Restaurant Automation vs. Human Labor: Cost-Benefit Analysis

April 19, 2024

Restaurant Automation vs. Human Labor: Cost-Benefit Analysis

Deciding between automating your restaurant or relying on human labor involves weighing costs, efficiency, and customer experience. Here's a quick breakdown:

Automation Benefits: Reduces labor costs, enhances order accuracy, and increases order volume.
Human Labor Benefits: Builds customer relationships, provides quality control, and handles surprises well.
Costs: Automation has high upfront costs but can be cheaper in the long run. Human labor has lower initial costs but higher ongoing expenses.
Efficiency and Productivity: Automation can handle tasks faster and with fewer errors, but humans are better at quality control and customer service.
Hybrid Model: Combining automation for repetitive tasks with human labor for customer interaction and quality control can offer the best of both worlds.

Quick Comparison

Factor	Automation	Human Labor
Upfront Costs	High	Low
Ongoing Costs	Low, fixed	Rising, variable
Order Volume Capacity	High	Low-Moderate
Order Accuracy	Excellent	Moderate
Custom Order Flexibility	High	Moderate
Customer Relationships	Low	High
Innovative Output	Low	High
Performance Consistency	Excellent	Variable

This introduction aims to provide you with a clear understanding of the key points, helping you make an informed decision about the best approach for your restaurant.

The Role of Human Labor

Human staff are still very important in restaurants. They do things that machines just can't do. Here's a look at what people are best at:

Building Customer Relationships

Even with all the tech we have, nothing beats a friendly chat with someone who works at the restaurant. Staff like waiters and managers can really make a visit special by just being nice and paying attention to what customers want. This makes people want to come back again.

Quality Control

People are great at checking if food looks and tastes good. They can quickly spot if something's wrong with an order or if a dish doesn't look right, and fix it before it reaches the table. Machines can't really do this kind of quality check.

Handling Exceptions

Restaurants can be unpredictable places. Humans are good at dealing with surprises like special requests, big groups, or when something in the kitchen stops working. They can think on their feet and keep things running smoothly, no matter what happens.

Driving Innovation

People who work in restaurants often come up with new ideas that can make the place better, like new dishes, different ways to set up the dining area, or fun events. This creativity and ability to think about what customers might like is something machines can't match.

In short, while machines are good for doing the same task over and over, people add something special. They create a friendly atmosphere, make sure the food is just right, handle any surprise, and think of new ways to make the restaurant better. The best setup is when both people and technology work together, making everything run better behind the scenes.

Cost Comparison

Initial Capital Investment

When you first bring in automation to a restaurant, it costs a lot. You need to buy and set up things like order kiosks, chat systems, and smart stock monitors. This includes:

Buying the tech like kiosks and robots.
Paying to make all these systems work together.
Paying experts to help get everything running right.
Teaching your team how to use the new tech.

On the other hand, if you stick with hiring people, you have to spend money on finding, hiring, and training them. This means:

Paying to find the right people.
Checking the backgrounds of new hires.
Paying new staff while they learn the ropes.

Automation gear can be pricey, from a few thousand dollars for a kiosk to over $200,000 for robot chefs. But, there are ways to make it cheaper, like tax breaks or payment plans.

Hiring people might seem cheaper at first since you only pay per person, but as you hire more, it adds up. You need to think about how much you can spend on both tech and people.

Ongoing Operating Costs

After everything’s set up, you still have to keep paying to use it. For automation, this means:

Paying to fix and keep the tech running.
Paying for updates or new versions.
The cost of electricity to power everything.

For staff, the ongoing costs include:

Paying wages, bonuses, and for benefits like health insurance.
Covering insurance for things like accidents at work.
Paying for days off, like vacation or sick leave.

Automation costs stay pretty much the same over time, but what you spend on staff can go up a lot as you hire more people or if they work more hours. However, if your restaurant does well and brings in more money, this can help cover the higher cost of staff.

Choosing between spending on tech or people is a big decision. You have to think about what each option costs now and in the future, and what works best for your restaurant.

