phone ringing off the hook during dinner service? Managing calls while taking care of on-site guests is challenging—but AI for restaurants is transforming the phone order experience. AI for restaurants like Loman offer a breakthrough: a 24/7 AI phone agent that can expertly handle phone orders and customer inquiries so your staff can stay focused on dine-in guests.
Loman seamlessly integrates with popular POS systems such as Square, Toast, and Clover. Its AI is trained specifically on restaurant menus, policies, and customer preferences, ensuring customers always get accurate answers and speedy service. With built-in analytics and real-time insights, you’ll gain crucial decision-making data, spot trends, and react faster. Loman’s rapid setup process means your business can be live in less than a day—no technical headaches. Best of all, whether you run one location or several, the system scales effortlessly to meet your needs.
Unlike traditional platforms like Toast and Upserve, Loman is designed exclusively for restaurants to eliminate missed calls, reduce wait times, and drive more revenue through better phone and digital experiences. If you want to optimize operations with minimal hassle, Loman stands apart as a focused yet complementary solution alongside these established POS providers.
Payment processing is a big differentiator—especially around fees and flexibility. Toast handles payments in-house, charging 2.6% + $0.10 per card-present transaction. Crucially, you must use Toast’s processing service; bringing your own processor isn’t allowed.
Upserve, operating under Lightspeed, is similarly restrictive: restaurants must use Lightspeed Payments, with a stiff $400 monthly penalty if you try an outside processor. The transaction rates are identical to Toast (2.6% + $0.10 per swipe), which means switching between these two won’t impact costs—but may affect your negotiating power for custom deals.
Both systems are fully EMV-compliant and support major payment methods including mobile and chip cards. Toast wins special praise for its reliable handheld payment terminals, streamlining tableside checkouts and improving table turnover.
Offline payment handling is decent with both platforms. Toast securely holds card data until connectivity resumes, minimizing service interruptions. Upserve also offers offline processing, though some reviews mention hoops to jump through if cards fail after the fact.
The “sticker price” rarely tells the full story of what a POS costs over time. Toast’s entry-level plan starts at $69/month, with extra terminals at $50/month. Upgrades pack in more features: $165/month for Essentials (including online ordering), and $272/month for the Growth plan, which adds loyalty and multi-location management. Hardware bundles kick off at $799, with financing available to ease upfront expenses.
Upserve’s pricing, now under Lightspeed, starts at $89/month for the Starter plan, plus add-ons per terminal. Stepping up to Professional and Enterprise means $399/month, unlocking advanced analytics and inventory, loyalty, and menu tools. Hardware costs depend on your setup but are often flexible due to device compatibility.
Budget Considerations to Watch:
Calculate your true total cost by factoring in payment processing, setup, annual upgrades, and potential hardware replacement.
Support and onboarding impact how smoothly operations run—and how quickly your team adapts. Toast delivers 24/7 phone, email, and chat support with specialists who understand restaurant-specific challenges. Onboarding services include menu setup, hardware install, and dedicated staff training, plus a local presence in over 230 US cities for extra reassurance.
Upserve also offers 24/7 support via multiple channels, though feedback is more mixed—phone wait times and response quality can fluctuate. The Lightspeed acquisition has shifted support processes according to some users, so read current reviews if quality is your top priority.
Both brands provide online learning resources, deep-dive documentation, and “training modes” for risk-free staff practice. Community forums and searchable knowledge bases mean most questions get quick answers. Toast’s training material is noted for depth and organization, while Upserve’s documentation stands out for clarity.
For most restaurants, Toast offers an edge in training and hands-on setup. Upserve satisfies needs for flexible, ongoing support.
After thoroughly evaluating Toast and Upserve (Lightspeed Restaurant U-Series), some clear distinctions emerge to help you choose with confidence. Toast leads with tightly integrated online ordering, durable hardware, and extensive support. Its Android-based application runs reliably under pressure and manages every aspect of restaurant operations seamlessly from front to back.
Upserve wins points for advanced check splitting, flexible hardware compatibility, and granular analytics. Offline functionality and user-friendly design make it attractive for certain service models. Reported system hiccups under heavy loads and less robust kitchen integration stand out as minor drawbacks for high-volume players.
Ultimately, your ideal choice depends on your business’s scale, workflow priorities, and growth vision. Toast is the go-to for reliability, streamlined ordering, and strong support, especially for full-service, multi-location operations, and those seeking frictionless in-person and phone customer service—especially with AI-driven solutions like Loman complementing the experience. Upserve serves best those with iOS hardware, complex check needs, or specific third-party software dependencies.
Keep payment restrictions, support dynamics, and cost structure in mind as you draw up your shortlist. Request demos, compare features, and talk to fellow operators in your niche before making a commitment.
No matter the size of your operation, Loman delivers efficiency and a better guest experience with lightning-fast implementation and scalable design. Whether you’re a solo location, a bustling chain, or a national franchise, Loman gives you the tools to deliver world-class service while freeing your staff for what matters most. Jumpstart your restaurant’s transformation—efficiency and customer happiness are just a click away.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
