Selecting a POS system today isn’t just a technical choice—it’s a crucial step toward smoother service and simpler management. With shifting staff patterns and changing customer expectations in 2025, restaurant owners need technology they can trust to keep up with real-world demands. CAKE POS and Toast POS are among the most widely considered options, and this honest comparison aims to highlight what really matters for owners making decisions in today’s fast-moving restaurant industry.
Restaurant-specific technology differs dramatically from generic retail solutions, requiring specialized features that handle the complexities of food service operations. CAKE POS, backed by Sysco and powered by Mad Mobile, delivers hardware specifically designed for restaurant environments alongside intuitive software that minimizes training time. Their bezel-less screens resist spills and crumbs while the fanless design prevents dust infiltration—essential features for busy kitchen operations. The system excels at guest management with advanced reservation capabilities and real-time floor mapping that optimizes table turns during peak hours.
Toast POS approaches restaurant management through a comprehensive ecosystem model, combining point-of-sale functionality with front-of-house, back-of-house, and customer-facing technology on a single platform. Built on Android for maximum customization control, their hardwired terminals maintain peak performance during high-volume periods while handheld devices enable tableside ordering and payment processing. Toast’s platform emphasizes scalability and extensive integration capabilities, making it particularly attractive for growing operations with multiple locations or concepts.
Both systems understand that restaurant operations demand reliability under pressure, but they achieve this through different approaches. CAKE prioritizes simplicity and durability with straightforward interfaces that reduce complexity, while Toast offers comprehensive functionality that can handle virtually any restaurant scenario through advanced customization options.
Restaurant environments test equipment limits daily through exposure to heat, moisture, grease, and constant handling. CAKE POS addresses these challenges with commercial-grade hardware featuring flush screens that prevent debris accumulation and fanless cooling systems that eliminate dust-related failures. Their design philosophy prioritizes longevity and consistent performance in demanding conditions, with equipment built specifically to withstand spills and temperature fluctuations common in food service operations.
Toast POS similarly provides restaurant-hardened hardware built on the Android platform, which they selected for greater control over updates and functionality compared to iOS alternatives. Their terminals feature robust construction designed for high-temperature environments and rough handling typical of busy restaurant operations. Toast leverages Android’s flexibility to create customized hardware solutions that integrate seamlessly with their software ecosystem while maintaining commercial-grade durability standards.
The hardware investment represents a significant upfront cost that must deliver years of reliable service. CAKE emphasizes their equipment’s restaurant-specific design features, while Toast highlights their system’s ability to maintain performance during peak operational periods.
Key hardware differences that impact daily operations:
Modern restaurant management extends far beyond simple transaction processing, requiring comprehensive tools that streamline operations across all service areas. CAKE POS delivers user-friendly interfaces with powerful management capabilities including online ordering, sales tracking, payment processing, inventory management, and detailed analytics. Their system particularly excels in guest management features with sophisticated reservation acceptance capabilities and real-time floor mapping that helps optimize table utilization during busy periods. Self-checkout options, mobile ordering, and loyalty programs enhance customer engagement while reducing staff workload.
Toast POS integrates point-of-sale functionality with comprehensive restaurant management through their unified platform approach. Features include course-firing capabilities for timed meal delivery, advanced split-check handling, comprehensive inventory management, and real-time reporting accessible from any location. Their menu management system allows quick edits to items and pricing through cloud access, essential for restaurants with frequently changing specials or seasonal offerings. Built-in marketing tools and customer relationship management features help restaurants build lasting customer relationships.
Cloud-based reporting provides real-time business insights accessible from anywhere, crucial for restaurant owners managing operations remotely. CAKE emphasizes their software’s intuitive design that reduces training time for new employees, while Toast highlights platform scalability and extensive customization options that grow with expanding operations. Both systems receive regular updates and feature enhancements to address evolving industry needs and regulatory requirements.
