Selecting the right point-of-sale (POS) system for your restaurant isn’t just a technological decision—it’s a strategic business choice that impacts everything from daily operations to long-term growth. Today, we’re examining two industry leaders: Toast and Lightspeed Restaurant. These robust platforms have emerged as frontrunners in the restaurant technology space, each offering distinct advantages for food service establishments.
Toast has built its reputation as a restaurant-specific solution with purpose-built hardware designed to withstand the demanding conditions of food service environments. The platform was developed from the ground up specifically for restaurants, creating an intuitive interface that staff can navigate with minimal training. Its order and table management system allows servers to open, split, and close checks with a single tool, streamlining service during busy periods. Toast also excels with offline functionality, maintaining full operation even when internet connectivity fails—a critical feature during peak service times.
Lightspeed presents itself as a versatile option with extensive integration capabilities and cross-industry functionality. While also offering robust restaurant functionality, it brings a more comprehensive approach with advanced in-depth insights and business analytics. The system creates automatic dashboards that generate valuable business intelligence, helping owners understand what brings guests back through detailed reporting on menu and staff performance. Lightspeed also provides more extensive PMS (Property Management System) integrations, making it particularly valuable for restaurants within hotels or multi-faceted hospitality establishments.
According to recent market research, restaurants implementing the right POS system can experience up to 20% increases in operational efficiency and significant improvements in customer satisfaction metrics. Both systems offer core sales reporting, multi-location management, advanced inventory tracking, and bill-splitting capabilities. However, the nuanced differences between these platforms may significantly impact operations depending on a restaurant’s service model, size, and specific needs.
Hardware flexibility represents a significant point of differentiation between Toast and Lightspeed, with direct implications for both initial investment and long-term operational costs. Toast operates exclusively on Android-based proprietary hardware, offering purpose-built restaurant equipment designed to withstand spills, heat, and constant use. Their hardware suite includes the Toast Flex terminal, Toast Go handheld devices for tableside ordering, and specialized kitchen display systems. While robust and durable, this approach requires purchasing hardware directly from Toast, potentially increasing initial investment costs. The Android exclusivity also means restaurants with existing iOS devices cannot incorporate them into their Toast ecosystem.
Conversely, Lightspeed offers greater hardware flexibility, running primarily on iPads and iOS devices while also accommodating existing hardware setups. This approach allows restaurants to potentially utilize equipment they already own, significantly reducing startup costs. Lightspeed’s compatibility extends to a wide range of peripherals and third-party hardware, giving restaurants more options when designing their POS configuration. Restaurants can customize their setup based on specific needs rather than conforming to a predetermined hardware package.
The hardware decision ultimately balances durability against flexibility and cost considerations. Toast’s purpose-built hardware excels in durability and seamless integration but comes with higher upfront costs and less flexibility. Lightspeed’s approach offers cost advantages and adaptability but may require more careful consideration of hardware durability in demanding restaurant environments. Restaurants with existing hardware investments might find Lightspeed’s flexibility advantageous, while those prioritizing purpose-built durability might prefer Toast’s specialized equipment.
When evaluating hardware options between these platforms, consider these essential factors:
While Toast and Lightspeed excel at managing in-house operations, today’s restaurants need comprehensive solutions that extend beyond the dining room. Modern restaurants face increasing challenges with phone orders, customer inquiries, and managing peak call volumes that can overwhelm staff during busy periods. This is where specialized AI for restaurants technology becomes invaluable, offering 24/7 automated phone support that seamlessly integrates with existing POS systems like Toast, Square, Clover, and other leading platforms.
Loman’s AI phone agent represents a breakthrough in restaurant automation, trained specifically on restaurant menus, policies, and customer preferences to ensure accuracy in every interaction. The system reduces missed calls that typically cost restaurants thousands in lost revenue monthly, shortens customer wait times, and actually improves sales through consistent upselling and cross-selling capabilities. Unlike generic chatbots, Loman’s technology understands restaurant-specific terminology, dietary restrictions, and complex order modifications that characterize food service operations. Built-in analytics provide real-time insights that help owners make better staffing and operational decisions based on call patterns and customer behavior data.
Understanding the total cost of ownership for both POS systems requires looking beyond advertised monthly fees to consider hardware requirements, payment processing fees, and add-on costs. Toast offers multiple pricing tiers, including a free starter plan with higher payment processing rates, and paid plans starting at $69 per month with lower processing fees. The company requires using Toast as your payment processor, with rates typically ranging from 2.49% + $0.15 to 3.5% + $0.15 per transaction, depending on your plan and transaction type. Toast also offers hardware on either an upfront purchase model or monthly financing options.
Lightspeed’s pricing begins at $69 per month for its basic restaurant package, with more comprehensive plans ranging from $189 to $399 monthly. Lightspeed charges 2.6% + $0.10 for in-person transactions and 2.9% + $0.30 for online payments when using Lightspeed Payments. Unlike Toast, Lightspeed allows integration with third-party payment processors, though this may incur additional monthly fees. Lightspeed also offers hardware bundles at various price points, with the flexibility to use existing iPads or purchase new equipment.
