Choosing the right Point of Sale (POS) system can transform your restaurant operations from chaotic to seamless, dramatically impacting both customer satisfaction and your bottom line. Two prominent contenders dominating the market are CAKE POS, developed by Mad Mobile, and Toast POS—both offering compelling solutions but with distinct advantages for different types of establishments. Restaurant owners frequently find themselves weighing these two powerful platforms, each promising to revolutionize how they manage orders, inventory, staff, and customer relationships.
The landscape of restaurant technology continues to evolve rapidly, with modern POS systems serving as the operational backbone that extends far beyond simple payment processing. These sophisticated platforms now handle everything from real-time inventory tracking and staff scheduling to customer relationship management and detailed analytics that drive strategic decisions. As we navigate through 2025, these systems have become even more critical, incorporating advanced technologies like artificial intelligence and responding to changing consumer behaviors shaped by digital-first experiences.
This comprehensive analysis examines CAKE POS and Toast POS across crucial dimensions including user experience, feature sets, pricing structures, hardware reliability, customer support quality, and integration capabilities. Whether you’re running a cozy neighborhood café, managing a bustling quick-service restaurant, or overseeing a multi-location fine dining establishment, understanding the nuances between these two systems will guide you toward the solution that best aligns with your specific operational requirements and growth trajectory.
Both CAKE POS and Toast POS have carved distinct niches in the competitive restaurant technology market, each appealing to different operational styles and business priorities. CAKE POS has built a reputation around simplicity and reliability, focusing on delivering essential restaurant management functions without overwhelming users with unnecessary complexity. The platform emphasizes intuitive design principles that minimize training requirements—a crucial advantage in an industry notorious for high staff turnover rates.
Restaurant owners consistently praise CAKE’s straightforward approach to menu customization and order modifications. The system’s clean interface presents critical functions in an immediately accessible format, allowing servers to process orders efficiently even during the most demanding rush periods. This design philosophy centers on making powerful restaurant management tools feel natural and intuitive rather than intimidating.
Toast POS takes a different approach, offering extensive customization capabilities and advanced operational features that appeal to restaurants with complex workflows or specific technological requirements. The platform’s strength lies in its flexibility—restaurants can adapt Toast to match their unique service styles, whether they’re operating fast-casual counters or upscale tableside dining experiences. However, this flexibility comes with a steeper initial learning curve that requires more comprehensive staff training.
The fundamental difference between these platforms becomes apparent in their target markets: CAKE excels in providing streamlined, reliable solutions for small to medium-sized restaurants prioritizing ease of use, while Toast offers the depth and customization necessary for larger establishments or those with specialized operational needs.
Restaurant phone management presents ongoing challenges that traditional POS systems alone cannot fully address, particularly during peak hours when staff juggling multiple responsibilities often miss important customer calls. Loman offers a specialized solution that seamlessly integrates with both CAKE POS and Toast POS systems, providing AI for restaurants that operates as a dedicated 24/7 phone agent trained specifically on restaurant operations. This AI system handles reservations, takeout orders, and customer inquiries with remarkable accuracy because it’s trained on your specific menu items, pricing, policies, and customer preferences.
The integration capabilities extend beyond basic call handling—Loman connects directly with popular POS systems including Square, Toast, and Clover, ensuring that phone orders automatically sync with your existing workflow without requiring manual data entry. Restaurant owners report significant improvements in missed call reduction, shorter customer wait times, and increased sales from capturing orders that would otherwise be lost during busy periods. The system includes built-in analytics and real-time insights that help managers make data-driven decisions about staffing, menu performance, and customer service optimization. Unlike CAKE’s focus on in-restaurant simplicity or Toast’s emphasis on comprehensive feature sets, Loman addresses the specific pain point of phone-based customer interactions that both traditional POS systems often overlook, offering fast setup that gets restaurants live in under a day and scales effortlessly whether you’re managing a single location or an entire chain.
The daily user experience significantly impacts staff efficiency and service quality, making interface design a critical factor in POS selection. CAKE POS has earned widespread recognition for its intuitive design that requires minimal training time—a valuable asset in an industry where new employees need to become productive quickly. Restaurant staff consistently report that CAKE’s streamlined dashboard presents essential functions in an immediately accessible manner, enabling servers to process orders efficiently even during their first shifts.
