Restaurants across the country are discovering that their payment processing system can make or break their customer experience and operational efficiency. With the rise of contactless payments, online ordering, and integrated business management tools, today’s POS systems do far more than simply process credit cards. Square and PayPal have emerged as two of the most popular solutions, each offering distinct advantages for different types of food service businesses. The decision between these platforms can significantly impact everything from daily operations to long-term scalability, making it crucial to understand their unique strengths and limitations. Both companies have evolved far beyond their original offerings, now providing comprehensive ecosystems designed to streamline restaurant operations and enhance customer satisfaction.
Square positions itself as an all-in-one business platform, with its POS system serving as the foundation for an extensive ecosystem of integrated business tools. Its core strength lies in its versatile point-of-sale software, which comes in both free and industry-specific premium versions tailored for retail, restaurants, and appointment-based businesses. Square’s business model emphasizes simplicity and accessibility—merchants can start accepting payments quickly with minimal setup and no long-term commitments. The company continuously builds new features and products designed to keep businesses within its ecosystem, from payroll services to marketing tools.
PayPal, conversely, has built its empire around online payment processing, only later expanding into the physical retail space. Its POS system (formerly called PayPal Here, now PayPal Zettle) complements its robust online payment infrastructure. PayPal’s business model leverages its massive consumer adoption and global recognition, offering merchants access to customers who prefer using their PayPal accounts for transactions both online and in-person. The company focuses more on payment versatility and international commerce, with fewer auxiliary business management features but stronger cross-border transaction capabilities.
The fundamental difference in their approaches becomes evident in their product development strategies. For merchants, this distinction matters significantly—Square offers a more cohesive, integrated business management experience, while PayPal provides broader payment acceptance options and stronger global commerce capabilities. Your choice ultimately depends on whether you need a comprehensive business platform or a versatile payment processor with international reach.
Square offers a diverse range of proprietary hardware solutions to accommodate different business types and sales environments. Their signature product remains the Square Reader for magstripe, which is free for new merchants (additional readers cost $10). For businesses needing more functionality, the Square Reader for contactless and chip ($49) accepts NFC payments and EMV chip cards. The Square Stand ($149) transforms an iPad into a complete checkout station, while the Square Terminal ($299) provides an all-in-one solution with built-in receipt printer. For full-scale restaurant operations, the Square Register ($799) offers a dual-screen setup with a dedicated customer-facing display, making it ideal for establishments that want to provide a professional checkout experience.
PayPal’s hardware lineup is more streamlined, focusing on essential payment collection rather than comprehensive POS infrastructure. The PayPal Zettle card reader ($29 for your first reader, $79 for additional units) processes chip cards and contactless payments. Their all-in-one Terminal ($249) includes a built-in receipt printer and barcode scanner, providing functionality similar to Square’s mid-range options at a lower cost. While PayPal’s hardware options are fewer, they generally cost less than comparable Square devices, making them attractive for budget-conscious restaurants.
Hardware durability and design aesthetics also differ significantly between the platforms. Square’s devices feature sleek, minimalist designs ideal for customer-facing environments in boutique restaurants or trendy cafes. PayPal’s hardware embraces functional practicality over aesthetic appeal, which works well for behind-the-counter operations. Square’s hardware works exclusively within the Square ecosystem, while PayPal’s readers can integrate with some third-party POS systems, offering more flexibility for restaurants with existing technology investments.
Understanding the fee structures of Square and PayPal is essential for predicting your payment processing costs, especially for restaurants with varying transaction volumes throughout the day. Square implements a straightforward flat-rate pricing model: 2.6% plus 10 cents for in-person transactions, 2.9% plus 30 cents for online transactions, and 3.5% plus 15 cents for manually entered transactions. This transparent approach eliminates guesswork, though it may not offer the most competitive rates for high-volume restaurants during peak hours.
PayPal’s pricing is slightly more complex but potentially more cost-effective for certain transaction types. For in-person transactions through Zettle, merchants pay 2.29% plus 9 cents—potentially lower than Square for larger transactions like group dining or catering orders. Online transactions range from 2.59% plus 49 cents to 3.49% plus 49 cents, depending on the payment type. PayPal also charges a $20 fee per chargeback and adds a 1.5% cross-border fee for international card transactions, plus additional currency conversion fees.
The difference becomes significant when processing refunds, which restaurants frequently handle for incorrect orders or customer dissatisfaction. Square refunds the full transaction fee to merchants when processing customer refunds, while PayPal keeps the transaction fee even when you issue a refund—a potential hidden cost for restaurants with frequent returns or order modifications. For high-volume establishments, Square offers custom pricing for businesses processing over $250,000 annually, while PayPal typically maintains its standard rates regardless of volume.