The pricing comparison reveals Toast potentially offers a lower entry point with its free plan option, but Lightspeed provides more flexibility with payment processing choices. Toast’s all-inclusive approach may simplify budgeting, while Lightspeed’s à la carte structure allows restaurants to pay only for needed features. When calculating total cost, restaurants must consider their transaction volume, hardware needs, and whether features like loyalty programs are essential to their operations.
Several elements contribute to the total investment in either POS system:
Payment processing represents a critical difference between Toast and Lightspeed, with implications for both operational flexibility and long-term costs. Toast operates on a closed payment ecosystem, requiring restaurants to use Toast’s payment processing exclusively. While this creates seamless integration, it eliminates negotiating leverage and potentially results in higher processing costs over time. The system handles all major payment types including contactless payments, digital wallets, and traditional credit cards, both on and off-premise.
Lightspeed offers greater flexibility with payment processing, allowing restaurants to choose between Lightspeed Payments or third-party processors. This flexibility can be particularly valuable for restaurants with existing processor relationships or those able to negotiate favorable rates due to high transaction volumes. Both systems provide integrated payment reporting, giving restaurants a comprehensive view of operations by connecting customer, operational, and payment processing data.
Beyond payment processing, both systems offer extensive integration ecosystems, though with different strengths. Toast features strong integrations with delivery platforms and restaurant-specific applications, while Lightspeed boasts a broader range of integrations across various business categories including extensive PMS connections. This distinction makes Lightspeed particularly suitable for restaurants within hotels or resorts that need to connect with property management systems. Restaurants should carefully evaluate whether payment processing flexibility or specialized restaurant integrations better serve their operational requirements.
Both Toast and Lightspeed have developed comprehensive feature sets tailored to restaurant operations, though with different areas of emphasis. Toast excels in operational efficiency with its purpose-built restaurant workflow design. The system offers robust table management, coursing controls, and kitchen display system (KDS) integration, creating seamless communication between front and back of house. Toast’s mobile ordering capabilities allow servers to take orders tableside, expediting service and increasing table turnover. The platform also includes specialized features for quick-service restaurants, including fast order entry screens and customer-facing displays.
Lightspeed counters with equally strong restaurant features plus enhanced analytical capabilities. Its advanced reporting suite provides deeper insights into menu performance, helping identify profitable items and optimize pricing strategies. Lightspeed also offers comprehensive inventory management with the ability to track ingredients at the recipe level, helping restaurants manage food costs more effectively. Both systems support online ordering, delivery integration, and gift card programs, though implementation details vary.
A notable distinction is Lightspeed’s inclusion of a loyalty program in all pricing tiers, while Toast offers this as a premium add-on. Lightspeed also provides more extensive customization options for menu engineering and reporting, giving restaurants greater flexibility in adapting the system to their specific operational needs. For restaurants prioritizing operational efficiency and straightforward workflows, Toast’s purpose-built approach may be preferable. Conversely, establishments seeking deeper analytical insights and customization flexibility might find Lightspeed’s feature set more aligned with their needs.
Modern restaurant POS systems must deliver core functionality that directly impacts daily operations:
The quality and availability of customer support can make or break a restaurant’s experience with their POS system, particularly during busy service periods when technical issues can significantly impact operations. Toast offers 24/7 customer support across all plan levels, providing assistance via phone, email, and chat. The company emphasizes its restaurant industry expertise, staffing support teams with individuals who understand the unique challenges of food service environments. Toast also provides free one-on-one onboarding as part of its standard package, helping restaurants configure their system and train staff on basic functionality.
Lightspeed similarly offers robust support options, including 24/7 technical assistance and personalized onboarding at no additional charge. The company provides a comprehensive knowledge base, video tutorials, and regular webinars to help restaurants maximize their system’s potential. Lightspeed’s support team demonstrates strong expertise across both restaurant and retail environments, though some users report that this broader focus occasionally results in less restaurant-specific knowledge compared to Toast’s dedicated restaurant support.
Both companies offer implementation assistance, though the depth varies by plan level and restaurant size. For enterprise-level implementations, both provide dedicated project managers to oversee system rollout. User reviews suggest Toast has a slight edge in restaurant-specific support quality, while Lightspeed receives praise for its comprehensive self-help resources and training materials. The ideal support structure depends on each restaurant’s internal technical capabilities and preference for self-service versus direct support.
For growing restaurant businesses, scalability and multi-location management capabilities are crucial considerations when selecting a POS system. Both Toast and Lightspeed offer tools designed to support expansion, though with different approaches to multi-unit operations. Toast provides comprehensive multi-location management features that allow restaurant groups to centralize menu management, customer data, and reporting across all locations. The system enables corporate-level oversight while maintaining location-specific customization capabilities.
Lightspeed also delivers strong multi-location functionality with centralized management tools and permission-based access controls. The system allows menu changes across all locations with just a few clicks, streamlining operations for restaurant groups introducing seasonal items or price adjustments. Lightspeed’s cross-location reporting provides visibility into performance metrics across the entire organization, helping corporate management identify trends and make data-driven decisions. The platform also excels in maintaining consistent guest data across locations, enhancing the customer experience for diners who visit multiple restaurant outposts.
