Selecting the right point-of-sale system can make or break your business operations. Restaurant owners, retailers, and service providers are increasingly turning to sophisticated POS solutions that go beyond simple payment processing. With countless options available, two platforms have emerged as industry leaders, each offering distinct advantages for different business models. The decision between Square and Lightspeed represents more than just choosing software—it’s about selecting a foundation that will support your business growth, streamline operations, and enhance customer experiences for years to come.
Square began as a simple mobile payment solution and has evolved into a comprehensive business management platform. It offers a free entry-level POS system with basic functionality, making it particularly attractive to small businesses and startups. Square’s ecosystem includes integrated payment processing, robust inventory management, and various business tools designed to grow with your business. Its platform emphasizes simplicity and ease of use, allowing merchants to start selling quickly with minimal setup time.
Lightspeed positions itself as a more advanced solution tailored to specific industries, including retail, restaurants, and golf businesses. With over a decade of experience serving businesses worldwide, Lightspeed provides sophisticated inventory features and detailed reporting capabilities. Unlike Square’s freemium model, Lightspeed operates on a subscription basis with different tiers of service, offering more specialized functionality but at a higher price point.
Both systems are cloud-based, enabling business owners to access their data from anywhere with an internet connection. While Square emphasizes universal accessibility across multiple devices, Lightspeed focuses on delivering industry-specific features that address the unique challenges faced by businesses in their target sectors. This fundamental difference in approach reflects the distinct market segments these platforms aim to serve—Square for the budget-conscious small business owner seeking simplicity, and Lightspeed for the established merchant requiring advanced functionality.
While both Square and Lightspeed offer restaurant features, many operators find these general-purpose systems fall short of addressing the unique challenges restaurants face daily. Missed calls during peak hours, inaccurate order taking, and poor integration with existing systems create friction that impacts both revenue and customer satisfaction. AI for restaurants has emerged as a game-changing solution that addresses these specific pain points through specialized technology designed exclusively for food service operations. Loman’s 24/7 AI phone agent handles customer calls around the clock, ensuring no business is lost to busy signals or after-hours inquiries.
Loman integrates seamlessly with popular POS systems like Square, Toast, and Clover, creating a unified ecosystem that enhances rather than replaces existing infrastructure. The system is trained on restaurant menus, policies, and customer preferences, delivering accuracy that generic solutions simply cannot match. Unlike Square and Lightspeed, which require extensive customization to handle restaurant-specific workflows, Loman reduces missed calls, shortens wait times, and improves sales through purpose-built features. Built-in analytics and real-time insights provide operators with actionable data for better decision-making, while fast setup ensures restaurants can be live in under a day—scalable for single locations or multi-unit operations.
Square’s pricing model centers on accessibility, with no monthly fees for its basic POS software. Instead, Square generates revenue primarily through payment processing fees—2.6% plus 10¢ per in-person transaction. This structure makes Square particularly appealing to businesses with lower sales volumes or seasonal operations. Upgraded versions like Square for Retail Plus and Square for Restaurants Plus are available at $60-89 per month, offering enhanced features for growing businesses.
Lightspeed adopts a different approach with subscription-based pricing starting at approximately $69-89 per month (when billed annually) for its basic plan, increasing to $149-269 for more advanced features. These plans include the POS software but not payment processing, which Lightspeed offers separately at rates comparable to Square’s (around 2.6% plus 10¢ per transaction). For businesses processing high volumes, Lightspeed offers custom pricing that may provide better value.
The value proposition differs significantly between these platforms. Square delivers immediate cost savings for small businesses through its free basic plan and transparent pricing model. Conversely, Lightspeed justifies its higher price point through more sophisticated features and specialized functionality. For established businesses with complex needs, Lightspeed’s additional capabilities may ultimately deliver better long-term value despite the higher upfront cost.
When evaluating costs, consider these essential factors beyond basic subscription fees:
Square offers versatile hardware solutions ranging from the basic free mobile card reader to more comprehensive options like the Square Terminal ($299) and Square Register ($799). These devices are designed with simplicity in mind—they work straight out of the box with minimal configuration required. Square’s hardware is proprietary but reasonably priced, with options to suit various business environments from mobile vendors to permanent retail locations. The company frequently offers promotional deals for new merchants, such as free card readers upon signup.
Lightspeed’s hardware approach is more flexible but potentially more complex. The system can run on iPads or desktop computers, with various peripheral options including barcode scanners, receipt printers, and cash drawers. While Lightspeed sells hardware kits directly, they don’t prominently display pricing on their website, instead requiring businesses to contact sales for quotes. This approach may better accommodate businesses with existing hardware they wish to integrate but makes immediate cost comparison more difficult.
A key distinction is that Square’s ecosystem is closed—you must use Square hardware with Square software. Lightspeed offers more flexibility, allowing third-party hardware integration and even third-party payment processing (though often at an additional monthly cost). For businesses with specific hardware requirements or existing equipment investments, Lightspeed’s openness may present advantages. However, Square’s streamlined approach eliminates compatibility issues and simplifies troubleshooting, potentially reducing long-term technical support needs and associated costs.
