Choosing the right point-of-sale system is a critical decision that impacts every aspect of restaurant operations. Two industry leaders, SpotOn and Toast, continue to dominate conversations among restaurant owners seeking reliable, feature-rich solutions. With technology evolving rapidly and customer expectations rising higher each year, restaurant operators need systems that not only process transactions but also enhance efficiency, improve guest experience, and provide valuable business insights. The competition between these platforms has intensified significantly over the past few years, making the choice even more complex for busy restaurant owners.
SpotOn consistently ranks higher than Toast in real user reviews, demonstrating strong performance across all key metrics. According to Capterra, SpotOn boasts an overall rating of 4.4 compared to Toast’s 4.2. This slight but significant edge extends to specific categories including ease of use (4.3 for both), customer service (SpotOn’s 4.4 vs Toast’s 3.7), features (SpotOn’s 4.3 vs Toast’s 4.1), and value for money (SpotOn’s 4.36 vs Toast’s 3.9). These ratings reveal that while both systems offer competitive functionality, SpotOn users report greater satisfaction, particularly in customer support and overall value.
The higher likelihood to recommend score (SpotOn’s 82% versus Toast’s 75%) further suggests that SpotOn users are generally more satisfied with their experience. This consistent performance across multiple review metrics indicates SpotOn may provide a more well-rounded solution that meets restaurant operators’ expectations more effectively than Toast. Customer testimonials frequently highlight SpotOn’s personalized support and transparency in communications, whereas Toast users occasionally express frustration with customer service responsiveness and pricing transparency issues.
Restaurant functionality sets SpotOn apart in several crucial areas. SpotOn’s interface receives consistently high marks for intuitiveness, with users noting its streamlined design requires minimal training for new staff. The system excels at quick-service operations with fast order entry and modification capabilities. SpotOn’s table management features allow for customization of floor plans by color, shape, and size directly through the POS front end, creating a more visual and intuitive experience for hosts and servers managing seating arrangements.
The platform provides numerous native integrations with popular restaurant management tools, including accounting software, scheduling platforms, inventory management systems, and marketing solutions. SpotOn’s integration philosophy emphasizes quality over quantity, focusing on partnerships that deliver clear operational benefits rather than simply expanding the number of available connections. This approach results in more reliable, better-supported integrations that actually enhance daily operations.
Both SpotOn and Toast offer tiered pricing structures, but their approaches differ significantly. SpotOn provides more transparent pricing with straightforward monthly fees ranging from $65 to $95 per terminal, plus quote-based setup fees. Their transaction fees typically start at 2.99% + $0.20 for card-present transactions, with lower rates of 1.99% + $0.20 for additional services. SpotOn offers one-year contracts, providing flexibility for growing businesses.
Toast’s pricing starts with a free Starter Kit option that includes limited hardware, making it appealing for very small operations. However, their more comprehensive plans start at approximately $90 per month per terminal with quote-based pricing for additional features. Toast typically requires three-year contracts, which represents a significantly longer commitment than SpotOn requires. A notable distinction emerged in 2023 when Toast implemented a controversial 99-cent fee on all online orders over $10, charging this directly to guests.
The backlash was immediate and intense, with many restaurant operators publicly criticizing the company on social media platforms like LinkedIn. While Toast eventually reversed this decision due to customer outrage, the incident left many questioning the company’s approach to pricing transparency and customer consideration. SpotOn’s commitment to fair, transparent pricing—particularly its long history of commission-free online ordering without passing additional fees to consumers—stands in contrast to Toast’s approach and represents a significant value consideration for restaurant operators.
When comparing these platforms to other major competitors, Square offers lower processing fees but charges for many features that SpotOn includes for free. Clover provides extensive hardware options but requires higher initial investments and purchasing through authorized dealers only. Square suits smaller restaurants with its ease of use and free basic features, while Clover appeals to those wanting customizable hardware solutions across multiple business types.
SpotOn’s pricing strategy positions it competitively against both Square and Clover while offering restaurant-specific features that general-purpose systems lack. The transparency in SpotOn’s pricing structure eliminates many of the surprise costs that plague restaurant operators using other platforms. Toast’s pricing complexity, particularly after the fee controversy, continues to create uncertainty for restaurant owners planning their technology budgets.
Hardware compatibility represents a significant divergence between these two POS systems. Toast operates exclusively on Android devices, using proprietary hardware that requires specific purchase through Toast. While Toast’s hardware is durable and purpose-built for restaurant environments, this restriction limits flexibility and may increase costs for restaurants transitioning from other systems.
SpotOn offers greater hardware flexibility, supporting both Android and iOS devices. This cross-platform compatibility allows restaurants to potentially repurpose existing tablets and devices, potentially reducing initial investment costs. SpotOn also provides a range of proprietary hardware options including modern, sleek terminals and handheld devices that enhance aesthetic appeal while providing robust functionality. The hardware decision ultimately depends on restaurant preferences regarding operating systems, existing technology investments, and specific operational needs.
