Restaurant operators in 2025 face unprecedented challenges managing rising labor costs, supply chain disruptions, and customers who expect flawless digital experiences. Your point-of-sale system has evolved from a simple cash register replacement to the central nervous system of your entire operation, handling everything from inventory tracking to customer data management. Square and Toast have emerged as the two dominant players in restaurant POS technology, but they take fundamentally different approaches to solving operational problems. Square appeals to businesses seeking flexibility and cost transparency, while Toast focuses exclusively on restaurant-specific functionality and durability. This detailed comparison examines how these platforms handle pricing, hardware, features, and support to help you choose the system that will actually improve your daily operations rather than complicate them.
Square began as a general payment processor before expanding into restaurant solutions. This broad foundation gives Square versatility across multiple industries, making it particularly appealing for establishments that serve food but also retail products. Square emphasizes simplicity and transparent pricing, with a genuinely free entry-level plan that attracts new restaurants and small establishments. The platform’s approach prioritizes accessibility, allowing restaurant owners to get started immediately without upfront costs or long-term commitments.
Toast was purpose-built exclusively for restaurants from day one. Every feature, interface element, and hardware component reflects this restaurant-first philosophy. Toast’s specialized focus becomes evident in its kitchen display systems designed for heat and splashes, inventory tracking down to ingredient levels, and table management features built for complex service workflows. While Toast requires greater initial investment and contract commitments, this specialization delivers solutions specifically crafted for food service operations.
The fundamental difference between a general system adapted for restaurants versus a restaurant-exclusive platform affects every aspect of your experience. Square offers broader flexibility but may require additional configuration for complex restaurant needs. Toast provides restaurant-optimized solutions but with less adaptability for non-food service functions.
Square’s pricing transparency sets it apart in the POS market. The free plan includes basic functionality with only payment processing fees of 2.6% + 10¢ per transaction. This straightforward structure makes budgeting predictable, while paid plans starting at $69/month per location add features like 24/7 support and advanced reporting. Square operates on month-to-month terms with no termination fees, providing maximum flexibility for seasonal businesses or those testing new concepts.
Toast’s pricing complexity reflects its comprehensive feature set. Standard plans begin at $69/month per location with lower processing rates of 2.49% + 15¢, while pay-as-you-go options eliminate monthly fees but increase per-transaction costs. Toast typically requires two-year contracts, trading flexibility for potentially lower total costs for committed operators. This structure works well for established restaurants confident in their long-term technology needs.
Additional services significantly impact total investment for both platforms. Toast charges extra for online ordering ($75/month), loyalty programs, and gift cards, while Square includes basic online ordering but charges for premium features. High-volume restaurants should calculate projected transaction volumes carefully, as the difference between Toast’s 2.49% + 15¢ and Square’s 2.6% + 10¢ processing rates can accumulate substantially over time.
Toast’s hardware advantage becomes immediately apparent in demanding restaurant environments. Their Android-based terminals feature industrial-grade components specifically designed for spills, heat, and constant use. The screens function even when wet, while handheld devices like Toast Go 2 offer all-day battery life and fit comfortably in server apron pockets. This purpose-built approach ensures reliability during peak service hours when technical failures directly impact revenue.
Square provides hardware flexibility but potentially less environmental durability. The platform works with existing iOS devices, particularly iPads, which restaurants may already own. This compatibility reduces initial investment, though standard consumer tablets may not withstand kitchen conditions as effectively as Toast’s specialized hardware. Square’s approach appeals to cost-conscious operators and those preferring familiar Apple interfaces.
Investment requirements differ significantly between platforms. Toast’s starter hardware packages begin around $799, though financing and leasing options are available. Square offers free mobile readers, with complete Register systems priced at $799, and allows businesses to use existing iPads with Square Stand ($169) for economical setups. For high-volume restaurants in challenging environments, Toast’s durability justifies higher costs, while smaller operations might benefit from Square’s flexibility and lower entry requirements.