Consider your long-term hardware needs when making this decision:
Square functions as an all-in-one payment processor, eliminating the need for separate merchant accounts. This integrated approach simplifies setup and management but offers less flexibility—Square is your only processing option. The platform accepts all major credit cards and digital wallets with uniform pricing regardless of card type, making cost predictions straightforward. Notably, Square doesn’t charge chargeback fees, a significant advantage for businesses vulnerable to disputed transactions. Square also offers installment payment options for customers, potentially increasing sales of higher-priced items.
Lightspeed Payments provides competitive processing rates comparable to Square’s, but with a key difference—businesses can opt to use third-party payment processors instead. This flexibility may benefit businesses with existing processor relationships or those seeking better rates through negotiation. However, using external processors typically incurs additional monthly fees with Lightspeed. Unlike Square, Lightspeed does charge a $15 fee for chargebacks, which could impact businesses with frequent disputes.
Both platforms facilitate various payment methods including cash, credit, and digital wallets. Square’s simpler approach works well for businesses seeking streamlined operations with minimal complexity. Lightspeed’s flexibility offers potential cost savings through processor competition but requires more management and potentially more complex reconciliation processes. For businesses processing high transaction volumes, the ability to negotiate rates with different processors through Lightspeed could deliver substantial savings despite higher base subscription costs.
Square offers solid inventory management features that satisfy the needs of many small to medium businesses. Users can track stock across multiple locations, manage vendors, create purchase orders, and set up low-stock alerts. The system allows for bulk inventory uploads and modifications, making initial setup and ongoing management reasonably efficient. For retail businesses, Square supports barcode scanning and printing, though these features may require upgraded plans or additional hardware.
Lightspeed’s inventory management capabilities represent one of its strongest selling points, particularly for retail businesses with complex inventory needs. The system excels in multi-location inventory tracking, serial number tracking, assemblies (creating products from component parts), and sophisticated vendor management. Lightspeed allows businesses to directly import products from over 3,000 supplier catalogs, significantly streamlining the procurement process. The ability to track inventory at a granular level—including size, color, and other variants—makes Lightspeed particularly valuable for apparel retailers and similar businesses with matrix inventory requirements.
For restaurants, both platforms offer specialized inventory features. Square for Restaurants includes recipe costing and ingredient-level tracking, while Lightspeed Restaurant provides similar capabilities with additional features for sophisticated menu management. The key difference lies in depth—Lightspeed typically provides more advanced features and greater customization options, while Square offers a more accessible but somewhat limited approach.
Essential features to evaluate for your business operations:
Square shines in the e-commerce domain by offering a free online store that seamlessly synchronizes with in-person sales operations. Even at the free tier, merchants can list unlimited products, sell through social media platforms, and offer delivery and pickup options. Square’s online platform includes marketing tools like abandoned cart emails and SEO features, with paid tiers adding custom domains and advanced website customization. The platform excels in creating a unified customer experience across channels, with inventory, customer data, and reporting integrated between physical and digital storefronts.
Lightspeed’s approach to e-commerce differs somewhat. While it offers a comprehensive e-commerce platform, its free plan is limited to five products. Paid plans provide more robust features including social media selling capabilities, multi-language support, and international shipping options. Lightspeed’s strengths include its B2B e-commerce capabilities and sophisticated inventory synchronization between online and offline channels, making it particularly valuable for businesses with complex product catalogs or wholesale operations.
Both platforms facilitate omnichannel selling strategies, but Square offers a more accessible entry point for businesses new to online selling. Lightspeed’s e-commerce tools are more powerful but require greater investment to fully utilize. For businesses already conducting significant online sales or planning to develop sophisticated e-commerce operations, Lightspeed’s advanced features may justify the higher cost. However, businesses primarily focused on in-person sales with modest online requirements may find Square’s free e-commerce tools sufficient and more cost-effective.
Square provides comprehensive reporting tools that give business owners insights into sales performance, inventory levels, and customer behavior. The platform offers customizable dashboards displaying key metrics like top-selling items, sales by time of day, and employee performance. Reports can be exported for further analysis, and automated reports can be scheduled for regular delivery. Even on the free plan, Square offers substantial reporting capabilities, though advanced analytics require subscription upgrades.
Lightspeed elevates reporting and analytics to a more sophisticated level. The platform offers over 50 pre-built reports with greater depth and customization options than Square. Lightspeed’s reporting excels in areas like profit margin analysis, vendor performance evaluation, and employee productivity metrics. The system allows for advanced data filtering and comparison across time periods or locations, providing business owners with more nuanced insights for strategic decision-making. Lightspeed also supports daily, weekly, and monthly automated reporting schedules.
The difference between these platforms becomes particularly evident for businesses requiring complex analytics. Lightspeed offers more granular data examination capabilities, especially for inventory performance and profitability analysis. This depth proves invaluable for businesses with slim profit margins or complex inventory management needs. While Square’s reporting tools are sufficient for many small businesses, they may fall short for enterprises requiring sophisticated data analysis to inform strategic planning.