Successful restaurant operations often require multiple specialized systems working together seamlessly, making integration capabilities crucial for operational efficiency. CAKE POS connects with hundreds of third-party applications through their Integrations Hub, enabling seamless connections with accounting software, delivery platforms, and marketing tools. Their approach emphasizes transparency and straightforward implementation, with clear pricing structures that help restaurant owners manage total technology costs effectively without unexpected charges or hidden fees.
Toast POS offers extensive integration options through their comprehensive API, connecting with inventory management systems, reservation platforms, marketing tools, and numerous other restaurant technology solutions. Their “best-in-class ecosystem” approach allows restaurants to select specialized tools while ensuring seamless integration and data synchronization. Toast’s platform includes both proprietary modules and third-party partner connections, providing flexibility to customize technology stacks based on specific operational requirements.
Payment processing integration represents a critical component where the systems differ significantly. CAKE offers flexible payment processing with transparent fee structures and multiple processor options, while Toast requires using their integrated payment processing system, which some restaurants find limiting but others appreciate for its seamless operation and unified reporting capabilities.
Restaurant phone management often becomes overwhelming during peak hours, leading to missed orders, frustrated customers, and lost revenue opportunities. Loman’s 24/7 AI phone agent revolutionizes how restaurants handle customer communications by seamlessly integrating with existing POS systems like Toast and CAKE while providing specialized capabilities that address the unique challenges of restaurant operations. Unlike basic automated systems, Loman’s AI for restaurants understands menu items, handles complex orders, manages reservations, and provides accurate wait time estimates—all while learning from your specific restaurant’s policies and customer preferences.
The system integrates effortlessly with major POS platforms including Square, Toast, and Clover, automatically syncing orders and payments to eliminate manual entry errors and streamline kitchen operations. Loman’s restaurant-trained AI handles unlimited simultaneous calls, ensures no customer receives busy signals during rush periods, and captures orders that would otherwise be lost when staff are occupied with in-person guests. Built-in analytics provide real-time insights into call patterns, peak times, and revenue metrics, enabling smarter staffing decisions and identifying growth opportunities that traditional phone systems miss entirely.
Loman’s implementation speed sets it apart from complex POS installations, with most restaurants going live in under 24 hours compared to weeks or months required for full POS system deployments. The AI learns your menu, pricing, and policies quickly while handling edge cases by routing complex requests to human staff when necessary. Unless CAKE or Toast systems that focus primarily on in-restaurant operations, Loman specifically addresses the critical communication gap that costs restaurants thousands in missed revenue monthly. The system scales effortlessly from single locations to multi-unit operations, providing consistent customer experiences across all locations while maintaining local customization for each restaurant’s unique offerings and policies.
Payment processing costs and capabilities significantly impact restaurant profitability, making this a crucial comparison factor. CAKE POS offers secure payment processing meeting PCI compliance standards with transparent, straightforward pricing structures that help restaurant owners manage costs without unexpected charges. Their system accepts all major payment types and provides integrated solutions for gift cards and loyalty programs. CAKE emphasizes fee transparency, allowing restaurants to accurately predict monthly processing costs based on transaction volumes and types.
Toast POS takes a different approach by requiring restaurants to use their integrated payment processing system, which they describe as offering “fair, flat rates that restaurants can understand.” Their payment processing integrates fully with the POS system, streamlining operations and reconciliation processes. Toast’s payment capabilities include contactless payments, digital receipts, and comprehensive tip management features that handle complex tip distribution scenarios common in restaurant operations.
Total cost of ownership extends beyond monthly software fees to include payment processing costs, which can significantly impact profitability over time. CAKE users frequently praise the system’s cost transparency and competitive processing rates, while Toast users often highlight the operational efficiency gained through integrated payment processing despite potentially higher overall costs. Both systems provide secure, reliable payment processing, but their fee structures and integration approaches differ substantially.