Both systems offer tableside ordering capabilities through mobile devices, enabling servers to send orders directly to the kitchen while remaining with guests. However, SpotOn’s hardware has received particular praise for its intuitive design and ease of use during high-volume service periods. Toast’s Android-only approach may limit options but ensures consistent performance across a controlled ecosystem, while SpotOn’s flexibility allows restaurants to choose hardware that best fits their budget and operational requirements.
Restaurant phone management has become increasingly complex, with missed calls translating directly into lost revenue. Traditional phone systems struggle during peak hours when staff are focused on in-person service. Modern restaurants require solutions that handle calls professionally while maintaining focus on dining room guests. AI for restaurants has emerged as a game-changing technology that addresses these operational challenges effectively.
Loman provides 24/7 AI phone agent services specifically designed for restaurant operations, offering seamless integration with major POS systems including Square, Toast, and Clover. The system is trained on individual restaurant menus, policies, and customer preferences to ensure accurate order taking and reservation booking. Unlike generic phone systems, Loman reduces missed calls during busy periods, shortens customer wait times, and actively works to improve sales through intelligent upselling suggestions. Built-in analytics provide real-time insights that help restaurant owners make better staffing and operational decisions.
Both SpotOn and Toast deliver robust core POS functionality designed specifically for restaurant operations. Their systems include essential features like menu management, order processing, payment handling, table management, and basic reporting capabilities. SpotOn’s strengths include its streamlined design that requires minimal staff training and fast order entry capabilities that excel during busy service periods.
Toast’s strengths include its kitchen display system integration and multi-location management tools, which provide excellent communication between front and back of house operations. Users particularly praise Toast’s ability to keep “staff in check” and “costings in line” through its comprehensive backend management features. Its menu management software allows updates from multiple locations simultaneously, with cloud-based synchronization ensuring consistency across all terminals.
Both systems support split checks, customizable modifiers, and various payment methods. They also offer offline functionality to continue operations during internet outages, though implementation details differ. SpotOn tends to excel in user-friendly interfaces and quick service environments, while Toast’s robust backend features may appeal to operations with complex inventory tracking needs or multiple locations requiring centralized management.
Modern restaurant operations require more than basic POS functionality. SpotOn provides comprehensive reservation management through its appointment system, featuring digital marketing tools and two-way texting for customer communication. This helps reduce no-shows and manage guest expectations effectively. The platform’s review management system consolidates online reviews and provides notifications of new reviews, representing a unique feature particularly valuable for reputation management.
Toast excels in multi-location reporting and inventory management, offering tools that allow restaurant groups to compare performance across venues and implement standardized reporting practices. The system’s analytics platform emphasizes deep-dive capabilities with particular strength in inventory and labor cost reporting. Both platforms integrate with major accounting systems, scheduling tools, and marketing automation platforms, though their approaches to ecosystem development differ significantly.
The pandemic dramatically accelerated the importance of integrated online ordering and delivery capabilities, and both POS systems have responded with comprehensive solutions. However, their approaches and fee structures differ significantly. SpotOn has long offered commission-free online ordering with full POS integration, creating a seamless experience between in-person and digital orders. Their system includes 2-way texting with customers, order pacing controls to manage kitchen workflow, and advanced reporting that treats online orders as an integrated part of overall business performance.
Toast also provides integrated online ordering capabilities with similar features, including QR code ordering options and delivery management. However, Toast’s approach to fees has been more controversial, particularly with the previously mentioned 99-cent guest fee implementation in 2023. While this policy was reversed after significant backlash, it exemplifies a philosophical difference in how the companies approach the balance between platform revenue and customer experience.
Both systems integrate with third-party delivery services like DoorDash and Grubhub, though the implementation details and additional fees vary. SpotOn emphasizes direct ordering through restaurant websites to help operators maintain control over the customer relationship and avoid third-party commission fees. Toast offers similar capabilities but has historically placed less emphasis on commission-free solutions in their marketing and product development priorities.
As restaurant operations increasingly embrace mobile technology, both POS systems have developed features to support evolving service models. SpotOn excels in mobile payment processing and tableside service capabilities through handheld devices that allow servers to take orders and process payments directly at tables. This improves service efficiency and table turnover rates significantly. SpotOn also offers strong mobile management capabilities, allowing owners and managers to monitor performance, adjust menus, and manage operations remotely from smartphones or tablets.
Toast provides similar tableside ordering capabilities through its Toast Go handheld devices, which are purpose-built for restaurant environments. Toast’s digital ordering solutions include self-service kiosks and QR code ordering options that integrate directly with the POS system. Their mobile app provides customers with ordering capabilities and loyalty program integration, enhancing the guest experience while capturing valuable customer data for future marketing efforts.
Data-driven decision making is essential for modern restaurant management, and both POS systems offer comprehensive reporting tools with notable differences in their approaches to data presentation and accessibility. SpotOn’s reporting suite receives particular praise for its intuitive design and real-time data accessibility. The system provides customizable dashboards that highlight key performance indicators most relevant to specific restaurant operations. Users can access these reports from any smartphone device with internet access through SpotOn’s dedicated reporting app.
