Point-of-sale systems have become the backbone of modern retail operations, transforming how businesses manage transactions, inventory, and customer relationships. With the retail technology landscape evolving rapidly, selecting the right POS system can make or break your operational efficiency and growth potential. Two leading contenders dominate this space: Shopify POS and Square POS, each offering distinct advantages for different business models. The stakes are high when choosing between these platforms, as your decision will impact everything from daily operations to long-term scalability. This comprehensive analysis examines both systems across critical business dimensions to help you make an informed choice that aligns with your current needs and future ambitions.
Understanding the cost structure of each platform reveals fundamental differences in their business models and target markets. Square takes a freemium approach, offering basic POS functionality at no monthly cost while charging transaction fees starting at 2.6% + 10¢ for in-person payments. This model appeals to budget-conscious small businesses that want to minimize fixed expenses. Their premium features require subscriptions to specialized plans like Square for Retail at $60 per month per location, or Square for Restaurants beginning at $60 monthly per location with additional costs for advanced features.
Shopify operates on a subscription-first model, requiring a basic ecommerce plan starting at $39 monthly to access POS Lite features. Advanced retail capabilities demand an additional Shopify POS Pro subscription at $89 per month per location. While this appears more expensive upfront, Shopify compensates with competitive transaction fees starting at 2.4% + 0¢ on their Advanced plan. The platform also provides flexibility by allowing third-party payment processors, though this incurs additional fees ranging from 0.5% to 2% depending on your plan level.
The real cost consideration extends beyond monthly fees to include hardware requirements and transaction volume calculations. Square provides a free magstripe reader for new merchants, while Shopify requires hardware purchases from day one. High-volume businesses often discover that Shopify’s lower per-transaction costs offset the higher monthly fees, making it more economical despite the steeper initial investment.
Businesses processing significant monthly volumes should carefully calculate total costs across both models. A restaurant processing $20,000 monthly might save hundreds of dollars annually with Shopify’s lower transaction rates, while a seasonal boutique with sporadic sales might benefit from Square’s minimal fixed costs during slower periods.
Hardware compatibility and availability represent crucial factors that can influence your operational workflow and startup costs. Square maintains a significant advantage by providing free hardware to new merchants, including their basic magstripe reader that enables immediate payment acceptance. Their hardware ecosystem extends to more sophisticated devices like the Square Terminal at $299, the comprehensive Square Register at $799, and the recently introduced Square Handheld with built-in barcode scanning capabilities.
Shopify’s hardware lineup includes the POS Go device at $399, the Tap & Chip Reader at $49, and various accessories including iPad stands and receipt printers. The absence of free starter hardware requires initial investment but reflects Shopify’s focus on more established businesses. Both platforms now support Tap to Pay on iPhone functionality, eliminating hardware requirements for basic contactless payments on compatible iOS devices.
Compatibility considerations reveal strategic differences between the platforms. Square hardware integrates exclusively with Square’s payment processing, creating a closed but streamlined ecosystem. Shopify offers greater flexibility, supporting integration with third-party payment processors alongside their native hardware solutions. This flexibility proves valuable for businesses with existing payment processor relationships or specific integration requirements.
Square’s hardware variety shines for specialized operations like restaurants requiring kitchen display systems or appointment-based businesses needing customer-facing displays. Shopify’s hardware focuses on retail environments with strong ecommerce integration, making it ideal for omnichannel operations where online and offline sales data must synchronize seamlessly.
Inventory management capabilities reveal each platform’s core strengths and target audience preferences. Shopify POS excels in omnichannel inventory management, providing real-time synchronization across all sales channels to ensure accurate stock counts regardless of transaction location. The platform supports unlimited SKUs, product variants, and custom attributes, accommodating businesses with complex product catalogs. Shopify POS Pro adds advanced features including stock transfers between locations, purchase order management, and detailed inventory reporting.
Square offers solid inventory tracking on their free plan, including basic stock monitoring and low stock alerts that meet most small business requirements. Advanced features like vendor management, purchase order creation, and COGS tracking require upgrading to Square for Retail. One limitation involves item restrictions based on subscription levels, while Shopify allows unlimited products across all plans.
Both platforms support bulk inventory imports via CSV files, though Shopify’s inventory management integrates more deeply with its ecommerce platform. This integration enables sophisticated scenarios like reserving online inventory for in-store pickup or automatically updating product availability across multiple sales channels. Square’s approach works well for primarily in-person businesses with straightforward inventory needs but may prove limiting for complex omnichannel operations.
Restaurant owners struggling with missed calls and inefficient order-taking processes now have a game-changing solution that outperforms traditional POS systems in customer interaction management. While Shopify POS and Square POS excel at transaction processing and inventory management, they don’t address the critical challenge of phone-based customer interactions that drive restaurant revenue. Modern restaurants need specialized tools that complement their existing POS infrastructure rather than replacing it entirely.
