AI vs Human Call Transcription: Pros & Cons

July 20, 2024

Here's a quick overview of AI and human call transcription for restaurants:

FeatureAI TranscriptionHuman TranscriptionSpeedVery fastSlowerAccuracy80-95%99%CostLowerHigherVolumeHandles many callsLimited by staffContextMay miss nuancesUnderstands wellCustomizationLimitedHighly customizableData securityNeeds strong protectionGenerally safer

Key points:

  • AI is faster and cheaper, good for high call volumes
  • Humans are more accurate and understand context better
  • Choose based on your call volume, budget, and accuracy needs
  • Consider using both: AI for speed, humans for quality checks

Restaurants should weigh these factors to pick the best option for their needs.

Related video from YouTube

What is AI Call Transcription?

AI call transcription turns spoken words into written text using computer programs. This technology can handle many calls quickly without much human help.

Defining AI Call Transcription

AI call transcription uses speech recognition and computer learning to create written records of calls. Many AI tools can do this job, often faster than people.

How AI Transcription Works in Restaurants

In restaurants, AI can write down customer calls, freeing up staff for other work. The AI can also look at calls to understand what customers want and think.

Main Features of AI Transcription Systems

FeatureDescriptionSpeedCan handle many calls quicklyScalabilityWorks well for both small and large call volumesIntegrationCan connect with other business systemsAnalysisCan spot trends in customer calls

AI systems can quickly turn speech into text, which helps businesses that get lots of calls. They can also work with other computer systems restaurants use, making it easier to understand and use the information from calls.

What is Human Call Transcription?

Human call transcription turns spoken words into written text using people instead of computers. This method is often more accurate than AI, especially when dealing with complex language, industry terms, and different accents.

Defining Human Call Transcription

Human call transcription is when trained people listen to recordings and type out what they hear. This job needs careful listening and good language skills.

How Human Transcription Works in Restaurants

In restaurants, human transcription can be used for:

  • Customer calls
  • Staff meetings
  • Voicemails

This lets restaurant staff focus on other work while making sure important talks are written down correctly. Human transcribers can also help find key themes and trends in customer chats, which can help improve the business.

Key Aspects of Human Transcription

AspectDescriptionAccuracyPeople can catch small details and understand context better than AIUnderstandingHumans can grasp industry terms and casual languageFlexibilityPeople can handle different accents and ways of speakingData SafetyHuman transcribers can keep sensitive info private and safe

Human transcribers are good at understanding the full meaning of what's said, not just the words. This makes them helpful for restaurants that talk to many different kinds of customers.

Benefits of AI Call Transcription

AI call transcription offers several advantages for restaurants handling customer interactions. Here are the main benefits:

Speed and Efficiency

AI can process many calls quickly, which helps restaurants:

  • Handle more customer inquiries
  • Respond to customers faster
  • Free up staff for other tasks

Cost Savings

AI transcription often costs less than human transcription, especially for many calls. This can help restaurants:

  • Reduce expenses
  • Use money for other needs, like training staff or marketing

Handling More Calls

As a restaurant gets busier, AI can easily handle more calls without slowing down. This means:

  • Consistent performance even during busy times
  • No need to hire more staff just for transcription

Working with Other Systems

AI transcription can connect with other restaurant tools, like:

  • Customer databases
  • Ordering systems

This connection helps restaurants:

  • Keep track of customer information
  • Provide better service based on past interactions

BenefitHow It Helps RestaurantsSpeedFaster response to customersCostLess money spent on transcriptionGrowthCan handle more calls as business growsIntegrationWorks with other restaurant systems

Drawbacks of AI Call Transcription

While AI call transcription has its good points, it also has some problems. Here are the main issues:

Accuracy Problems

AI can make mistakes when writing down calls, especially with:

  • Different accents or ways of speaking
  • Noisy backgrounds or poor sound quality
  • Special words used in restaurants or local areas

These problems can lead to wrong words in the transcript, which might need fixing later.

Privacy and Security Worries

Using AI to write down calls can raise concerns about keeping information safe. When calls are recorded and written down, private details might be at risk, such as:

  • Personal information
  • Money details
  • Secret business information

It's important to make sure AI companies keep customer information safe and private.

Trouble Understanding Meaning

AI might not get the full meaning of what people say. This can cause:

  • Misunderstanding the tone or what someone means
  • Missing small but important details in how people talk
  • Not getting jokes or sarcasm

Because of this, AI transcripts might miss the feelings and complexity in how people talk.