Both systems scale effectively from single locations to large enterprise operations, though Toast has historically focused more specifically on multi-unit restaurant groups. Lightspeed’s broader focus across retail and hospitality provides advantages for mixed-concept operations that combine restaurant, retail, and other hospitality elements. When evaluating scalability, restaurants should consider not just current needs but future expansion plans, including potential diversification into related hospitality segments. The ideal system should grow seamlessly with the business without requiring significant retraining or operational disruption during expansion phases.
Enterprise restaurant operations require sophisticated tools to maintain consistency and control across multiple locations:
System reliability during internet outages represents a critical consideration for restaurants, where service disruptions can severely impact revenue and customer satisfaction. Toast and Lightspeed take different approaches to offline functionality, with significant implications for operational continuity. Toast offers robust offline capabilities that allow restaurants to continue full operations during internet outages. When connectivity is lost, Toast terminals maintain communication with each other via local networking, enabling continued order entry, payment processing, and kitchen communication.
Lightspeed’s offline capabilities, while present, are somewhat more limited compared to Toast’s comprehensive offline functionality. The system allows for basic continued operations during outages, but some functionality may be restricted. This distinction could prove consequential during extended outages, particularly for high-volume operations where service disruptions directly impact revenue. Beyond offline functionality, overall system reliability encompasses factors like update management, hardware performance, and system uptime.
Both companies maintain modern cloud-based architecture with regular updates and improvements. Toast’s purpose-built hardware approach creates a more controlled ecosystem that may reduce compatibility issues, while Lightspeed’s flexibility with hardware potentially introduces more variables that could affect system stability. Restaurants in areas with unreliable internet connectivity should carefully evaluate the offline capabilities of both systems, potentially prioritizing Toast’s more comprehensive offline functionality if service continuity during outages is a primary concern.
Understanding how existing customers perceive each system provides valuable insight beyond feature comparisons and pricing considerations. Based on aggregated reviews across platforms like G2, Capterra, and TrustRadius, both Toast and Lightspeed maintain strong overall satisfaction ratings, though with different strengths highlighted by users. Toast consistently receives praise for its intuitive interface, restaurant-specific workflows, and hardware durability. Users particularly appreciate the system’s reliability during peak service times and the quality of Toast’s customer support when issues arise.
Lightspeed users frequently highlight the system’s analytical depth, customization flexibility, and integration capabilities as key advantages. Restaurants particularly value the detailed reporting and inventory management features that help optimize operations and control costs. Some reviews mention steeper learning curves compared to more specialized restaurant systems, though most indicate the additional complexity delivers worthwhile capabilities. Lightspeed’s payment processing flexibility receives consistent positive mention, particularly from larger operations able to negotiate favorable processing rates.
Market perception positions Toast as the restaurant industry specialist with purpose-built solutions, while Lightspeed is viewed as a more versatile platform with broader application across hospitality segments. This distinction influences which restaurants gravitate toward each solution, with Toast attracting operations seeking restaurant-focused simplicity and Lightspeed drawing those requiring cross-functional capabilities or extensive customization. Both companies continue expanding their feature sets and addressing areas of customer feedback, maintaining competitive positions in the rapidly evolving restaurant technology landscape.
After comprehensive analysis of Toast and Lightspeed Restaurant POS systems, the optimal choice depends on each restaurant’s specific needs, operational model, and growth trajectory. Toast excels as a purpose-built restaurant solution with intuitive workflows, durable hardware, and exceptional offline capabilities. Its strengths make it particularly well-suited for restaurants prioritizing operational reliability, straightforward implementation, and restaurant-specific functionality. The system’s limitations primarily involve payment processing flexibility and potentially higher costs as businesses scale.
Lightspeed distinguishes itself with analytical depth, customization options, and broader hospitality integration capabilities. Its flexible hardware approach and payment processing options may deliver cost advantages for certain operations, particularly those with existing equipment or favorable processing relationships. Restaurants within hotels or with retail components will likely benefit from Lightspeed’s cross-industry functionality and extensive PMS integrations. For quick-service and fast-casual concepts seeking operational simplicity and reliability, Toast often represents the more aligned solution.
Full-service restaurants with complex analytical needs or those operating within larger hospitality environments may find greater value in Lightspeed’s extensive customization and integration capabilities. Multi-location operations should carefully evaluate the enterprise tools offered by both platforms, considering both current requirements and future expansion plans. The ideal POS partner will align not just with current operational needs but with long-term business vision and growth strategy.
Restaurants ready to modernize their operations should consider how solutions like Loman complement these POS systems by handling the increasing volume of phone orders and customer inquiries that can overwhelm staff during peak periods. With fast setup capabilities that get restaurants live in under a day and scalability for single locations, chains, or franchises, Loman provides the efficiency gains and improved customer experience that today’s competitive restaurant market demands.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