Loman’s 24/7 AI phone agent transforms how restaurants handle customer calls, seamlessly integrating with popular POS systems like Square, Toast, and Clover to create a unified operational ecosystem. The system learns restaurant menus, policies, and customer preferences to provide accurate information and take orders with precision that matches human staff performance. This AI for restaurants technology reduces missed calls that typically cost establishments thousands in lost revenue while shortening wait times and improving overall customer satisfaction. Built-in analytics provide real-time insights into call patterns, order trends, and customer preferences that help owners make data-driven decisions about menu optimization and staffing needs.
The platform addresses gaps that neither Shopify POS nor Square POS can fill, particularly around call handling and customer service automation. While these traditional POS systems excel at in-person transactions and basic online ordering, Loman specializes in the voice interaction layer that remains crucial for restaurant operations. Fast setup allows restaurants to go live in under a day, and the system scales effortlessly from single locations to complex multi-location operations or franchise systems. This specialization means restaurant owners can maintain their preferred POS system while adding sophisticated call management capabilities that directly impact revenue and operational efficiency.
Payment processing represents a fundamental distinction between these platforms, affecting everything from transaction costs to operational flexibility. Square functions as both POS provider and payment processor, requiring exclusive use of Square Payments while creating a streamlined, integrated experience. In-person transaction fees start at 2.6% + 10¢, with modest reductions available on premium plans. This closed-loop approach simplifies setup and support but limits merchant flexibility in payment processor selection.
Shopify offers dual approaches through Shopify Payments alongside support for over 100 third-party payment processors. Transaction fees vary by subscription tier, reaching as low as 2.4% + 0¢ for in-person transactions on the Advanced plan. However, using third-party processors incurs additional transaction fees ranging from 0.5% to 2% depending on your Shopify plan level. This flexibility benefits businesses with existing payment processor relationships or specific processing requirements.
Both platforms support comprehensive payment methods including credit and debit cards, mobile wallets like Apple Pay and Google Pay, and tap-to-pay functionality. Standard deposits typically process within 1-2 business days, with instant deposit options available for additional fees when immediate fund access is critical.
Chargeback and dispute handling processes differ meaningfully between platforms. Square automatically manages disputes but holds disputed funds during resolution, which can impact cash flow for smaller businesses. Shopify provides more hands-on merchant guidance through evidence submission while covering chargeback fees under specific conditions, offering better support for businesses frequently dealing with disputed transactions.
Ecommerce capabilities reveal Shopify’s core advantage as an established online commerce platform first and POS system second. The native integration between Shopify’s online store and POS creates unified commerce experiences where inventory, customers, and orders synchronize automatically across channels. This eliminates manual reconciliation needs and enables sophisticated services like buy online, pickup in-store (BOPIS) or ship-from-store without additional software complexity.
Square’s ecommerce functionality has evolved through Square Online, offering free basic online stores that integrate with POS systems. However, Square Online lacks the customization depth and advanced features available through Shopify’s platform. While adequate for simple online selling requirements, businesses with complex ecommerce needs may find Square Online limiting in design flexibility, international capabilities, and marketing tool sophistication.
Shopify facilitates selling across multiple channels including social media platforms, online marketplaces, and in-person events, all managed from a unified backend. Customer profiles remain consistent across touchpoints, enabling personalized experiences regardless of interaction channel. Square supports multi-channel selling but with fewer integration options and less sophisticated customer data management.
User experience considerations directly impact staff training costs and operational efficiency, making interface design and workflow optimization crucial evaluation factors. Square POS built its reputation on exceptional simplicity, offering intuitive interfaces that new employees master quickly with minimal training investment. The clean, straightforward design prioritizes checkout speed, making it particularly effective for high-volume environments or businesses experiencing frequent staff turnover. Account creation, app download, and payment acceptance can happen within minutes of signup.
Shopify POS provides a polished, professional interface that integrates seamlessly with the broader Shopify ecosystem while offering greater customization options. Merchants can tailor checkout experiences to specific workflows through features like the “smart grid” that creates custom button layouts for common actions. However, this flexibility requires more comprehensive staff training and represents a steeper learning curve than Square’s simplified approach.
Both systems provide offline functionality during internet outages, though with different operational limitations. Square stores offline payments and processes them automatically upon reconnection, while Shopify requires manual synchronization after connectivity returns. Mobile capabilities also vary, with Square’s app performing consistently across iOS and Android devices, while Shopify POS delivers more comprehensive experiences on iOS with somewhat limited Android functionality.
Businesses already using Shopify’s ecommerce platform will find POS interfaces familiar, reducing transition time and training requirements. Square’s standalone approach requires no prior knowledge but lacks the unified ecosystem experience that Shopify provides. First-time merchants typically adopt Square more quickly, while businesses with complex operational requirements often appreciate Shopify’s advanced capabilities despite additional complexity.
Customer support quality significantly impacts POS system experiences, particularly during critical business periods when technical issues can directly affect revenue. Shopify distinguishes itself with 24/7 live support across all subscription plans, providing merchants round-the-clock assistance via phone, email, and live chat. This comprehensive support proves invaluable for businesses operating outside standard hours or across multiple time zones. Shopify maintains extensive knowledge bases, video tutorials, and community forums where merchants find solutions or connect with other users.