ProblemExampleAccuracyAI might hear "pizza" instead of "pita"PrivacyCustomer credit card info might not be protected wellUnderstandingAI might not catch that a customer is joking about a complaint

These drawbacks show that while AI call transcription can be helpful, it's not perfect. Restaurants need to think about these issues when deciding whether to use AI for writing down their calls.

Benefits of Human Call Transcription

Human call transcription has several good points for restaurants. Here's why it can be helpful:

Very Accurate

People who write down calls make fewer mistakes than computers. This matters a lot for restaurants because:

  • Orders need to be right
  • Customer requests must be clear

Human transcribers can:

  • Understand different ways of speaking
  • Get local words right
  • Hear clearly even with background noise

Understands Restaurant Talk

People who work on transcripts know about restaurant words and how customers talk. They can:

  • Tell the difference between similar-sounding food names
  • Get local sayings right
  • Understand when customers are happy, upset, or joking

Can Be Changed to Fit Needs

Restaurants can ask for transcripts in ways that work best for them. For example:

What Can Be DoneWhy It HelpsAdd order numbersMakes it easy to find specific ordersInclude customer namesHelps with personalized serviceNote special requestsEnsures customer needs are met

Transcribers can also sum up main points or suggest ways to make service better.

Keeps Information Safe

People who write down calls know how important it is to keep customer information private. They:

  • Use strong computer safety rules
  • Make sure only the right people can see the information
  • Keep customer details safe from others

Safety MeasureWhat It DoesEncryptionScrambles information so others can't read itLimited accessOnly lets certain people see the transcriptsSecure storageKeeps information in safe places

Human call transcription gives restaurants accurate, clear, and safe records of customer calls. This can help make service better and keep customers happy.

sbb-itb-d417701

Drawbacks of Human Call Transcription

While human call transcription has its good points, it also has some problems. Here are the main issues:

Higher Costs

Human transcription often costs more than AI, especially for many calls. This can be hard for restaurants, especially smaller ones with less money to spend.

Cost FactorImpact on RestaurantsTranscriptionist wagesHigher operating expensesTime spent on transcriptionLess budget for other needsTraining and quality controlAdded costs for maintaining accuracy

Slower Work

Human transcription takes more time than AI. This can cause delays in getting call information.

Time FactorResultListening to callsLonger wait for transcriptsWriting down contentDelayed access to call dataChecking for mistakesSlower problem-solving

Possible Mistakes

People can make mistakes when writing down calls. They might:

  • Hear words wrong
  • Not understand accents well
  • Make typing errors

These mistakes can lead to wrong information in the transcripts.

Hard to Handle More Calls

When restaurants get busier and have more calls, human transcription might not keep up. This can cause problems like:

ProblemEffectNot enough transcribersBacklog of untranscribed callsLonger wait timesDelayed responses to customersNeed to hire more peopleHigher costs for the restaurant

Human call transcription can be good for accuracy, but these drawbacks show it's not always the best choice for every restaurant.

AI vs Human Transcription: Side-by-Side Comparison

Here's a simple breakdown of how AI and human transcription compare:

FeatureAI TranscriptionHuman TranscriptionSpeedVery fast, almost instantSlower, depends on the personAccuracy80-95% right, based on sound quality99% right, people understand betterCostCheaper, can handle more callsMore expensive, limited by people availableHandling many callsCan do lots of callsLimited, might need more peopleUnderstanding contextNot great with subtle meaningsVery good, people get the full pictureFitting special needsLimited, same output for everyoneCan be changed to fit what you needKeeping info safeMight have data leaks, needs strong protectionSafer, people can keep things privateUnderstanding restaurant wordsMight struggle with special termsPeople know restaurant words wellWorking with other systemsCan connect to other computer programsMight need extra setup to work with other systems

This table shows the main differences between AI and human transcription. AI is faster and cheaper, but humans are more accurate and understand context better. Restaurants should pick based on how many calls they get, how much money they can spend, and how accurate they need the transcripts to be.