Toast’s restaurant-exclusive focus delivers specialized features that address industry-specific challenges. Their comprehensive table management system includes coursing for fine dining, automated kitchen workflows, and ingredient-level inventory tracking with food cost calculations. The kitchen display system withstands kitchen heat and splashes while providing ticket timing and color-coding to help staff prioritize orders efficiently. These purpose-built solutions reduce training time and improve operational flow.
Square offers solid restaurant functionality but sometimes requires additional configuration or third-party integrations to match Toast’s native capabilities. While Square provides basic table management and kitchen display options, these features may lack the depth required for high-volume or complex operations. Square’s kitchen displays run on standard iPads, which may need additional protection in harsh kitchen environments but offer familiar interfaces for staff.
Both systems excel at essential restaurant functions including menu customization, modifier options, and split checks. Toast provides more advanced inventory management with waste tracking and automated reordering, while Square offers inventory alerts with less granular control. Complex operations like catering or large event management benefit from Toast’s specialized solutions, whereas Square users might integrate third-party applications for similar functionality.
While Square and Toast handle in-store operations effectively, neither addresses the critical challenge of phone order management and customer service. Restaurants lose revenue daily from missed calls, long hold times, and inconsistent order taking during peak hours. Loman’s 24/7 AI phone agent solves these problems specifically for restaurants, integrating seamlessly with existing POS systems including Square, Toast, and Clover. This specialized AI for restaurants understands menu items, dietary restrictions, and customer preferences to provide accurate, consistent service around the clock.
Traditional POS systems require staff to answer phones while managing in-person customers, creating inefficiencies that hurt both revenue and customer experience. Loman eliminates this bottleneck by handling phone orders, reservations, and customer inquiries automatically, reducing missed calls and shortening wait times. The system trains on your specific menu, policies, and customer data, ensuring accuracy that matches or exceeds human performance. Built-in analytics provide real-time insights into call patterns, popular items, and customer preferences that help optimize operations and boost sales. Unlike Square’s general approach or Toast’s in-restaurant focus, Loman specializes exclusively in restaurant communication, delivering fast setup (live in under a day) and scalable solutions for single locations, chains, or franchises seeking immediate efficiency improvements.
Digital ordering capabilities have evolved from nice-to-have features to essential revenue channels. Square includes free online ordering with its base package, allowing restaurants to establish digital presence immediately without additional monthly fees. The system integrates seamlessly with in-store POS operations, consolidating reporting and inventory management across all channels. Square charges 2.9% + 30¢ for online transactions, competitive with most third-party platforms.
Toast charges $75/month for online ordering but provides restaurant-specific features designed for operational efficiency. Their system includes estimated preparation times based on kitchen capacity and current order volume, helping manage customer expectations and kitchen workflow. Toast processes online orders at 3.5% + 15¢, higher than Square but often justified by specialized functionality. Both platforms support QR code ordering for contactless tableside service, allowing customers to browse menus, place orders, and pay directly from smartphones.
Integration with third-party delivery services like DoorDash and Uber Eats works well on both platforms, though setup processes and commission structures vary. Square offers greater flexibility for businesses selling both food and retail items through unified online platforms, while Toast focuses exclusively on food service optimization. Restaurants heavily dependent on delivery and takeout should evaluate these differences carefully, as they significantly impact operational efficiency and profit margins.
Support quality becomes critical during service hours when technical issues directly affect revenue and customer satisfaction. Toast provides 24/7 customer support across all subscription levels, ensuring assistance during late-night service or early morning prep times. Their onboarding includes personalized setup and staff training, delivered remotely or on-site depending on the selected package. Toast representatives typically understand restaurant operations and the urgency of service-time technical issues.
Square limits 24/7 support to paid plans, with free users restricted to standard business hours (6 AM to 6 PM PT, weekdays). Support operates through phone, email, and live chat, backed by extensive self-service resources. Square’s implementation is largely self-directed, expecting users to configure systems independently, though support agents assist when needed. This approach works well for tech-savvy operators but may challenge those preferring guided setup.
