Selecting the right point-of-sale system can significantly impact your restaurant’s efficiency and profitability. Breadcrumb POS (now part of Lightspeed Restaurant’s U-Series) and Square represent two major players in the restaurant POS arena, each offering unique advantages tailored to different operational needs. Understanding the strengths, weaknesses, and specific capabilities of each system becomes crucial to making an informed choice that will serve your business both now and in the future.
Breadcrumb POS was built from the ground up specifically for restaurants, evolving through acquisitions by Groupon, Upserve, and now Lightspeed. This system carries deep restaurant industry DNA in every feature and workflow. Square began as a simple payment processing solution but has expanded to offer comprehensive POS capabilities across various industries, including their restaurant-specific version called Square for Restaurants.
Both systems provide cloud-based solutions that work on mobile devices, enabling tableside ordering and payment processing. However, their approaches to restaurant management differ significantly. Breadcrumb focuses on specialized restaurant workflows and operations, while Square emphasizes unified commerce across multiple sales channels and touchpoints.
The hardware requirements also set these systems apart. Breadcrumb exclusively runs on iPad devices with iOS 8.0 or later, ensuring consistent performance but requiring Apple hardware investment. Square offers greater flexibility, working with both iOS and Android devices, plus their own proprietary hardware options like Square Stand and Square Terminal.
While traditional POS systems handle in-restaurant transactions effectively, modern restaurants need comprehensive solutions that extend beyond the dining room. This is where AI for restaurants like Loman creates a competitive advantage that neither Breadcrumb nor Square can match. Loman operates as a 24/7 AI phone agent specifically designed for restaurants, seamlessly integrating with existing POS systems including Square, Toast, and Clover to create a unified operational ecosystem.
Loman’s specialized restaurant training enables it to understand your menu, policies, and customer preferences with remarkable accuracy. Unlike generic POS systems that focus primarily on transaction processing, Loman actively reduces missed calls, shortens customer wait times, and directly improves sales through intelligent call handling and upselling capabilities. The system includes built-in analytics and real-time insights that complement your POS data, providing a complete picture of customer interactions both in-person and over the phone. What sets Loman apart from traditional POS solutions is its rapid deployment (live in under a day) and scalability for single locations, chains, or franchises seeking operational efficiency gains that extend far beyond standard point-of-sale functionality.
Breadcrumb’s exclusive iPad requirement means restaurants must invest in Apple hardware, typically representing a higher upfront cost. However, this approach ensures consistent performance and user experience across all installations. iPads purchased through Lightspeed come pre-installed with necessary software and configurations, reducing setup complexity and potential technical issues.
For peripheral hardware, Breadcrumb integrates seamlessly with Upserve’s EMV card readers and supports Epson printers. The Star SP742ML Impact Kitchen Order Printer works particularly well with Breadcrumb, supporting both single-ply and carbon copy receipt paper with autocutter functionality for efficient kitchen operations. This compatibility ensures smooth integration with existing restaurant equipment.
Square’s broader hardware compatibility provides more options and potentially lower costs. Their ecosystem includes Square Stand (converting iPads into complete POS stations), Square Terminal (all-in-one payment processing), and Square Register (dedicated POS system). This variety allows restaurants to choose configurations matching their specific needs and budget constraints.
Both systems support crucial restaurant peripherals including receipt printers, kitchen printers, cash drawers, and barcode scanners. Square offers more proprietary hardware options, while Breadcrumb relies more heavily on third-party devices. This difference affects initial setup costs and the ability to repurpose existing hardware when implementing new systems.
Breadcrumb excels with its restaurant-specific interface designed for intuitive navigation in fast-paced food service environments. The touchscreen interface enables quick staff mastery, reducing training time and operational errors. Core restaurant functions like split checks, tableside ordering, tableside payment processing, and inventory management operate seamlessly within workflows designed specifically for food service.
The training mode allows staff to practice transactions without affecting reporting data, ensuring smooth onboarding. Breadcrumb’s table management system efficiently organizes dining spaces into server-assigned zones. Menu updates happen in real-time, automatically removing sold-out items from servers’ screens to prevent customer disappointment.
Square for Restaurants provides a clean, modern interface with flexible configuration options for different restaurant types. While it includes features like coursing, table management, and check splitting, some users report these functions aren’t as streamlined as restaurant-specific systems. Square’s strength lies in seamless integration with other Square products, creating a unified ecosystem for payment processing, online ordering, delivery management, and loyalty programs.
Both systems offer cloud-based operation with real-time data synchronization across devices, enabling remote monitoring and quick adjustments. Breadcrumb’s software design reflects its restaurant-specific origins, with workflow optimizations closely aligned to food service operations. Square, while increasingly robust for restaurants, still shows its broader payment processing heritage.