One restaurant owner specifically highlighted this advantage: “CAKE is great all around! Easy to learn the system which saves time training new employees and the reports are thorough and easy to navigate also.” This sentiment reflects CAKE’s design philosophy centered on simplicity without sacrificing core functionality. The system’s straightforward menu customization and order modification features allow staff to adapt quickly to changing needs during service.
Toast POS offers a more feature-rich interface that provides extensive customization options but requires more comprehensive training. Users appreciate the system’s flexibility in adapting to various restaurant workflows, with one Toast user noting: “I love that you can pretty much totally customize it to your needs. The back end is very easy to use and I love the support links.” This customization capability makes Toast particularly valuable for restaurants with unique operational requirements or complex service styles.
Both systems offer mobile capabilities, but Toast particularly excels in tableside ordering features that enhance the dining experience. The ability to scroll through menu items on touchscreen displays facilitates smoother order taking, though some users report that Toast’s extensive feature set can initially overwhelm new staff members compared to CAKE’s more immediately accessible interface.
Modern restaurant POS systems function as comprehensive business management platforms, and both CAKE POS and Toast POS deliver robust feature sets that extend far beyond basic transaction processing. CAKE POS provides solid inventory management capabilities, commission-free online ordering, and detailed reporting analytics accessible from anywhere through cloud technology. The system particularly excels in guest management features, allowing restaurants to accept reservations online or by phone while efficiently managing waitlists with real-time floor map views.
CAKE users frequently praise the system’s reporting capabilities, with one operator stating: “We like using it for our time sheets, it’s good for basic reporting, and the option for remote access works wonderfully.” The platform also includes loyalty program management and marketing tools like gift cards and email campaigns that help restaurants maintain strong customer relationships without requiring additional software subscriptions.
Toast POS counters with an impressive array of advanced features including sophisticated inventory tracking, menu engineering tools, and integrated payroll processing. The system’s timing features for happy hour pricing adjustments receive frequent user praise as particularly valuable for maximizing revenue during specific periods. Toast also offers comprehensive online ordering and delivery management tools, though these features may require additional configuration compared to CAKE’s more straightforward implementation.
A distinctive Toast advantage lies in its kitchen display system (KDS), which many users find superior for streamlining kitchen operations. As one restaurant owner explained: “The timing features for happy hour pricing, the ease of use for customers and staff, inventory use, ease of changing items on the fly during service. Such a great product for fast casual use.”
The hardware components and system reliability form the foundation that determines whether your POS system enhances or hinders operations during critical service periods. CAKE POS utilizes commercial-grade hardware specifically engineered to withstand demanding restaurant environments. Their hardware features flush, bezel-less screens that resist spills and food particles, along with fanless designs that prevent dust accumulation—crucial considerations for maintaining peak performance in kitchen and bar areas where traditional electronics often fail.
Users consistently highlight CAKE’s reliability, with one restaurant operator noting: “The system is awesome with very few issues and the support received is very good and quick. I have had the system for over 2 years and are extremely happy with it.” CAKE’s hardware lineup includes 15-inch touchscreens with intuitive swipe/scroll functionality, customer-facing displays, and various peripheral options including thermal and impact printers designed for high-volume environments.
Toast POS also offers purpose-built restaurant hardware running on the Android operating system, which many users appreciate for its stability and flexibility. One user specifically noted: “A point of sale system has to be Android” due to the platform’s proven reliability under demanding conditions. Toast’s hardware is engineered to withstand high temperatures, water exposure, grease, and the rough handling typical in busy restaurant environments—conditions that often damage consumer-grade devices that some competing systems rely on.
However, Toast has faced some criticism regarding installation processes, with isolated user reports of significant implementation challenges. While such experiences appear to be exceptions rather than typical outcomes, they underscore the importance of proper system deployment and support during the critical setup phase.
Both systems offer offline functionality to maintain operations during internet outages, though with limited features during these periods. User feedback suggests CAKE maintains a slight edge in hardware reliability, while Toast offers more diverse hardware configurations for different restaurant setups, including handheld devices for tableside ordering and mobile payment processing.