Implementation timeframes reflect each platform’s philosophy. Square enables setup within hours or days, allowing rapid deployment with minimal operational disruption. Users can configure menus and settings independently without professional assistance. Toast typically requires weeks for full implementation, including menu building, hardware installation, and comprehensive staff training. While this process demands advance planning, it delivers more customized solutions tailored to specific operational needs.
Modern restaurants rely on multiple software solutions for accounting, inventory, marketing, and staff management, making integration capabilities essential. Square maintains an extensive app marketplace with over 300 integrations spanning all business functions. This open ecosystem allows restaurants to build customized technology stacks using best-in-class solutions for specific needs. The broad selection provides flexibility but requires careful evaluation to ensure compatibility and avoid feature overlap.
Toast offers fewer but more carefully curated integrations, prioritizing seamless compatibility over quantity. Their approach ensures reliable connections with leading restaurant software providers but provides limited options for specialized requirements. Both systems integrate with major accounting platforms like QuickBooks and Xero, though setup processes and data synchronization methods differ significantly.
Each platform expands its native ecosystem continuously. Square provides payroll ($35/month base + $5/employee), marketing tools, and banking services that integrate directly with POS operations. Toast offers similar services including payroll ($69/month + $8/employee), marketing solutions, and restaurant-focused financial products. These native add-ons create unified experiences but may lack specialized features of dedicated third-party solutions.
Service efficiency and customer experience improve significantly with mobile POS capabilities. Square excels in mobility options, functioning on iOS and Android devices that staff may already own. This cross-platform compatibility enables cost-effective deployment of mobile ordering and payment solutions. Square’s free tier supports unlimited devices, making it economical to equip entire teams with mobile capabilities for tableside service or outdoor events.
Toast operates exclusively on Android devices, limiting hardware choices but ensuring consistent performance across the system. Their purpose-built handheld devices like Toast Go 2 include integrated card readers, barcode scanners, and batteries designed for full-shift operation. These comprehensive mobile solutions require investment in proprietary hardware but deliver superior functionality for demanding restaurant environments.
Both platforms excel at tableside ordering and payment processing, reducing server travel time and increasing table turnover rates. Offline capabilities ensure continued operation during internet outages, though with different functionality levels. Square processes payments offline with Terminal devices, while Toast maintains full operational capability with proper backup router setup. These features provide significant advantages for restaurants with outdoor seating, catering operations, or unreliable internet connectivity.
Your POS system decision should align with operational requirements, growth plans, and budget realities rather than following industry trends. Square typically serves smaller establishments, new restaurants, seasonal operations, and businesses valuing flexibility over specialized features. Its intuitive interface, transparent pricing, and month-to-month flexibility make it excellent for testing concepts or operating with tight margins. The platform works especially well for restaurants that also sell retail products or need rapid deployment capabilities.
Toast better serves established restaurants, full-service dining operations, and businesses with complex service models requiring specialized functionality. Restaurant-specific features, durable hardware, and comprehensive implementation support justify higher investment and contract commitments for establishments that will fully utilize these capabilities. High-volume restaurants often benefit from Toast’s lower processing rates over time, while complex operations appreciate the depth of native restaurant features.
Conduct thorough cost analysis incorporating monthly fees and processing costs based on your specific ticket sizes and transaction volumes. Request system demonstrations allowing staff to test interfaces and workflows in realistic scenarios. Connect with similar restaurants using each platform to gather real-world perspectives on performance, reliability, and support quality. The optimal system enhances operational efficiency while supporting your long-term growth objectives, making this decision crucial for sustained restaurant success.
For restaurants seeking immediate efficiency improvements, Loman provides specialized AI phone agents that integrate seamlessly with Square, Toast, or other POS systems. This fast-to-implement solution scales effortlessly across single locations, chains, or franchises, delivering 24/7 customer service that reduces missed calls and improves customer experience while you focus on in-person operations.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