Both services avoid monthly fees for basic plans, long-term contracts, or early termination penalties. However, PayPal charges monthly fees for certain premium services: $30 for Virtual Terminal and $10 for recurring billing. Square includes these features in its free plan, though its premium industry-specific POS solutions range from $29-$79 monthly, which can be worthwhile for restaurants needing advanced table management or inventory tracking features.
Square’s software ecosystem stands out for its comprehensive restaurant management capabilities. The free Square POS app includes inventory management with low-stock alerts, customer databases with purchase histories, employee management with customizable permission levels, and detailed sales analytics. Square’s industry-specific premium POS solutions offer additional features like table management for full-service restaurants, advanced inventory tracking for multi-location operations, and scheduling tools for managing staff shifts. The software’s intuitive interface requires minimal training, making it accessible even to technology-hesitant employees and reducing onboarding time.
PayPal’s POS software, primarily through the Zettle app, offers core payment processing functionality with basic inventory and sales reporting features. While competent for simple restaurant operations, it lacks the depth and customization options of Square’s platform. PayPal’s strength lies not in its POS software but in its seamless integration with online payment systems and its developer tools that allow for custom implementations on websites and mobile ordering platforms. The company focuses more on payment flexibility than comprehensive business management.
Both platforms offer mobile apps that transform smartphones and tablets into payment terminals, though Square’s app provides more robust features for restaurant-specific needs. Square integrates with over 400 third-party applications across various business functions, including popular restaurant tools for scheduling, accounting, and marketing. PayPal prioritizes e-commerce integrations, which can benefit restaurants with strong online ordering or delivery components.
For restaurant owners requiring robust inventory management, employee scheduling, and comprehensive analytics, Square’s feature-rich platform provides significant value. Those prioritizing online sales with occasional in-person transactions may find PayPal’s simpler approach sufficient, particularly if they’re already using PayPal’s online payment processing services for delivery platforms or their restaurant website.
Modern restaurants face constant challenges managing phone orders while maintaining quality service during busy periods. Traditional phone systems often result in missed calls, incorrect orders, and overwhelmed staff who must juggle multiple responsibilities simultaneously. Loman revolutionizes this process by providing a 24/7 AI phone agent specifically designed for restaurant operations, seamlessly integrating with existing POS systems like Square, Toast, and Clover to ensure accurate order processing and real-time inventory updates.
The system goes beyond simple order-taking by training on each restaurant’s specific menu, policies, and customer preferences, ensuring every interaction feels personalized and accurate. Unlike generic POS solutions that focus primarily on transaction processing, AI for restaurants like Loman addresses the critical gap in phone-based customer service that traditional systems often overlook. The platform reduces missed calls that typically cost restaurants significant revenue, shortens customer wait times during peak hours, and actually improves sales through intelligent upselling suggestions based on order history and menu optimization. Built-in analytics provide real-time insights that help restaurant owners make better operational decisions, from staffing adjustments to menu modifications based on ordering patterns and customer feedback trends.
Square and PayPal both offer robust solutions for online commerce, but with distinct approaches that can significantly impact restaurants with delivery or takeout operations. Square provides an integrated e-commerce platform through Square Online, allowing merchants to quickly establish a web presence with built-in payment processing. This service includes a free tier with basic functionality and paid plans ($29-$79 monthly) for advanced features like advanced customization and integrated marketing tools. Square’s checkout API enables seamless integration with major e-commerce platforms like WooCommerce and Wix, while its unified backend connects online and in-person sales data for comprehensive business analytics.
PayPal dominates in online payment integration, supporting over 200 countries and 25 currencies—a significant advantage for restaurants serving international customers or tourists. Its wide consumer adoption means many online customers already have PayPal accounts, potentially increasing conversion rates for restaurant websites and third-party delivery platforms. PayPal integrates natively with virtually all major e-commerce platforms, offering various implementation options from simple payment buttons to complete checkout solutions.
Both platforms support digital wallets like Apple Pay and Google Pay, though PayPal adds its own widely-used digital wallet and Venmo as payment options—particularly valuable for restaurants targeting younger demographics. PayPal also offers Buy Now, Pay Later services through PayPal Credit and Pay in 4, while Square provides similar functionality through Afterpay integration. For restaurants with subscription services like meal plans or coffee subscriptions, both support recurring billing, though PayPal charges an additional monthly fee for this service.
The key differentiator lies in scope and specialization: Square’s e-commerce tools work best within its own ecosystem, making it ideal for restaurants that primarily serve in-person but want a complementary online presence. PayPal’s global reach and widespread consumer adoption make it superior for restaurants with strong online ordering components, especially those serving international customers or needing to integrate with various delivery platforms and marketplaces.