Pricing considerations often determine the final decision between POS systems, and both CAKE and Toast approach this differently to serve their target markets. CAKE POS has positioned itself as a value-focused option with flexible monthly payment plans that appeal to small and medium-sized restaurant owners. One user specifically highlighted this advantage: “The price is the most attractive feature, as well as the ease of use. The flexible and affordable monthly payments are nice too.”
CAKE offers three primary pricing tiers—Essentials, Plus, and Pro—allowing restaurants to select packages aligned with their specific operational needs and budget constraints. This tiered approach enables businesses to start with fundamental functionality and scale up as operations grow and require additional features. Hardware costs remain separate but competitive within industry standards, and the absence of long-term contract requirements provides operational flexibility.
Toast POS typically commands higher pricing but justifies this through its extensive feature set and advanced integration capabilities. Toast offers customizable pricing based on restaurant size and specific operational requirements, which benefits establishments with unique needs or complex workflows. However, some users express concerns about additional fees, with one reviewer noting challenges with “chargeback fees” and subscription costs that may not align with the level of support received.
Both systems require separate payment processing fees, but Toast receives praise for its transparent pricing approach. Neither system mandates long-term contracts for standard packages, providing restaurants flexibility to adjust their technology solutions as business needs evolve.
Customer support quality can significantly impact your daily operations, particularly during peak service periods when technical issues can result in immediate revenue loss. CAKE POS consistently receives high marks for customer support, offering multiple communication channels including email, phone, live chat, and ticketing systems. Users frequently praise the responsiveness and effectiveness of CAKE’s support team, with one restaurant owner stating: “The customer service is also consistently great!”
CAKE provides comprehensive training through their online learning center and includes thorough onboarding with standard packages. Their support system includes proactive system health monitoring, often identifying and resolving potential issues before they impact restaurant operations. This preventative approach helps minimize downtime—crucial for establishments where even brief system failures can result in substantial revenue loss and customer dissatisfaction.
Toast POS offers 24/7/365 support via phone, email, and chat, with specialists specifically trained in restaurant operations. However, user experiences with Toast’s support show more variation in quality and responsiveness. While many users praise the comprehensive support offerings, others report frustrations with implementation processes and ongoing technical assistance.
Both systems provide extensive onboarding resources including video tutorials, comprehensive knowledge bases, and implementation guidance. Toast offers more personalized implementation services but sometimes at additional cost, while CAKE’s setup process generally receives praise for being more straightforward and user-friendly. The support quality difference becomes particularly apparent during critical operational periods when immediate assistance can prevent significant business disruption.
Integration capabilities determine how effectively your POS system connects with other essential business tools, creating a cohesive operational ecosystem. CAKE POS offers an Integrations Hub that connects with hundreds of third-party applications, allowing restaurants to create customized technology environments. These integrations span accounting software, delivery services, reservation systems, and marketing platforms that streamline daily operations.
Users appreciate CAKE’s straightforward integration process, though some note that integration depth varies across different third-party services. The system particularly excels in providing seamless connections with popular accounting software like QuickBooks and Xero, and scheduling platforms like 7shifts, enabling restaurants to maintain consistent financial reporting and staff management across platforms.
Toast POS has invested heavily in developing both native modules and a robust partner ecosystem. This approach allows restaurants to select specific tools that match their operational needs while ensuring reliable system integration. Toast’s API (Application Programming Interface) is particularly robust, enabling custom integrations for restaurants with specialized requirements or proprietary systems.
Toast generally offers more extensive integration options, particularly valuable for enterprise-level establishments with complex operational requirements. CAKE provides a more streamlined but comprehensive integration experience that many small to medium-sized restaurants find sufficient for their operational needs. Both systems integrate effectively with essential third-party services, but the choice often depends on the complexity of integrations required and the restaurant’s technical sophistication.
Digital ordering capabilities have become essential for restaurant success, particularly as consumer preferences continue shifting toward convenient takeout and delivery options. CAKE POS offers commission-free online ordering that integrates directly with the POS system, allowing restaurants to avoid the high fees typically associated with third-party delivery platforms. The system supports contactless curbside pickup and delivery management—features that became critical during the pandemic and remain important for many customers.
