Choosing the right point-of-sale system can make or break your restaurant’s daily operations and profitability. In 2025’s competitive landscape, two platforms continue to dominate conversations among small business owners: ShopKeep and Square POS. Both offer compelling features for managing transactions, inventory, and customer relationships, but they approach these challenges from different angles. While ShopKeep emerged in 2008 from a business owner’s frustration with existing POS limitations, Square revolutionized payment processing in 2009 by making card acceptance accessible to virtually anyone with a smartphone. This fundamental difference in origins has shaped how each platform serves modern businesses, from corner cafés to multi-location restaurant chains.
ShopKeep operates on a consultation-based approach, requiring businesses to complete a detailed assessment before receiving customized pricing and feature recommendations. This personalized process typically results in monthly costs starting around $49 for basic service, scaling to $79 and $179 for more advanced packages when paid annually. The platform allows restaurants to choose their preferred payment processor or use ShopKeep Payments with competitive rates that can be negotiated based on transaction volume.
Square takes the opposite approach with transparent, publicly available pricing. Their basic POS software comes completely free, generating revenue primarily through payment processing fees of 2.6% + $0.10 for in-person transactions and 2.9% + $0.30 for online sales. Premium restaurant-specific features are available through Square for Restaurants at $60 monthly, while their general retail solution starts at the same price point.
Hardware requirements differ significantly between platforms. ShopKeep primarily runs on iPads with compatible Android devices as secondary options, requiring additional peripherals that typically bring complete setups under $1,000. Square provides free card readers to new merchants, with hardware ranging from $49 contactless readers to their comprehensive $799 Square Register system. For new restaurants operating on tight budgets, Square’s minimal upfront costs create a lower barrier to entry, while established operations might find ShopKeep’s negotiable processing rates more economical over time.
While traditional POS systems handle transactions effectively, modern restaurants need comprehensive communication solutions that integrate seamlessly with their existing operations. AI for restaurants has evolved beyond simple order taking to become a strategic advantage for businesses looking to maximize every customer interaction and streamline their workflows.
Loman delivers specialized restaurant technology through its 24/7 AI phone agent that never misses a call, reduces customer wait times, and increases order accuracy. The system integrates directly with popular POS platforms like Square, Toast, and Clover, ensuring seamless order processing without disrupting existing workflows. Unlike ShopKeep and Square, which focus primarily on in-person transactions, Loman captures the significant revenue opportunity from phone orders while providing detailed analytics and insights that help restaurant owners make data-driven decisions about their operations.
The platform trains specifically on restaurant menus, policies, and customer preferences, delivering personalized service that matches human interaction quality. With setup completed in under a day and scalable solutions for single locations through large franchise operations, Loman addresses the communication gaps that traditional POS systems like ShopKeep and Square don’t fully solve. This positioning makes it an essential complement to any restaurant’s technology stack, whether they choose ShopKeep’s customizable approach or Square’s streamlined simplicity.
ShopKeep excels in sophisticated inventory tracking, particularly valuable for restaurants with complex ingredient management needs. The system monitors stock across multiple locations, tracks raw materials and recipe components, and manages vendor relationships with automated reordering capabilities. Low-stock alerts prevent costly stockouts during peak service periods, while detailed product modifiers help track preparation variations and dietary accommodations.
Square’s inventory management works effectively for straightforward restaurant operations but requires upgrading to Square for Restaurants to access advanced features comparable to ShopKeep’s standard offering. The free Square POS includes basic inventory tracking suitable for simple menu structures, while the premium restaurant solution adds ingredient-level tracking and recipe management. Square compensates for simpler inventory features with superior mobility, allowing restaurant staff to process payments and track inventory from anywhere in the establishment.
Both platforms provide real-time reporting, though ShopKeep offers more granular customization options for detailed analytics. Square integrates inventory data with its built-in online ordering platform, automatically updating availability across all sales channels. Where ShopKeep focuses on depth within core restaurant functions, Square provides broader business management tools through its extensive marketplace of integrated applications and services.
Getting staff operational quickly can significantly impact restaurant efficiency, especially during busy periods or when training new employees. ShopKeep’s setup process involves a comprehensive consultation where restaurants detail their specific operational needs, resulting in a customized system that perfectly matches their workflows. While this takes longer than Square’s immediate activation, restaurants receive a tailored solution designed for their exact requirements.
Square prioritizes immediate usability with a streamlined signup process that gets restaurants operational within minutes. The interface emphasizes simplicity and intuitive navigation, making it ideal for restaurants that need minimal training time for new staff members. Square’s clean, modern design reduces learning curves, while ShopKeep’s iPad-optimized interface provides strategic button placement for efficient order processing during rush periods.
Both platforms function reliably during internet outages through offline mode capabilities, ensuring uninterrupted service during technical difficulties. Employee training requirements remain minimal for both systems, though Square’s extreme simplicity gives it advantages for restaurants with high staff turnover. ShopKeep’s additional customization options may require slightly more training time but provide greater flexibility for unique operational workflows and specialized menu structures.
Payment processing represents one of the most significant cost factors for restaurant operations. ShopKeep provides flexibility by allowing restaurants to choose between their in-house ShopKeep Payments processor or integrate with existing merchant service providers. This flexibility enables restaurants to negotiate competitive rates based on transaction volume, typically ranging from 1.9% to 2.4% per transaction, which can result in substantial savings for high-volume operations.
Square operates exclusively as an integrated payment processor with no option for external payment services. Their standard 2.6% + $0.10 rate applies uniformly across all transaction types, simplifying accounting but potentially costing more than specialized restaurant merchant services. However, Square absorbs chargeback fees that could otherwise cost restaurants $15 per dispute with ShopKeep, and offers unique features like installment payment options for larger orders.