The customer experience at checkout significantly impacts sales conversion and repeat business, making this a crucial consideration for restaurant owners. Square’s customer-facing interface presents a clean, professional appearance with customizable digital receipts, tipping options, and customer loyalty integration. Its dual-screen Register allows customers to see items as they’re being entered and provides a dedicated payment interface, creating transparency that builds trust. Square accepts all major credit and debit cards, mobile wallets like Apple Pay and Google Pay, and Cash App payments—but notably doesn’t accept PayPal in physical locations.
PayPal’s customer experience emphasizes familiar payment options that many diners already use regularly. The Zettle reader provides a straightforward interface for card payments, but PayPal’s unique advantage is accepting PayPal and Venmo payments in-person—tapping into the substantial user bases of these popular digital wallets. This capability provides customers with more payment flexibility, potentially increasing sales with younger demographics who prefer these contactless payment methods. PayPal also supports QR code payments at lower rates than standard transactions, which became particularly popular during the pandemic.
Both services offer email receipts with customization options, but Square provides more extensive customization for receipt templates, including the ability to add restaurant logos, promotional messages, and return policies. Both platforms support split payment functionality, allowing customers to divide transactions between multiple payment methods—particularly useful for restaurants where groups frequently split checks or customers want to use multiple cards.
For restaurants with international customers or those located in tourist areas, PayPal offers superior functionality, accepting international cards and multiple currencies with real-time conversion. Square’s international payment support is more limited, primarily serving businesses with customers in the same country. The ideal choice depends on your customer base: Square delivers a more polished checkout experience for domestic transactions, while PayPal offers greater payment flexibility, particularly for businesses serving international diners or those catering to consumers who prefer PayPal’s digital wallet solutions.
Both Square and PayPal implement robust security measures to protect merchants and customers, maintaining PCI DSS Level 1 compliance—the highest level of certification in the payment industry. They employ end-to-end encryption for all transactions and assume the burden of PCI compliance, simplifying security management for restaurant owners who would otherwise need to navigate complex regulations independently. This level of security is particularly important for restaurants that store customer information for loyalty programs or recurring orders.
Square’s approach to fraud protection includes machine learning algorithms that analyze transaction patterns to detect suspicious activity. Their risk management system, Square Secure, monitors accounts 24/7 and provides dispute management tools at no additional cost. Importantly, Square offers chargeback protection up to $250 monthly without charging merchants chargeback fees—a significant advantage for restaurants vulnerable to fraudulent claims, especially those with high-ticket catering orders or disputed delivery charges.
PayPal’s security includes similar fraud monitoring systems plus Seller Protection policies that cover eligible transactions against fraudulent chargebacks. However, PayPal charges a $20 fee per chargeback, which can accumulate quickly for restaurants experiencing frequent disputes. PayPal’s additional fraud protection tools are available but may incur extra costs, making it important for restaurant owners to factor these potential expenses into their decision-making process.
Both services have faced criticism regarding account stability issues, employing automated systems that may unexpectedly freeze accounts or hold funds when detecting unusual activity patterns. PayPal has historically been more aggressive with account holds, sometimes freezing funds for 180 days in suspicious cases, which can create severe cash flow challenges for restaurants operating on thin margins. Square has improved its communication regarding account issues but still occasionally implements holds with limited warning, particularly for businesses experiencing sudden volume spikes during events or seasonal rushes.
Customer support accessibility becomes crucial when payment processing issues arise, as they directly impact a restaurant’s ability to collect revenue during critical service periods. Square offers email support for all users, with phone support available Monday through Friday from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. PT. Premium subscribers receive priority support with reduced wait times, which can be valuable during dinner rush emergencies. Square’s self-service resources include a comprehensive knowledge base, community forum, and detailed documentation specifically tailored for restaurant operations.
PayPal’s support structure includes a Message Center accessed through your account, which may direct you to call an agent depending on your issue. Phone support hours match Square’s (6 a.m. to 6 p.m. daily), and PayPal maintains a Resolution Center specifically for account and transaction issues. Like Square, PayPal offers extensive self-help resources, though navigating their support system can be challenging due to the breadth of their services beyond restaurant-specific needs.
Both companies provide onboarding resources for new merchants, but Square’s materials are generally more user-friendly and comprehensive for restaurant-specific implementations. Square offers video tutorials, step-by-step guides, and dedicated resources for restaurant setups including table management and menu organization. PayPal’s documentation tends to be more technical, requiring greater effort to navigate for non-technical restaurant owners who simply want to start processing payments quickly.