CAKE’s online ordering system provides seamless menu synchronization between in-restaurant and digital offerings, ensuring price and availability consistency across all customer touchpoints. One user highlighted this advantage, noting that “The additional options for online orders and other features are really nice!” The system allows customers to place orders through multiple channels, including restaurant websites and mobile applications, while maintaining brand consistency.
Toast POS similarly offers commission-free online ordering but extends functionality with additional features like real-time delivery management and driver assignment tools. Toast’s online ordering system provides extensive customization options, allowing restaurants to maintain brand consistency while adapting to specific operational workflows. Some users particularly value Toast’s ability to seamlessly integrate delivery operations, with one noting the system’s capability to “send and receive orders from anywhere.”
Both platforms support QR code ordering, enabling customers to view menus and place orders using personal devices—a feature that enhances operational efficiency while appealing to tech-savvy customers. Both also offer mobile app capabilities, though Toast’s mobile ordering features often receive praise for their advanced customization options and comprehensive functionality for restaurants with complex delivery operations or multiple locations.
Access to comprehensive business intelligence has become increasingly vital for restaurant success, enabling data-driven decisions that significantly impact profitability and operational efficiency. CAKE POS offers cloud-based reporting and analytics accessible from anywhere, providing restaurant owners with real-time insights into sales patterns, inventory levels, staff performance, and customer behavior trends.
Users particularly appreciate CAKE’s straightforward reporting interface, with one restaurant operator noting: “The reports are thorough and easy to navigate.” The system provides essential business metrics including sales by item, labor costs as percentage of sales, inventory usage reports, and customer frequency analysis. CAKE also offers customizable dashboards that allow operators to focus on their most critical Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) without information overload.
Toast POS delivers more advanced analytical capabilities, offering detailed reporting on menu engineering, customer behavior patterns, and operational efficiency metrics. The system’s strength lies in generating actionable insights from complex data sets that help restaurants optimize menu performance, staffing levels, and inventory management. Toast’s analytical tools can identify underperforming menu items, determine optimal staffing patterns, and predict potential inventory issues before they impact operations.
Both systems enable automated report scheduling and distribution, ensuring key stakeholders receive regular updates on business performance without manual intervention. Mobile access to reports allows owners and managers to monitor performance remotely—particularly valuable for multi-location operators or those who travel frequently for business development.
While both platforms offer comprehensive reporting capabilities, Toast generally provides more sophisticated analytical tools suited for data-intensive operations, while CAKE delivers clear, accessible reports that many restaurant operators find sufficient for their decision-making needs without overwhelming complexity.
After comprehensive analysis across multiple operational dimensions, both CAKE POS and Toast POS offer robust restaurant management solutions, but with distinct strengths that appeal to different establishment types and operational philosophies. The optimal choice depends largely on your restaurant’s specific requirements, current size, operational complexity, and projected growth trajectory.
CAKE POS presents a compelling solution for small to medium-sized restaurants seeking user-friendly, reliable systems with exceptional customer support. Its intuitive interface minimizes training requirements, making it particularly valuable for establishments with high staff turnover rates. CAKE excels in delivering essential restaurant management functions without overwhelming users with unnecessary complexity, and its guest management features combined with straightforward reporting tools provide core functionality at competitive pricing.
Toast POS emerges as the stronger candidate for growing or larger restaurants with complex operational needs and specific customization requirements. Its extensive feature set, advanced reporting capabilities, and robust integration ecosystem provide the flexibility required by multi-location establishments or restaurants with specialized workflows. Toast’s strengths in kitchen display systems, tableside ordering, and comprehensive analytics make it particularly valuable for full-service restaurants focused on operational optimization and data-driven decision making.
Important decision factors should include your staff’s technical proficiency levels, restaurant growth projections, menu and service style complexity, budget constraints, and the importance of specific features like advanced inventory management or online ordering integration to your business model. Additionally, taking advantage of system demos or trial periods before making final commitments can provide valuable insights into daily operational compatibility.
For restaurants seeking to modernize their phone operations alongside POS upgrades, Loman provides a specialized AI solution that integrates seamlessly with both platforms, handling reservations and orders around the clock while reducing missed calls and improving customer satisfaction. Whether you choose CAKE’s streamlined approach or Toast’s comprehensive feature set, Loman can enhance your customer communication efficiency from day one, scaling effortlessly whether you’re managing a single location, growing chain, or established franchise operation.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