Essential payment processing considerations for restaurant owners:
Restaurant success depends on understanding financial performance across multiple dimensions, making comprehensive reporting capabilities essential. CAKE POS provides real-time reporting accessible from anywhere, giving owners visibility into sales performance, labor costs, and inventory metrics that drive profitability. Their analytics platform offers insights into menu performance, helping restaurants optimize offerings based on popularity and profitability data. Customizable dashboards allow users to focus on their most critical metrics while scheduled report delivery ensures regular performance review.
Toast POS includes cloud reporting in their basic POS package, with advanced analytics available in higher-tier subscriptions. Their reporting suite encompasses sales summaries, labor reports, menu analysis, and detailed payment information presented through intuitive dashboards. Toast emphasizes actionable insights rather than raw data, helping restaurant owners identify improvement opportunities through forecasting tools that use historical data to predict future sales and staffing needs.
Both systems enable detailed business performance analysis across time periods, menu categories, and service types. CAKE users appreciate straightforward reporting interfaces though some mention limitations in highly customized report creation, while Toast users highlight comprehensive data collection and visualization tools despite noting a learning curve for full feature utilization.
Technology support becomes critical when system issues directly impact restaurant operations and revenue. CAKE POS emphasizes US-based support available 24/7/365, including dedicated Sysco support lines for their backed restaurants. Their customer service approach focuses on “real people, real support, real fast,” addressing the urgency of restaurant technology issues that can immediately affect operations. Comprehensive training resources include online training centers that help restaurant staff quickly become proficient with system features, while Sysco backing and Best Buy installation services provide additional support layers.
Toast POS provides 24/7 customer service through phone, email, and chat channels, with support staff specifically trained in restaurant industry challenges and operational urgency. Their “restaurant-specific customer service” means support teams understand unique food service challenges and the critical nature of system functionality during peak hours. Training resources include video tutorials and knowledge base articles, with optional paid training services available for comprehensive onboarding and advanced feature utilization.
User experiences with both systems reflect mixed support quality, as common with technology providers serving demanding industries. CAKE users frequently praise responsive and knowledgeable customer service, though some report occasional delays during peak support times. Toast users similarly report positive experiences with knowledgeable support teams, though some mention challenges with initial installation and setup complexity.
Restaurant operations increasingly demand mobility and remote management capabilities to maintain efficiency and oversight. CAKE POS offers mobile solutions including their CAKEpop handheld device providing complete POS functionality in portable form factors. Staff can take orders and process payments from anywhere in the restaurant, improving table turns and enhancing customer experiences through reduced wait times. Cloud-based system architecture enables managers to access reports and make menu changes remotely through any internet-connected device, providing operational flexibility during off-site hours.
Toast POS emphasizes mobility through Toast Go handheld devices that integrate seamlessly with their main POS system while providing complete restaurant management capabilities from mobile devices. Menu editing, staff scheduling, and performance monitoring can all be accomplished remotely through their mobile applications. Customer-facing mobile capabilities include tableside ordering and payment processing that reduces wait times while increasing server efficiency through streamlined workflows.
Both platforms recognize mobile flexibility’s importance in modern restaurant operations, implementing these capabilities through different approaches. CAKE emphasizes intuitive mobile interface design accessible even for less tech-savvy staff members, while Toast highlights comprehensive mobile functionality providing access to virtually all system features from portable devices.
Mobile capabilities that enhance restaurant operations:
Pricing structures vary significantly between systems, making direct comparison challenging without specific business requirements. CAKE POS emphasizes value through competitive monthly fees and transparent pricing that includes hardware costs, monthly software subscriptions, and payment processing fees. User reviews frequently cite CAKE as offering good value for money, particularly for small to medium-sized restaurants. Their pricing model includes options for purchasing hardware outright or leasing, providing flexibility based on available capital and cash flow preferences.
Toast POS offers tiered subscription plans with varying features and capabilities, including hardware costs (purchased or leased), software subscription fees, and payment processing rates. Toast’s comprehensive ecosystem approach can result in accumulating costs as additional features are added, though many users report operational efficiencies and increased sales justify the investment. Their requirement to use Toast payment processing limits flexibility but provides integrated reporting and reconciliation benefits.