For restaurants requiring additional implementation support, Square offers dedicated account representatives for high-volume merchants, while PayPal provides specialized support for enterprise-level clients. Neither company offers consistently reliable 24/7 emergency support—a limitation worth considering for restaurants operating late hours or in multiple time zones. Restaurant owners should evaluate their technical comfort level and operating hours when choosing between these platforms, though Square generally receives higher marks for support accessibility and restaurant-specific resource quality.
As your restaurant expands, your payment processing needs will evolve significantly, making scalability an essential consideration from the outset. Square’s ecosystem is designed to grow with your business, offering increasingly sophisticated tools as you scale from a single location to multiple restaurants or franchises. You can start with a simple free card reader and basic POS, then gradually adopt advanced features like comprehensive inventory management across locations, sophisticated customer relationship tools, and multi-location reporting. Square’s premium industry-specific POS solutions ($29-$79 monthly) provide specialized features for growing restaurant businesses, including advanced analytics, employee management across locations, and integrated marketing tools.
PayPal’s scalability focuses more on payment versatility than operational tools, which may limit its usefulness for restaurant chains or franchises. While its basic features support small restaurants effectively, PayPal’s advantage emerges for restaurants expanding internationally or serving diverse customer bases. Its ability to process transactions in 25 currencies across 200+ countries significantly eases global expansion, though few restaurants require this level of international capability. PayPal’s enterprise solutions include customized checkout experiences and specialized support, though these require significant technical implementation.
Both platforms offer business financing options based on your processing history, which can help restaurants fund expansion or equipment upgrades. Square Capital provides merchant cash advances with repayment automatically deducted from daily sales, while PayPal Working Capital operates similarly. These financing options can help fund expansion without traditional loan applications, though restaurants should carefully evaluate the terms and impact on cash flow.
Integration capabilities represent another crucial scalability factor for growing restaurant operations. Square connects with over 400 third-party applications across various business functions, creating a robust ecosystem for inventory management, accounting, scheduling, and marketing as you grow. PayPal prioritizes payment-focused integrations, particularly with e-commerce platforms and delivery services, but offers fewer restaurant-specific operational tools for multi-location management.
Selecting between Square and PayPal ultimately depends on understanding your restaurant’s specific requirements, customer base, and growth trajectory. For traditional brick-and-mortar restaurants, fast-casual establishments, and full-service dining operations with significant in-person transactions, Square’s comprehensive POS system typically provides superior functionality. Its integrated business tools—inventory management, employee scheduling, table management, customer relationship features, and robust reporting—create a cohesive operational platform designed specifically for food service businesses.
PayPal represents the stronger choice for restaurants with significant online ordering components, especially those serving international customers or operating in tourist areas. Its global reach, widespread consumer adoption, and multiple currency support facilitate diverse customer service. Restaurants operating primarily through delivery platforms and online ordering may find PayPal’s universal integration capabilities and familiar customer interface advantageous. Mobile food operations with simple needs and higher-value transactions may benefit from PayPal Zettle’s lower in-person transaction fees.
Consider your customer base preferences carefully: restaurants whose customers frequently use PayPal or Venmo will benefit from offering these payment methods in-person through PayPal Zettle. Conversely, restaurants integrating with the Cash App ecosystem or targeting younger demographics will find Square’s native integration valuable. Your technical capabilities should also influence your decision—Square offers a more intuitive interface with less technical implementation required, making it accessible for non-technical restaurant owners, while PayPal provides more flexibility but often requires greater technical knowledge to fully customize.
Both platforms offer free basic accounts, so restaurant owners should consider testing both solutions before committing fully. Many successful restaurants even use both services strategically—Square for in-person transactions and comprehensive business management, with PayPal as an additional online payment option for delivery platforms and website orders. This hybrid approach maximizes the strengths of each platform while mitigating their respective limitations, creating a comprehensive payment solution tailored to your specific restaurant needs and customer expectations.
Both Square and PayPal offer robust solutions for restaurant operations, but the right choice depends on your specific operational priorities and customer service goals. Square excels for restaurants needing comprehensive business management tools, intuitive interfaces, and industry-specific features like table management and integrated scheduling. PayPal provides superior payment flexibility, international capabilities, and seamless online integration for restaurants with diverse ordering channels. The decision ultimately comes down to whether you prioritize operational depth or payment versatility in your restaurant’s technology stack.
For restaurant owners ready to modernize their operations, Loman offers a specialized solution that complements either POS platform by addressing the critical area of phone-based customer service. With fast setup capabilities that can have your restaurant live in under a day, Loman scales efficiently whether you’re operating a single location, managing a chain, or growing a franchise system that demands consistent, professional customer interactions across all touchpoints.
Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!