Toast’s analytics platform emphasizes deep-dive capabilities, with particular strength in inventory and labor cost reporting. Its multi-location reporting features are especially robust, allowing restaurant groups to compare performance across venues and implement standardized reporting practices. Toast users appreciate the ability to group particular locations together for macro management and cohesive real-time reporting. Both systems offer essential sales reporting, labor analysis, menu performance metrics, and inventory tracking capabilities.
The primary difference lies in user experience—SpotOn tends to prioritize accessibility and visual clarity, while Toast offers more granular data analysis capabilities that may appeal to operations with dedicated data analysis resources. SpotOn also offers proactive notifications for significant data spikes or anomalies, helping managers identify potential issues before they become serious problems that impact service quality or profitability.
A POS system’s ability to integrate with other business tools significantly impacts its long-term value and adaptability. SpotOn provides numerous native integrations with popular restaurant management tools, though their ecosystem is somewhat more curated than Toast’s. Toast boasts an exceptionally extensive third-party integration network, with connections to over 70 restaurant technology providers. Their open API flexibility is particularly appealing to restaurants with in-house development teams who can create custom integrations tailored to specific operational needs.
Both systems integrate with major accounting platforms like QuickBooks, popular scheduling tools, and inventory management systems. They also connect with customer relationship management (CRM) platforms and marketing automation tools. The choice between them may depend on whether a restaurant prefers SpotOn’s more curated approach with stronger native capabilities or Toast’s broader ecosystem with greater customization potential. Restaurants with unique operational requirements should verify specific integration availability before making a decision.
Customer support represents one of the most significant differentiators between these two POS providers, with consistent differences appearing in user reviews and satisfaction metrics. SpotOn emphasizes personalized, relationship-based support with dedicated account representatives assigned to each restaurant. This approach ensures support staff develop familiarity with each client’s specific setup and operational needs. Users frequently praise SpotOn’s quick response times, knowledgeable staff, and proactive support even after installation.
Toast’s support model has received more mixed reviews in comparison to platforms like Square and SpotOn. While the company offers 24/7 technical support, users occasionally report longer wait times and inconsistent knowledge levels among support staff. The implementation process includes comprehensive training resources through “Toast University,” though some users note the self-guided nature requires more independent learning compared to SpotOn’s more hands-on approach. Toast’s larger size sometimes results in more standardized support procedures that may feel less personalized to individual restaurant needs.
Both companies provide extensive documentation, training videos, and knowledge bases for self-service support. However, SpotOn’s customer service satisfaction rating (4.4 on Capterra compared to Toast’s 3.7) suggests a significant advantage in this critical area. For restaurants where immediate support during busy service periods is essential, this difference may substantially impact operational continuity and staff satisfaction throughout the implementation process and beyond.
The onboarding experience sets the tone for long-term satisfaction with any POS system. SpotOn provides personalized training and menu setup assistance, helping ensure smooth transitions from previous systems. Their approach includes dedicated account representatives who understand each restaurant’s unique operational requirements and can provide targeted guidance during the learning process. This personalized attention often results in faster adoption rates and fewer operational disruptions during the transition period.
Toast’s training methodology relies more heavily on self-guided learning through their comprehensive online resources. While Toast University provides extensive materials and video tutorials, some restaurant operators prefer the hands-on guidance that SpotOn offers. The choice between these approaches often depends on restaurant staff technical comfort levels and available time for training during busy operational periods.
Choosing between SpotOn and Toast ultimately depends on your restaurant’s specific needs, operational priorities, and growth plans. Based on comprehensive analysis of features, user reviews, and overall value, several clear distinctions emerge to guide your decision-making process. SpotOn represents the superior choice for restaurants prioritizing exceptional customer support, transparent pricing, and user-friendly interfaces that require minimal staff training.
SpotOn particularly excels for restaurants concerned about flexible hardware options, personalized support relationships, and avoiding unexpected fee increases that can impact profitability. Its commission-free online ordering without consumer fees demonstrates a philosophy that aligns well with restaurants focused on delivering value to their guests. The platform’s higher satisfaction ratings across key metrics suggest more consistent performance and better alignment with restaurant operators’ expectations over time.
Toast may better serve restaurants with complex multi-location management needs, those already invested in Android-based hardware, or operations requiring extensive third-party integrations for specialized workflows. Its robust backend reporting and inventory management tools appeal to data-driven operations with dedicated analysis resources and technical staff. However, potential concerns about contract length, customer support responsiveness, and pricing transparency should factor significantly into the decision-making process.
For most independent restaurants and small to medium-sized restaurant groups, SpotOn’s combination of intuitive usability, fair pricing, and exceptional support makes it the more compelling overall choice. The platform’s focus on restaurant-specific needs rather than trying to serve all business types results in features and support that directly address daily operational challenges. Loman AI represents the next evolution in restaurant technology, offering fast setup (live in under a day) and scalable solutions for single locations, chains, or franchises that prioritize efficiency and improved customer experience through intelligent automation.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