Total cost of ownership considerations extend beyond initial investments and monthly fees to include training time, potential revenue increases from improved efficiency, and customer retention through enhanced experiences. CAKE users frequently mention value propositions particularly regarding ease of use reducing training costs, while Toast users highlight operational efficiency increases and sales improvements through features like tableside ordering and integrated loyalty programs.
Hardware represents a significant upfront investment requiring careful consideration of financing options and long-term value. CAKE POS provides flexible hardware acquisition through purchase or lease options, allowing restaurants to choose approaches that best fit their capital structure and cash flow requirements. Their restaurant-specific hardware design emphasizes durability and longevity, potentially reducing replacement costs over time through extended equipment lifecycles in demanding restaurant environments.
Toast POS offers similar flexibility in hardware acquisition with purchase, lease, and rental options depending on specific business needs and financial preferences. Their starter kit options include free hardware with pay-as-you-go pricing models, while traditional plans allow bring-your-own-hardware approaches for restaurants with existing equipment investments. Custom enterprise plans often include bundled hardware/software packages with volume-based pricing for multi-location operations.
Both systems provide hardware specifically designed for restaurant environments that significantly outperforms consumer-grade alternatives in durability and functionality. Investment decisions should consider not only upfront costs but also expected equipment lifecycles, replacement costs, and operational efficiency improvements that justify higher initial investments through improved performance and reduced downtime.
System implementation timelines and complexity significantly impact restaurant operations during transition periods. CAKE POS emphasizes straightforward implementation with user-friendly interfaces designed to minimize training time and operational disruption. Their partnership with Best Buy for installation services provides professional setup support, while Sysco backing offers additional resources for restaurants within their network. Training programs focus on quick proficiency development to reduce the learning curve during busy operational periods.
Toast POS implementation involves more comprehensive setup reflecting their extensive feature set and customization options. Professional installation and training services ensure proper system configuration, though the process may take longer due to platform complexity and integration requirements. Their approach focuses on maximizing system utilization through thorough training that helps restaurants leverage advanced features for operational improvements.
Both systems offer demonstration opportunities allowing restaurant owners to experience interfaces and workflows before making commitments. Speaking with current users in similar restaurant concepts provides practical insights into real-world performance and implementation experiences. Free trials and pilot programs help restaurants evaluate systems under actual operating conditions before full deployment.
Implementation factors that affect restaurant success:
Selecting between CAKE POS and Toast POS ultimately depends on your restaurant’s specific operational requirements, growth objectives, and technology preferences. CAKE POS excels for restaurants prioritizing simplicity, reliability, and straightforward implementation with intuitive interfaces that minimize training requirements and operational disruption. Their restaurant-specific hardware design and transparent pricing make them particularly attractive for small to medium-sized operations seeking proven reliability without complex feature sets they may not utilize.
Toast POS stands out for restaurants needing comprehensive ecosystem solutions with extensive customization options and scalability for growing operations. Their platform offers integrated modules and third-party connections that can reduce the need for multiple disparate systems while providing advanced features that support complex operational requirements. Toast may be especially appropriate for restaurants planning expansion across multiple locations or concepts requiring consistent technology platforms.
Consider several critical factors when making this important decision: current operational challenges, anticipated growth patterns, staff technical capabilities, budget constraints, and specific feature requirements that directly impact your restaurant’s success. Both systems offer demonstration opportunities that provide valuable hands-on experience with interfaces and workflows, while speaking with current users in similar restaurant types offers practical insights into real-world performance and satisfaction levels.
Restaurant success increasingly depends on technology that enhances rather than complicates daily operations, while providing the flexibility to adapt to changing customer expectations and industry trends. Whether you choose CAKE’s straightforward approach or Toast’s comprehensive ecosystem, the right system will become an invisible enabler of exceptional customer experiences and operational efficiency. Loman complements either choice by ensuring every customer call becomes a growth opportunity, providing the missing communication link that transforms how restaurants handle customer interactions while seamlessly integrating with your chosen POS solution.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