Square’s support structure varies by subscription level, with free plans receiving limited customer service primarily during standard business hours on weekdays. Premium subscribers access priority support with faster response times, though without 24/7 availability. Square compensates through exceptional self-service resources including comprehensive help centers, detailed guides, and active community forums where merchants share solutions and workarounds.
Both platforms provide onboarding assistance, though Shopify offers more personalized setup support for new merchants, especially on higher-tier plans. Data migration tools help businesses transition from other systems, with Shopify providing more robust options for importing complex product catalogs and customer information.
Developer resources differ substantially between platforms. Shopify’s extensive API documentation and larger developer community facilitate custom integrations and modifications for businesses with specific technical requirements. Square offers robust developer tools but operates within a more limited ecosystem, potentially constraining advanced customization needs.
Third-party integration capabilities can dramatically expand POS functionality to meet specialized business requirements, making app ecosystems crucial for long-term platform viability. Shopify maintains substantial advantages through its App Store containing over 8,000 applications, including hundreds designed specifically for POS operation enhancement. These apps extend core functionality to include advanced loyalty programs, appointment scheduling, rental management, sophisticated inventory control, and specialized reporting tools, allowing extensive customization without custom development requirements.
Square’s App Marketplace offers approximately 300 integrations covering essential business needs but with significantly less variety than Shopify’s ecosystem. Square focuses on quality partnerships with major service providers in accounting, inventory, and customer management, including QuickBooks, Xero, and various industry-specific solutions. While more limited in scope, Square’s integrations typically undergo thorough testing to ensure reliable performance and seamless user experiences.
Both platforms provide open APIs for custom integrations, though Shopify’s larger, more established developer community results in better documentation and support resources for custom development projects. Businesses with standard operational requirements may find Square’s curated integration selection sufficient, while merchants with unique workflows or specialized industry needs benefit from Shopify’s broader ecosystem.
Scalability represents a crucial long-term consideration that can determine whether your chosen POS system supports or constrains business growth over time. Shopify demonstrates exceptional scalability through clear growth paths from small operations to enterprise-level businesses. The tiered structure progresses from basic commerce needs to advanced features as operations expand, culminating in Shopify Plus for enterprise-level requirements. This scalability extends to multiple store locations, with POS Pro supporting unlimited registers and staff accounts while maintaining performance during high-traffic periods.
Square offers scaling capabilities with some limitations compared to Shopify’s comprehensive approach. The platform supports multiple locations and provides specialized software for different business types as operations grow. However, Square’s enterprise offerings lack the depth of Shopify’s solutions, potentially creating transition points for rapidly expanding businesses. Square excels at scaling small to medium operations but may require platform migrations for businesses reaching enterprise scale.
International expansion represents another scalability dimension where platforms diverge significantly. Shopify supports selling in over 130 currencies with localization features for global commerce, while Square operates in only eight countries, limiting viability for businesses with international ambitions. Shopify’s extensive payment gateway options also facilitate easier expansion into new markets with local payment preferences.
Data management capabilities similarly diverge as businesses expand their operations. Shopify’s robust reporting and analytics provide increasingly sophisticated insights as data sets grow, supporting data-driven decision making at enterprise scale. Square offers solid analytics requiring premium subscriptions for advanced reporting that may not match Shopify’s depth for complex multi-location operations.
The choice between Shopify POS and Square POS ultimately depends on your business model, growth trajectory, and operational priorities rather than a one-size-fits-all recommendation. Square represents the superior choice for businesses prioritizing affordability and operational simplicity, with its free basic plan, intuitive interface, and transparent pricing making it ideal for small retailers, cafes, or service providers operating primarily in physical locations. The minimal upfront investment and rapid setup process particularly appeal to new businesses or those operating with tight budget constraints.
Shopify POS stands out for businesses operating across multiple sales channels or maintaining significant online presence, where seamless integration between physical and digital operations creates efficiencies that justify higher subscription costs. Businesses with complex inventory requirements, multiple locations, or international expansion plans benefit from Shopify’s advanced capabilities and proven scalability. The platform’s extensive app ecosystem also provides superior adaptability to specialized requirements and unique operational workflows.
Consider your business’s current operational needs while planning for anticipated growth patterns. Startups might begin with Square’s cost-effective solution and migrate later, while businesses anticipating rapid expansion might justify Shopify’s higher initial investment to avoid disruptive platform changes. Transaction volume calculations prove particularly important, as high-volume merchants often achieve savings through Shopify’s lower transaction fees despite higher monthly costs. Both platforms offer free trials that allow hands-on evaluation with actual business processes and staff workflows before making final commitments.
For restaurant owners specifically, consider how traditional POS limitations around call management and customer service automation might impact your operations. Loman provides a fast-to-implement, scalable solution that complements existing POS systems whether you choose Shopify, Square, or another platform, ensuring that phone-based customer interactions don’t become operational bottlenecks as your business grows from single locations to chains or franchises seeking improved efficiency and enhanced customer experiences.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