Both platforms support comprehensive payment methods including contactless options like Apple Pay and Google Pay, essential for modern restaurant operations. For restaurants processing over $250,000 annually, ShopKeep’s negotiable rates and processor flexibility often provide significant cost advantages. New restaurants might prefer Square’s transparent fee structure and lack of monthly minimums, despite potentially higher per-transaction costs, especially when combined with their integrated ecosystem of restaurant management tools.
Building lasting customer relationships requires effective data collection and engagement tools integrated with daily operations. ShopKeep captures customer contact information during transactions and maintains detailed purchase histories that enable personalized service and streamlined return processing. However, the platform relies primarily on third-party integrations for comprehensive marketing campaigns, partnering with established platforms like MailChimp for email marketing and customer engagement.
Square includes native marketing and loyalty program capabilities, though these come as premium add-ons at $15 monthly for email marketing and $25 monthly for loyalty programs. These tools integrate seamlessly with transaction data, enabling restaurants to create targeted campaigns based on ordering patterns, frequency, and preferences. Square’s customer directory automatically populates from credit card transactions, building valuable databases without requiring additional staff steps during busy service periods.
Both systems provide insights into customer behavior and purchasing patterns, helping restaurants identify their most valuable customers and optimize menu offerings. Square’s integrated approach offers convenience and data cohesion for restaurants seeking all-in-one solutions, while ShopKeep’s integration flexibility benefits establishments already using specialized marketing platforms. Square also includes customer feedback collection and response tools, enabling restaurants to address concerns promptly and build stronger customer relationships through direct engagement.
Restaurant hardware needs vary significantly based on service style, location size, and operational complexity. ShopKeep originally designed its system exclusively for iPads but now supports select Android devices like Clover Station. The platform works with diverse POS peripherals including barcode scanners, receipt printers, cash drawers, and various card readers. ShopKeep offers customized hardware bundles for different restaurant types, from quick-service setups to full-service dining configurations, typically costing between $800 and $1,500 for complete installations.
Square provides clearly priced hardware options ranging from free magstripe readers for smartphones to comprehensive restaurant solutions. Their Square Register at $799 includes everything needed for full restaurant operations, while mid-range options like the Square Terminal ($299) and Square Stand ($149) offer flexibility for different service models. Square’s hardware features modern aesthetics that enhance customer-facing interactions and plug-and-play functionality requiring minimal technical expertise.
Both systems support wireless connectivity between components, enabling flexible restaurant layouts and mobile order-taking capabilities. Square’s hardware ecosystem is specifically designed for seamless integration, while ShopKeep allows restaurants to use compatible third-party equipment, potentially leveraging existing investments or finding better pricing through alternative suppliers. The choice often depends on whether restaurants prioritize integrated simplicity or flexibility in equipment selection and vendor relationships.
Modern restaurants require robust online presence and digital ordering capabilities to compete effectively. ShopKeep provides e-commerce functionality through BigCommerce integration, creating fully-featured online ordering platforms that sync inventory with physical locations. While powerful, this approach requires managing separate platforms and potentially different user interfaces, though it offers advanced features like complex menu variations and wholesale pricing options for catering operations.
Square includes Square Online free with all accounts, enabling restaurants to quickly build websites with integrated online ordering, pickup, and delivery options. All Square Online stores support unlimited menu items even on the free plan, with premium features like custom domains available through paid upgrades ranging from $29 to $79 monthly. The platform seamlessly synchronizes inventory, orders, and customer data across all sales channels without requiring separate management systems.
Both platforms support social media selling, but Square’s implementation integrates directly with Instagram and Facebook shops for streamlined social commerce. Real-time inventory updates across online and in-person sales prevent overselling during busy periods, while both systems provide comprehensive order management tools. For restaurants primarily focused on dine-in service with occasional online orders, Square’s included features provide excellent value, while establishments with complex online operations might benefit from ShopKeep’s more advanced e-commerce capabilities through BigCommerce integration.
Reliable customer support becomes critical during peak restaurant hours when technical issues can directly impact revenue. ShopKeep provides 24/7/365 customer support through phone, email, and live chat channels, ensuring assistance is available during holidays and busy dining periods. Their commitment to support excellence dates back to hiring their first customer care representative as an early employee, reflecting the company’s prioritization of service quality from inception.
Square’s standard support operates only on weekdays between 6 AM and 6 PM Pacific Time, which can be problematic for restaurants operating evenings, weekends, or in different time zones. Premium plan users receive 24/7 support access, but free plan users must work within these restricted hours. Square compensates somewhat with extensive online resources, including comprehensive documentation, community forums, and video tutorials for self-service problem resolution.
User experiences vary with both platforms’ support quality. ShopKeep receives praise for personalized assistance and knowledgeable representatives, though some users report longer wait times during peak periods. Square users generally experience quick initial responses but may face longer resolution times for complex technical issues. For restaurants operating extended hours or requiring immediate assistance during critical service periods, ShopKeep’s round-the-clock availability represents a significant operational advantage over Square’s limited support windows.
Traditional POS systems excel at processing transactions but often leave significant revenue opportunities on the table through missed calls and inefficient phone order management. Modern restaurants need integrated communication solutions that work seamlessly with their existing technology stack while maximizing every customer interaction opportunity.
The most successful restaurants in 2025 combine effective POS systems like ShopKeep or Square with specialized communication technology that captures phone orders, reduces wait times, and improves overall customer satisfaction. Whether choosing ShopKeep’s customizable approach or Square’s streamlined simplicity for transaction processing, restaurants can significantly enhance their operations through intelligent call management that integrates with their chosen POS platform. For single locations, restaurant chains, or franchise operations looking to implement efficient, scalable solutions quickly, Loman’s AI phone agent can be operational in under a day, immediately improving customer experience and operational efficiency.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