How to Choose Between AI and Human Transcription

When picking between AI and human transcription, think about these key points:

Call Numbers

Look at how many calls your restaurant gets:

Call VolumeBest OptionMany callsAI (faster, handles more)Few callsHuman (more careful)

Money Available

Think about how much you can spend:

BudgetBest OptionLimitedAI (cheaper)More flexibleHuman (costs more but may be worth it)

How Correct It Needs to Be

Decide how perfect the transcripts must be:

NeedBest OptionVery accurateHuman (fewer mistakes)Some errors okayAI (still mostly right)

Special Restaurant Words

Think about the words used in your restaurant:

LanguageBest OptionLots of special termsHuman (understands better)Simple, common wordsAI (can handle well)

Working with Other Tools

Check if it needs to work with other computer programs:

NeedBest OptionMust connect easilyAI (works well with other systems)Can be separateHuman (might need extra setup)

Keeping Info Safe

Think about how private the call info needs to be:

Privacy NeedBest OptionVery privateHuman (can be more careful)Normal privacyAI (needs good safety measures)

Combining AI and Human Transcription

Using both AI and human transcription together can give restaurants the best of both worlds. This mix helps get accurate, fast, and scalable results, which is great for projects that need both speed and correctness.

Here's how it works:

  1. AI does the first draft quickly
  2. People check and fix any mistakes

This team-up helps solve the problems of each method on its own.

How It Helps Restaurants

BenefitDescriptionHandle more callsAI can work on many calls at onceGet things rightPeople catch what AI missesKeep info safeHumans make sure private details stay privateWork with different languagesGood for restaurants with many types of customers

Making It Work Well

To use this mixed method:

  • Find out where AI works best
  • Let people focus on the hard parts
  • Check that the final writing is good

The Future of Call Transcription in Restaurants

As AI gets better, call transcription in restaurants will change a lot. This will affect how restaurants work and serve customers.

Better AI Systems

AI transcription will get:

  • More accurate
  • Faster
  • More efficient

This means restaurants can:

  • Handle more calls
  • Cut down wait times
  • Give better service to each customer

Voice AI in Restaurants

Voice AI is coming to restaurants. It will let customers:

  • Order food by talking
  • Ask questions easily

This new tech will help restaurants:

  • Take many orders at once
  • Make more money
  • Spend less on staff

New AI Features

AI will do more than just write down calls. It might:

  • Understand how customers feel
  • Suggest things customers might like
  • Help restaurants sell more

What This Means for Restaurants

BenefitHow It HelpsBetter serviceFaster responses, fewer mistakesMore salesAI can suggest extra items to buyLower costsLess need for people to answer phonesHappy customersQuick, easy ordering and answers

Restaurants that use AI for calls will do well as things change. It will help them work better, make customers happier, and grow their business.

Conclusion

Picking between AI and human call transcription for your restaurant depends on what you need. Here's a quick look at the main points:

FactorAI TranscriptionHuman TranscriptionSpeedVery fastSlowerAccuracyGood, but can make mistakesVery accurateCostCheaperMore expensiveUnderstanding contextNot as goodVery goodHandling many callsCan do lotsLimited by people available

To choose the best option:

  1. Think about how many calls you get
  2. Look at your budget
  3. Decide how accurate you need the transcripts to be
  4. Consider if you use special restaurant words
  5. Check if it needs to work with other computer programs
  6. Think about how private the call info needs to be

You might want to use both AI and human transcription together. This can give you the best of both:

  • AI does the first draft quickly
  • People check and fix any mistakes

This way, you get fast and accurate results.

FAQs

Is AI faster than humans in audio transcription?

Yes, AI is much faster than humans in transcribing audio. Here's a quick comparison:

Transcription MethodSpeed for 1-hour AudioAIMinutesHumanSeveral hours or days

What are AI transcription's main problems?

AI transcription has some key issues:

  • Trouble with context
  • Problems with accents
  • Difficulty with background noise
  • Possible errors in the text
  • Concerns about data privacy and security

Why do we still need humans for transcription?

Humans are still important for transcription because they:

  • Understand context better
  • Handle complex language well
  • Check and improve quality
  • Follow ethical rules
  • Keep information private

When is human transcription better?

Human transcription is best for:

  • Legal records
  • Medical notes
  • Private business meetings

These need to be very accurate and keep data safe.

Can AI transcribe different languages?

Yes, AI can work with many languages. Most AI transcription tools can:

  • Recognize various languages
  • Handle different accents
  • Transcribe content in multiple languages

Is human transcription more correct than AI?

Generally, yes. Humans are usually more accurate than AI, especially for:

  • Technical topics
  • Complex language
  • Situations needing context

Related posts

Try it yourself

Call Loman's Pizza

Enter your information in the form to receive a call from Loman and place an order like a customer would!