Productivity and Efficiency

Efficiency Metric Comparison Table

Metric	Baseline (Human Staff)	Post-Automation
Average Order Processing Time	2-3 minutes	Under 1 minute
Orders Processed per Hour	15-20	Up to 100+
Order Accuracy Rate	90-95%	Over 99%
Customizations per Order	2-3	10+
Sales per Labor Hour	$20-$30	$60+

Using machines instead of just people can really speed things up and make things run smoother in restaurants. For example, machines like order kiosks and computer programs that take orders can do things faster and make fewer mistakes than people. This means they can handle more orders every hour and almost always get them right. They can also deal with lots of special requests without getting confused.

Even though machines are great at doing the same thing over and over without getting tired, they're not so good at checking if a meal looks good to eat or making changes on the fly like humans can. When we rely only on machines, we might end up with more wrong orders or a less interesting menu because machines can't think outside the box.

The best way is to use both machines and people. Let the machines do the repetitive work, like taking orders and cooking basic stuff. This lets the people focus on making sure the food looks and tastes great, and giving customers a warm welcome. This mix helps restaurants serve more people faster without messing up the quality or making the place feel too robotic.

Pros and Cons Comparison

Automation

When we use machines and technology in restaurants, like order kiosks and chatbots, a lot of good things can happen. Here are some benefits:

Cost reductions: Using machines means we don't need as many workers, which saves money on paying wages. Usually, the money spent on machines pays off in 1-2 years.
Increased order volume: Machines can handle more orders in an hour than people, which means more sales.
Enhanced order accuracy: Machines make fewer mistakes, so almost every order is right.
Better customization: With machines doing the basic stuff, workers can focus on special orders.
Higher sales per hour: Serving more customers faster means making more money in less time.

But, there are some downsides too:

High upfront costs: It costs a lot to get and set up these machines at first.
Impersonal service: If we use too many machines, the place might feel less friendly.
Tech reliability issues: If the machines break down, it could cause big problems.
Menu limitations: Machines can't cook complex dishes as well as people.

Human Labor

People bring things to the table that machines just can't:

Customer relationships: Friendly staff make customers feel welcome and want to come back.
Quality control: People can check if the food looks and tastes right.
Handling surprises: People are great at dealing with unexpected things, like special orders.
Driving innovation: Staff can come up with new ideas for the menu or the restaurant.

But, relying only on people has its problems:

High turnover: Restaurants often have to keep hiring new people.
Rising labor costs: Paying workers gets more expensive, especially with higher minimum wages.
Variable performance: People might not work the same way every day.
Lower order volume: People can't handle as many orders as machines, and might make more mistakes.

Comparison Table

Factor	Automation	Human Labor
Upfront Costs	High	Low
Ongoing Costs	Low, fixed	Rising, variable
Order Volume Capacity	High	Low-Moderate
Order Accuracy	Excellent	Moderate
Custom Order Flexibility	High	Moderate
Customer Relationships	Low	High
Innovative Output	Low	High
Performance Consistency	Excellent	Variable

As shown, both ways have their good and bad points. The best plan mixes machines for the heavy lifting and people for their unique skills. This way, restaurants can work efficiently and keep customers happy at the same time.

Hybrid Model

Using both tech and people in restaurants helps get the best of both worlds. Tech can do the repeat jobs fast, like taking orders, so people have more time to make sure the food is good, talk to customers, and come up with new dishes. This way, tech takes care of the boring stuff, and people handle the things that need a human touch, like making sure customers feel welcome and dealing with any surprises.

Case Studies

Freshii has machines where customers can order by themselves, but there are still people around to check the orders are right and help with any special requests. This mix has helped them sell 10-15% more without having to hire more people. Because the machines do the routine jobs, the staff can spend more time with customers and making sure everything's perfect.

McDonald's uses machines to pour drinks and timers to help cook fries just right, so the crew can spend more time talking to customers. They also have a service where they bring your food to your table, making things feel more welcoming, even though they also use machines to take orders faster. McDonald's found that this mix keeps the place friendly while helping them serve more people.

Sweetgreen lets people order online or through an app, which means the staff can focus on making custom salads and being friendly. By letting tech handle the simple orders, they can take care of more customers, especially when it's busy. But they make sure that quality and being friendly are still the most important things, with staff helping customers pick what they want and making them feel at home.

These stories show that even though it costs money to start using tech, in the long run, it can really pay off when you mix it with having people around. The trick is to figure out what jobs tech can do best and what jobs need a human touch in your restaurant. With some planning, using both tech and people can make things run smoother and keep customers happy.