Breadcrumb offers robust offline capabilities, allowing continued operations during internet connectivity issues. Transactions save locally and process automatically once connection restores, providing crucial business continuity. Square also includes offline mode, though with some limitations compared to online functionality.
Breadcrumb provides comprehensive restaurant-specific reporting tools with detailed insights into business performance, server productivity, and menu item popularity. Real-time inventory management automatically deducts items as orders process, preventing stockouts and simplifying reordering processes. The reporting suite helps identify profitable menu items and categorizes products to help staff promote high-margin offerings.
One standout feature aggregates reviews from various social media platforms into a single dashboard. This enables efficient online presence monitoring, customer feedback responses, and competitor performance tracking. Server performance tracking allows managers to evaluate staff based on sales metrics, identify training opportunities, and recognize top performers.
Square’s reporting capabilities focus on sales analytics with clean, visually appealing dashboards. The system offers real-time sales tracking, hourly reports, and employee performance metrics. Square for Restaurants provides food cost analysis and menu reporting, though users sometimes find these less comprehensive than restaurant-specific alternatives.
Square’s significant advantage lies in integration across all Square services, providing holistic views of both in-person and online sales channels. This unified data environment proves particularly valuable for establishments with significant online ordering components. Both systems offer mobile access to reports, allowing remote performance monitoring.
Breadcrumb, through Lightspeed, typically works with integrated payment processing via Lightspeed Payments but may offer processor selection flexibility depending on service agreements. Processing rates vary based on negotiated terms, transaction volume, and business type. This model allows potential rate customization for high-volume restaurants, though requiring more involved setup negotiations.
Square operates on a fixed-rate payment processing model with transparent pricing. For Square for Restaurants users, in-person transactions typically cost 2.6% + 10¢ per transaction. This straightforward pricing eliminates negotiation but may result in higher processing costs for restaurants with large average tickets or high transaction volumes.
Both systems support major credit cards, mobile payments like Apple Pay and Google Pay, and contactless transactions. Square offers consistent processing rates across payment types, while Breadcrumb’s rates may vary by card type and processing method. Square provides instant deposits for additional fees, allowing quicker fund access than standard next-business-day timelines.
EMV compliance and security features remain robust in both systems. Breadcrumb integrates with Upserve’s EMV card readers and employs end-to-end encryption for transaction data protection. Square similarly offers strong security measures including encryption and PCI compliance. Both provide chargeback protection and dispute management tools, though Square’s process benefits from its unified ecosystem streamlining.
Breadcrumb, under Lightspeed, offers 24/7/365 support providing round-the-clock assistance for critical issues. This comprehensive support includes setup assistance and ongoing technical help through phone, email, and chat channels. Lightspeed maintains an extensive knowledge base with articles and tutorials for self-service troubleshooting and training.
The training capabilities within Breadcrumb are particularly noteworthy. The dedicated training mode allows staff practice without affecting sales data, enabling new employee proficiency before handling real customer interactions. This reduces errors and improves service quality. Lightspeed offers personalized onboarding to help restaurants configure systems optimally from the start.
Square provides support through email, phone, and chat, though highest-level support typically serves larger accounts. Their self-service resources are extensive, including comprehensive help centers, video tutorials, and community forums for user tip exchange. Square’s interface design emphasizes intuitive use, potentially reducing extensive training needs but sacrificing some restaurant-specific functionalities.
Breadcrumb’s training resources focus heavily on restaurant operations with specific guidance for servers, bartenders, and kitchen staff. Square’s training materials tend toward generalization, covering POS basics but requiring restaurants to develop their own industry-specific protocols. For restaurants with high staff turnover or complex operational needs, Breadcrumb’s restaurant-focused support may provide advantages.
Integration with third-party systems significantly enhances POS functionality and streamlines restaurant operations. Breadcrumb offers integration with various business tools including QuickBooks accounting software, inventory management systems, and customer relationship management platforms. These integrations create cohesive operational ecosystems, reducing manual data entry and improving accuracy.
Breadcrumb’s online ordering system fully integrates with the POS, ensuring loyalty program and customer data consistency across ordering channels. This helps restaurants provide seamless experiences whether customers dine in or order delivery. The system also supports reservation platform integration for comprehensive table management and customer data views.
Square boasts impressive integration options through its App Marketplace featuring hundreds of third-party applications across various categories. Square for Restaurants integrates with popular delivery services, accounting software, inventory management tools, and employee scheduling platforms. The Eat App integration particularly enriches guest data across entire customer journeys.
A key difference lies in integration approaches. Square’s ecosystem remains more open with APIs allowing numerous third-party connections, while Breadcrumb offers more curated integrations specifically optimized for restaurant operations. Square’s broader integration capabilities may benefit restaurants using diverse software tools, while Breadcrumb’s focused integrations might provide more seamless core restaurant process functionality.