Key reporting capabilities to consider for your business:
Square offers robust customer relationship management (CRM) tools that help businesses build stronger customer connections. The platform automatically creates customer profiles that track purchase history, enabling personalized marketing and service. Square’s built-in marketing tools allow businesses to create email campaigns, design custom promotions, and establish a loyalty program to encourage repeat business. These features are available through add-on services that integrate seamlessly with the POS system, though they incur additional monthly fees based on usage volume.
Lightspeed similarly provides customer management capabilities, storing detailed customer information and purchase histories. The platform’s loyalty features allow businesses to offer store credit, reward points, and special promotions to regular customers. Unlike Square, Lightspeed includes these loyalty features in higher-tier subscription plans rather than charging separately. Lightspeed’s marketing tools integrate with email platforms and social media, enabling targeted promotions based on customer segments and behavior patterns.
Both systems enable businesses to collect customer feedback and track satisfaction metrics, though their approaches differ. Square emphasizes ease of use with templates and automation features that make marketing accessible to non-specialists. Lightspeed offers more customization options but may require greater marketing expertise to fully utilize. For businesses where customer retention and relationship building represent key growth strategies, these features may significantly influence the platform choice.
Square boasts an extensive ecosystem of first-party business tools including payroll, team management, banking services, and inventory management. This native integration creates a seamless experience across business functions. Additionally, Square’s App Marketplace features hundreds of third-party integrations with popular business software in categories like accounting, e-commerce, and customer management. Many small businesses appreciate that they can start with basic Square functionality and gradually add components as they grow, without changing their core POS system.
Lightspeed takes a somewhat different approach to integrations. While offering fewer first-party tools than Square, Lightspeed provides robust API access (though typically only on higher-tier plans) and integrates with numerous third-party solutions. Lightspeed’s integrations tend to focus on specialized industry needs, particularly for retail and restaurant businesses. The platform offers connections to industry-specific tools like advanced restaurant reservation systems or retail supplier networks that may not be available through Square.
The key difference lies in flexibility versus simplicity. Square’s approach provides an easy path to adding functionality within a unified ecosystem, ideal for businesses seeking simplicity and consistency. Lightspeed offers potentially greater customization through third-party integrations and API access, better serving businesses with specialized requirements that Square’s ecosystem might not address. For businesses anticipating unique future needs or planning significant expansion, Lightspeed’s openness to customization may provide an advantage despite the potentially higher implementation complexity.
Consider these integration advantages when choosing your platform:
Square provides support through multiple channels including email, chat, phone support, and an extensive knowledge base. Phone support is available during business hours, while email and chat options offer extended coverage. The platform’s substantial self-help resources include detailed articles, video tutorials, and an active community forum where users can exchange advice. New users particularly appreciate Square’s straightforward setup and intuitive interface, which often reduces the need for technical support during implementation.
Lightspeed distinguishes itself with premium support options, including 24/7 phone and chat support on all plans. New customers receive free onboarding sessions to ensure smooth implementation, and the company assigns dedicated account managers to assist with ongoing needs. This high-touch approach helps businesses maximize their return on investment in the more complex Lightspeed system. The company also provides extensive documentation and training resources, though user reviews suggest the learning curve is steeper than with Square.
Customer experiences with both platforms reveal important distinctions. Square users generally report satisfaction with the platform’s reliability and ease of use, though some mention limitations in reaching live support during peak times. Lightspeed customers frequently praise the quality and availability of technical assistance but occasionally note that the system’s complexity requires more ongoing support. For businesses without dedicated IT staff, Lightspeed’s comprehensive support services may justify its higher cost, particularly during the critical implementation phase and when addressing complex operational challenges.
Choosing between Square and Lightspeed ultimately depends on your business’s specific needs, growth trajectory, and operational priorities. Square presents a compelling option for small to medium-sized businesses seeking an affordable, user-friendly solution with minimal upfront investment. Its free basic plan, integrated payment processing, and intuitive interface make it particularly suitable for startups, seasonal businesses, or enterprises with straightforward operational needs. The ability to add functionality incrementally as your business grows provides flexibility without overwhelming new users.
Lightspeed offers a more sophisticated solution targeting established businesses with complex requirements, particularly in retail and hospitality. Its advanced inventory management, detailed reporting, and industry-specific features justify the higher subscription costs for businesses that can leverage these capabilities to improve efficiency and profitability. The platform’s flexibility in hardware choices and payment processing options may also deliver long-term value for larger operations despite the higher initial investment.
Consider your business’s growth stage, technical expertise, budget constraints, and operational complexity when making this decision. Many businesses find that their needs evolve over time—what works for a startup may become limiting as the enterprise expands. Fortunately, both Square and Lightspeed offer free trials, allowing you to experience their interfaces and evaluate their features before committing. By carefully assessing how each platform aligns with your current requirements and future aspirations, you can select the POS system that will best support your business’s success in today’s dynamic marketplace.
For restaurant operators specifically, consider that while both platforms offer valuable features, specialized solutions like Loman provide targeted functionality that addresses the unique challenges of food service operations. With seamless POS integration, 24/7 AI-powered call handling, and fast implementation, Loman delivers efficiency gains that general-purpose systems often cannot match—whether you operate a single location, manage a chain, or oversee franchise operations.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