Future Outlook

The future of eating out is heading towards a mix of tech and people working together. Here's what we might see:

Operations and Productivity

Tech will keep doing the repetitive stuff like taking orders and making simple dishes, so restaurants can serve more people faster.
Smart tech will track supplies and how the restaurant is running in real-time, helping to buy only what's needed and keep everything working smoothly.
People will still be in charge of making sure the food is top-notch, handling special requests, and sorting out any surprises. This means they can quickly adapt to what customers want.
Using more data from tech can help plan better when to have more staff around to match when it's busy.
Jobs that need a personal touch, like making guests feel welcome and coming up with new ideas, will still be done by humans.

Staffing and Labor

While some basic jobs might not be needed because of tech, there will be more jobs for people who can work with or manage these technologies.
With machines doing the routine tasks, workers can spend more time on service, making the dining experience better and building relationships with customers.
Restaurants might train staff whose jobs are replaced by tech for more important roles.
The best setup will use both tech and people for what they do best.

Customer Experience

Tech makes ordering and getting your food faster and more accurate, but people add the friendly, personal touch.
Customers, especially younger ones, expect reliable service and good quality that tech helps with.
Even though they like using tech, customers still want to feel a personal connection when they eat out, so having both tech and people is key.

In short, using more tech but keeping the human touch is the way forward. Restaurants that find the right balance between the two will be the ones that do well.

Conclusion

When we look at using machines versus hiring people in restaurants, we see that both have their good and bad points. If we only use machines or only hire people, we might run into some problems that could make the restaurant not work as well, cost too much, stop new ideas, or make eating there not as nice. But, if we mix machines for the repeat jobs and keep people for checking the food, talking to customers, and coming up with new stuff, restaurants can do really well in all the important areas.

Key Takeaways

Machines are great for always doing things the same way, not making mistakes, and handling lots of orders. But, they're not good at making friends with customers or coming up with new food or ways to do things. People are still the best at checking if the food is okay, handling surprises, thinking of new ideas, and making customers feel welcome.
Starting with machines costs more money upfront, but over time, they can be cheaper to keep going than paying more and more people. There's a point where using machines saves more money than just hiring people.
The best setup has machines doing the boring, repeat jobs so people can use their time and skills on making sure the food is good, serving customers, thinking of new things, and dealing with anything unexpected.
Stories from real restaurants show that mixing machines and people can lead to making more money without needing more workers, because the workers can spend more time with customers when machines take care of the routine stuff.
The way things are going, restaurants will keep using more machines for the behind-the-scenes work but will keep people for the jobs that need talking to customers and making quick decisions.

Using the right machines while keeping the important people jobs allows restaurants to handle more orders and make fewer mistakes, all while making sure the food is good, the service is friendly, and the place feels welcoming. Looking ahead, finding the perfect balance between technology and people is key. Restaurants that get this balance right will do better in the long run, with happier customers and smoother operations.## Related Questions

How much does automation cost compared to human labor costs?

When you automate your restaurant, the start-up cost is pretty high because of all the tech you need. But, if you look at the costs over 2 years, automation ends up being cheaper than paying staff. For instance, using machines instead of people can save you around $360,000 over two years because you're not paying for staff hours. That's like getting 90% of what you spent on automation back.

How does automation reduce Labour costs?

Automation saves money on staff in a few ways:

It uses machines that don't need breaks or salaries and can work all the time.
It makes more food faster and with fewer mistakes.
It uses materials better, so less gets wasted.

Basically, by doing the routine tasks faster and without mistakes, you don't need as many people, which means you spend less on wages.

How much does it cost to automate a restaurant?

The cost to add tech to your restaurant depends on what you pick. Some examples include:

Online ordering system: $2,000
A simple cooking robot: $3,500 a month
Self-order kiosks: between $4,000 and $8,000 each
A system to keep track of your stock: $5,000 and up

Even though this sounds expensive, this tech can help you serve more customers faster, which means you'll start making your money back pretty quickly.

What percentage should labor cost be in a restaurant?

labor cost

How much you spend on staff should be a certain part of your total sales, kind of like a rule of thumb:

For fast food places: 25%
For casual dining: 30-35%
For fancy restaurants: 30-40%

Using tech like kiosks can help fast food restaurants especially keep their staff costs in check while still selling more.

Blog