Breadcrumb, now part of Lightspeed Restaurant’s U-Series, typically operates on tiered subscription models. While specific pricing requires custom quotes, Lightspeed Restaurant generally offers several tiers based on features and terminal numbers. Subscription fees cover software updates, cloud storage, and basic support. Additional costs include hardware purchases, optional features, and payment processing fees.
Square for Restaurants offers transparent pricing with three tiers: Free, Plus ($69/month), and Premium ($165/month). The Free plan includes basic POS functionality with standard processing rates. Plus adds seat management, automated inventory management, and advanced reporting. Premium includes dedicated account management and lower processing rates for high-volume businesses. Square offers 30-day free trials of paid plans.
Hardware costs differ significantly between systems. Breadcrumb requires iPads and compatible peripherals, while Square works with iOS/Android devices plus proprietary hardware options. Square’s flexibility may result in lower initial hardware investments, particularly for restaurants owning compatible tablets. However, Breadcrumb’s hardware, while potentially more expensive upfront, is specifically configured for restaurant environments with better durability expectations.
When calculating total ownership costs, restaurants must consider monthly subscription fees, hardware costs, payment processing fees, integration expenses, and additional feature costs. For high-volume restaurants, processing rates significantly impact overall costs, making fee structure evaluation against typical transaction volumes and ticket sizes essential.
Breadcrumb distinguishes itself with capabilities designed exclusively for food service establishments. Its table management system allows intuitive dining space organization with efficient server assignments and table tracking. The system excels at restaurant-specific processes including coursing, check splitting, and seat management. Breadcrumb’s kitchen display system ensures clear front-of-house and kitchen staff communication.
Menu management capabilities are particularly robust, allowing easy updates and modifications. The system automatically removes sold-out items from servers’ screens in real-time, preventing customer disappointment. For bars and alcohol-serving establishments, Breadcrumb offers specialized liquor inventory tracking and bar tab management features.
Square for Restaurants has evolved to include many restaurant-specific features, though its general payment platform foundation remains evident. The system offers table management, coursing, and check splitting capabilities, but some users report these functions aren’t as streamlined as restaurant-specific alternatives. Square excels in quick-service environments with fast transaction processing and customer-facing display options.
Both systems support online ordering and delivery management with different approaches. Breadcrumb’s online ordering system fully integrates with the POS, creating seamless information flow between digital orders and in-house operations. Square integrates with various third-party delivery services and offers its own delivery platform through Square Online.
Breadcrumb offers robust mobile capabilities centered around iPad usage with tableside ordering and payment processing. Servers can input orders and process payments directly at tables, significantly improving service efficiency by reducing terminal travel time. The touchscreen interface is optimized for quick operation in fast-paced environments with clearly marked items and prices.
Square provides strong mobile functionality across iOS and Android devices. Square for Restaurants runs on tablets for tableside ordering, while Square Terminal provides all-in-one mobile solutions. The clean, intuitive interface works well on smaller screens, making it suitable for various restaurant settings.
A notable Breadcrumb strength is offline capabilities allowing continued function during internet connectivity issues. Restaurants can process sales and maintain operations when connections drop, with transactions saved locally and automatically processed once connectivity restores. This provides crucial business continuity during network outages.
Both systems support tableside payment processing, increasing table turnover rates and improving customer experiences by eliminating check processing wait times. Mobile capabilities enable flexible service models like line-busting during peak periods or service in non-traditional areas.
Selecting between Breadcrumb POS and Square ultimately depends on your restaurant’s specific needs, operational model, and growth trajectory. Breadcrumb offers specialized restaurant solutions with robust industry-specific features, comprehensive training resources, and extensive reporting capabilities tailored to food service operations. Its design prioritizes unique restaurant workflows, making it particularly well-suited for full-service establishments with complex service needs.
Square provides more flexible, integrated ecosystems extending beyond restaurants into multiple sales channels. Its transparent pricing, broader hardware compatibility, and extensive third-party integrations make it attractive for restaurants prioritizing simplicity and unified commerce across various platforms. Square may be particularly advantageous for quick-service restaurants, hybrid models, or establishments with significant online ordering components.
When making your final decision, assess your restaurant’s operational complexity and service model to determine which system’s features best align with daily needs. Calculate total ownership costs for each system, including subscription fees, hardware costs, and payment processing rates based on typical transaction volumes and ticket sizes. Consider your growth plans and how each system might accommodate expansion, multiple locations, or new service models like catering or retail components.
For restaurants seeking comprehensive operational efficiency that extends beyond traditional POS capabilities, solutions like Loman offer specialized AI-powered call management that integrates seamlessly with existing systems. Whether you choose Breadcrumb’s restaurant-focused approach or Square’s unified commerce platform, Loman provides the missing piece for complete customer interaction management, delivering fast implementation and scalable solutions for single locations, chains, or franchises prioritizing efficiency and enhanced customer experiences.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
